In numbers: The COVID-19 pandemic

Data | In the battle against COVID-19, severity of lockdown matters less than testing rates

Stranded people being screened at Chennai Central before boarding the Shramik Special to Manipur on May 10.   | Photo Credit: R. Ragu

It has been nearly a month and a half since India enforced a stringent lockdown to arrest the COVID19 outbreak. Cases have recently continued to rise in the country at a relatively fast pace, even as the lockdown has brought the economy to its knees.

There were other countries that also enforced stringent lockdowns in order to implement a physical distancing strategy that will halt the increase in COVID19 infections, but there were significant variances in testing rates conducted across such countries. How does higher testing, stringent lockdown, both or a lack of both influence outcomes across countries, is the question that we seek to answer in this Data Point article.

To measure which approach led to better outcomes, we analysed four parameters – tests per million population, stringency of the lockdown, case doubling time and volume of cases. The parameters were compared on three specific dates March 25, April 15 and May 4 (the dates on which India announced or extended its nation-wide lockdown) for 46 nations which had maintained consistent data in this period.

How to read the charts

The graphs plot tests conducted per million people against how stringent a country’s lockdown was as on March 25, April 15 and May 4. Each circle corresponds to a country. The colour red for the circle denotes a case doubling time of <16 days; yellow circle denotes a doubling time of 16-35 days; green circle denotes a doubling time of > 35 days on that date.

The size of the circles correspond to the absolute number of confirmed COVID-19 cases on that date. Stringency is calculated based on 17 indicators such as school closures and restrictions in movement. The index was created by the Oxford University (more details: bit.ly/3bhwiiv).

Doubling time is the estimated number of days it takes for the number of cases to double in a nation. Here the doubling time was considered for infection counts in the last ten days for the three dates. The higher the number of days, the fewer the new infections in a country.

A quadrant-wise breakdown

The charts are divided into 4 sections, based on the median numbers of both tests and the stringency index.

1. Top left: Relatively less stringent lockdown, more tests

2. Bottom left: Relatively less stringent lockdown, fewer tests

3. Top right: Relatively more stringent lockdown, more tests

4. Bottom right: Relatively more stringent lockdown, fewer tests

Graph 1: As of March 25

In the initial days, as the number of infections was low in most countries, the cases doubled within 15 days. Most of the nations were therefore in the “red” category with the exception of South Korea and Qatar.

Viewing in app? Click to see graph

Graph appears incomplete? Click to remove AMP mode.

Observations from graph 1

1. India belonged to section 4 (a more stringent lockdown, and fewer tests). Though cases were doubling faster as in other countries, the overall case load was still smaller compared to countries such as the U.S. and Italy.

2. The only country in green - South Korea - was in section 3 (a stringent lockdown and more tests conducted). This was an early sign that such an approach worked.

Graph 2: As of April 15

Viewing in app? Click to see graph

Observations from graph 2

1. It is interesting to note the approach taken by Iceland, Norway, Austria and Thailand, the four new countries which turned green and also kept the circle sizes smaller. Iceland conducted a very high number of tests and kept the lockdown relatively less stringent on both March 25 and April 15. Austria on March 25 had the second most stringent lockdown in the world but relaxed it later once the doubling time increased. It too conducted a relatively higher number of tests. Norway, on March 25, had one of the least stringent lockdowns but it increased the severity on April 25 despite keeping the case count low, while also conducting a relatively higher number of tests. In all these three cases, the approach towards stringency of lockdown varied but the higher number of tests remained a constant.

2. Thailand was the odd one out. It featured in section 2 (relatively less stringent lockdown, fewer tests) on both dates and still managed to keep the case count low and increased the doubling time.

3. India continued to be in section 4. The case count had increased a bit and it still remained in the red category (low doubling time).

A look at data as of May 4 throws in more clarity.

Graph 3: As of May 4

The graph on May 4 shows that more nations had successfully increased their doubling time and also kept the case count low. Circles coloured green appear in every section of the graph.

Viewing in app? Click to see graph

Observations from graph 3

1. Of the 15 nations in section 1, one is in red (6%), 10 are in green (66%).

2. Of the eight nations in section 3, two are in red (25%); four are in green (50%)

3. Of the 17 nations in section 4, eight are in red (47%); five are in green (29%).

3. Section 2 is unfit for analysis as Ethiopia has conducted very few tests and there are two few countries to come to a conclusion.

In sum, a higher share of countries in sections 1 and 3 increased the doubling time (turned green) than those in section 4. This indicates that the countries that tested more were able to reduce the infection growth rate better though the lockdown policy varied.

India, along with Bolivia, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Mexico continue to occupy the bottom most part of the section 4 on all three dates.  All these countries continue to be in the red category(low doubling time) with circle sizes (case load) consistently rising every passing day.

This comparative exercise across countries clearly illustrate the centrality of a higher testing rate of the population in curbing the COVID19 outbreak. Stringent lockdowns and mandated physical distancing might have lessened the case load and given a breather to the public health system, but this has not arrested the infection growth rates sufficiently in countries which have imposed them as they did not ramp up their testing rates relative to the rest of the world.


