The Hindu CSDS-Lokniti Post-Poll Survey 2021

West Bengal Assembly Elections | Development mattered most, not corruption

A supporter of the Chief of Trinamool Congress (TMC) Mamata Banerjee, wearing a face shield with her image on it, gestures during celebrations after the initial poll results, in Kolkata, India, May 2, 2021.   | Photo Credit: Reuters

A common account given by journalists and scholars who travelled far and wide in West Bengal during the elections was about corruption and cut money. So what happened then that the ruling party still comfortably won the election? Was corruption not an issue? Or is it the case that it was an issue but not on the scale at which was being reported, and that other more bread and butter issues mattered far more? The post-poll data indicate that the case is the latter.

image/svg+xml % Development 33 Unemployment/jobs 9 Change/ Poriborton 5 Government performance 4 Electricity/water 4 Status quo 3 State govt’s welfare schemes 2 Condition of roads/bridges 2 Corruption/extortion/cut money 2 Poverty/hunger/fnancial problem 1 Other issues (<1% each) 13 No response 23 Note: Figures are percentages and may not add up to 100 due to rounding. Table 1: Development and unemployment were the top issues; corruption was not much of an issue despite media narrative
 

When we asked voters in the survey what the single most important issue had been for them while voting, corruption figured way down in the list of issues at the seventh spot — only 2% of our 4,200+ respondents said it had been a consideration for them while deciding whom to vote for (Table 1). What mattered most instead to voters was the larger issue of development. One-third (33%) said development or the desire for more of it is what determined their vote.

image/svg+xml Voted AITC Voted BJP TMC govt is.. Very corrupt (23%) 9 75 Somewhat corrupt (33%) 43 41 Not at all corrupt (26%) 81 10 No response (18%) 60 25 TMC has a lot of corruption.. Agree (51%) 26 58 Disagre (30%) 77 13 No response (19%) 61 23 Agree that TMC workers/ leaders intimidate people (38%) 22 62 Disagree that TMC workers/leaders intimidate people (39%) 69 20 No response (23%) 56 30 Table 2: Many of those who saw the TMC as corrupt and intimidating still voted for the party, especially those who held a more moderate view about it
 

Data further indicate that those who voted on the basis of development and related issues such as government performance, water and electricity, roads and welfare schemes voted overwhelmingly for the Trinamool Congress. The BJP secured most of the votes of those for whom unemployment, poriborton and corruption were issues. The problem for the BJP, however, was that there were not enough people basing their vote on these issues.

We must stress here that it is not that corruption was not a concern for voters. It was. It is just that it was not a major one. Most voters opened up about the issue only when we asked them specifically about it. For instance, on being asked about how corrupt the Trinamool government was in their opinion, one-fourth (23%) described it as being very corrupt, one-third (33%) as somewhat corrupt and another one-fourth (26%) as not at all corrupt with the rest being ambivalent (Table 2). Similarly, a little over half (51%) agreed with the statement that there was a lot of corruption in the Trinamool as a party.

But even with respect to these findings there are two caveats that need to be added — one that these figures were not unprecedented in any way and were in fact quite similar to the figures received on the same questions asked in the 2016 and 2011 surveys with respect to the Trinamool Congress and the CPI(M). Secondly, even though many voters held the Trinamool to be corrupt, when we look at how they actually ended up voting, we find that their vote did not overwhelmingly fall in the lap of the BJP (Table 2). On the other hand many of those who viewed the Trinamool as being moderately corrupt or remained ambivalent on the questions, voted mostly for the Trinamool. It was therefore a matter of degrees and this is where journalistic ground reports seem to have got it wrong.

(The author is a Research Associate at Lokniti-CSDS, Delhi.)


Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jun 18, 2021 5:00:50 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/elections/west-bengal-assembly/csds-lokniti-survey-development-mattered-most-not-corruption/article34493110.ece

In This Package
Assam Assembly Elections | Hindu consolidation pays off for BJP
Assam Assembly Elections | Mahajot fails to net tribal votes
Assam Assembly Elections | Beyond community vote, urban, middle class voters back NDA
Assam Assembly Elections | Sonowal scores higher than Sarma, despite the latter making steady gains
Huge win: BJP supporters celebrating at the party's State head office in Guwahati on May 2, 2021.
Assam Assembly elections | Welfare measures not a decisive factor
Assam Assembly elections | CAA, NRC evoke mixed sentiments
Kerala Assembly Elections | How the Left Front bucked a decades-old trend in Kerala
Kerala Assembly Elections | Votes for tackling the coronavirus
Kerala Assembly Elections | Social demographics shaped the elections
Kerala Assembly Elections | Not ready for a third force
Kerala Assembly Elections | Sabarimala did not become an electoral issue
Kerala Assembly Elections | A shift in social basis of voting
West Bengal Assembly Elections | The limits to polarisation in Bengal
You are reading
West Bengal Assembly Elections | Development mattered most, not corruption
West Bengal Assembly Elections | Women rally behind Trinamool
West Bengal Assembly Elections | Subaltern Hindutva on the wane?
West Bengal Assembly Elections | BJP failed to attract Congress, Left supporters
West Bengal Assembly Elections | Longest elections did not help BJP
What post-poll numbers tell us about the elections, and how our politics is evolving | The Hindu In Focus Podcast
Tamil Nadu Assembly Elections | The caste calculus in DMK’s win
Tamil Nadu Assembly elections | A silent yearning for an alternative force?
Tamil Nadu Assembly elections | The impact of social factors
Local factors determine electoral outcomes in States
Local issues crucial to voters across States: survey
Tamil Nadu Assembly Elections | The land of the rising sun
T.N. Assembly polls | BJP: a liability rather than asset
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Edappadi K. Palaniswami and Deputy Chief Minister O. Panneerselvam. File
TN Assembly polls | Did last-minute sops help the AIADMK?
Tamil Nadu Assembly polls | Leadership play a key role
Tamil Nadu Assembly polls | Methodology of post-poll survey
Next Story