Our code of editorial values

Related Topics
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jul 25, 2021 10:46:06 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/data/data-in-the-battle-against-covid-19-severity-of-lockdown-matters-less-than-testing-rates/article31565369.ece

In This Series
Data | What is the COVID-19 vaccine policy of countries across the world?
Data | U.K. variant of the novel coronavirus spreads at least 50% faster than old variants
Data | U.S. bears the brunt of global COVID-19 deaths in December; Delhi, W.B. and Punjab record spurt in fatalities
Data | How India fared in various COVID-19 parameters since March, compared with other countries
Data | India's COVID-19 testing declines sharply despite rising positivity rate
From 0 new COVID-19 cases to 10,000 in six months: dissecting Kerala's second wave
Data | COVID-19 infections continue to grow at a constant pace in India
Data | Lower COVID-19 fatality rate in rural areas not necessarily due to lower share of co-morbidities among rural population
The Hindu Explains | Is COVID-19 intensifying in rural India?
Data | What's afoot on the COVID-19 vaccine front?
Data | COVID-19 deaths in India are rising third fastest in the world
Puducherry's pandemic trajectory shows the need for more testing
Data | India's COVID-19 cases are the fastest growing in the world
Data | Less reliable rapid antigen tests ramped up in many States
Coronavirus | In contrast to initial stages, districts now push tally in Tamil Nadu
Data | COVID-19 resurges in Kerala as migrants return, testing rate drops
Data | Overcrowded jails and the COVID-19 contagion
Data | Among nations with a high case load, infections continue to double in less than 20 days only in India
Understanding Chennai’s COVID-19 trend
Data | How do States fare on reporting COVID-19 data?
Data | Not just Mumbai and Chennai, COVID-19 cases are starting to swell in Cooch Behar and Ayodhya too
Data | Major uptick in COVID-19 cases in the past week and it's not just the usual suspects
Data | Coronavirus deaths increasing significantly in several States
Data | Domestic violence complaints at a 10-year high during COVID-19 lockdown
Data | A study of India's coronavirus cases: symptoms to secondary transmission
Data | Karnataka, Telangana, A.P. see sharp spike in COVID-19 cases; burden easing in Delhi
Data | COVID-19 has affected higher share of men in India, difference relatively lesser in other countries
Data | An estimated 12.2 crore Indians lost their jobs during the coronavirus lockdown in April: CMIE
Data | Sudden spike in cases results in fastest COVID-19 doubling rate in Punjab in the past week
Data | States which tested more in the initial days of the coronavirus outbreak found it easier to contain the spread
Data | Why handwashing and physical distancing are a privilege to the poor
Data | Migrant workers' distress continues as nationwide lockdown extended for the second time
Data | The variable impact of the novel coronavirus across different countries
Data | A State-wise comparison of coronavirus infection doubling rates and testing
Data | Kerala flattens the coronavirus curve but must remain vigilant as 'import' cases still dominate
Data | Why has Mumbai seen the most coronavirus cases in Maharashtra?
Data | Where are the coronavirus hotspots in India?
Data | The lockdown effect on jobs in India
Data | How quickly are coronavirus infections and deaths increasing in India, compared to the rest of the world?
Data | 96% migrant workers did not get rations from the government, 90% did not receive wages during lockdown: survey
Data | How fast are India's coronavirus cases doubling since the lockdown?
Data | Who gets tested for coronavirus determines infection rates better than how many are
Data | How many doctors and nurses have tested positive for coronavirus in India?
Data | India's coronavirus infection rates are among the highest in Asia
Data | From 129 to 430 districts in a month: how coronavirus cases are spreading thick and fast
COVID-19 | Under which zone does your district lie?
You are reading
Data | In the battle against COVID-19, severity of lockdown matters less than testing rates
Data | Are States testing enough compared to the size of their coronavirus outbreaks?
Data | Is India undercounting its COVID-19 deaths?
Data | The curious case of Gujarat's COVID-19 curve: remained flat throughout May
Data | Why is it necessary to test more to reduce the impact of COVID-19?
Data | The path to 5 lakh coronavirus cases: infections, fatalities spiralling; testing rate consistently coming down
Data | Most COVID-19 deaths occurred within two days of hospital admission in Chennai, Karnataka
Data | India's COVID-19 situation worst among Asian countries
Data | Japan's limited testing strategy for coronavirus does not yield in the long run
Data | Which States recorded the most coronavirus cases, deaths, and the best testing rates?
Data | To reduce coronavirus spread, India needs to test more, lockdown notwithstanding
Data | Who are the most vulnerable to the lockdown among urban dwellers
Coronavirus | Patient data from Singapore and South Korea shows physical distancing is the only option
Data | How prepared are India's States in health infrastructure to tackle COVID-19
Data | Kerala leads States in testing for coronavirus, Maharashtra in infections
Data | Where does India stand on the coronavirus curve?
Data | COVID-19 is deadliest for the elderly
Data | 5,680 flights cancelled: the coronavirus impact on global air travel
Data | Coronavirus death rates peak in Italy and Spain
Data | India's coronavirus testing rates are among the lowest in the world
Data | Govt. rarely passes on the benefit of falling crude oil price to consumers
The Disaster Response Force teams of Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation wearing protective gear and spray disinfectant chemical at medical shop amid concerns over the spread of the novel coronavirus, in Hyderabad on March 23, 2020.
COVID-19 | Interactive map of confirmed coronavirus cases in India
Data | Where does the March 9 market crash rank among the biggest falls in Sensex history?
Data | Is COVID-19 spreading faster outside mainland China?
Data | The wide, rapid spread of the novel coronavirus
Next Story