Manipur violence updates | 60 Meitei people leave Mizoram fearing outrage; fifth accused arrested in sexual assault case

A 26-second video that surfaced on July 19 showed the two women stripped naked, groped by a violent mob and taken towards a paddy field on May 4, sparking nationwide outrage

Updated - July 22, 2023 07:58 pm IST

Published - July 22, 2023 10:09 am IST

Women's wing of the Indigenous Tribal Leaders' Forum (ITLF) stage a protest near the 'Wall of Remembrance' erected to honor lives lost during the ongoing ethnic violence in the State, in Churachandpur, on July 22, 2023

Women's wing of the Indigenous Tribal Leaders' Forum (ITLF) stage a protest near the 'Wall of Remembrance' erected to honor lives lost during the ongoing ethnic violence in the State, in Churachandpur, on July 22, 2023 | Photo Credit: PTI

The Manipur Police have arrested the fifth accused in connection with the video that surfaced on July 19 showing two women being paraded naked by a mob in the strife-torn State. The accused has been identified as a 19-year-old.

Also read | Social media platforms told to censor posts on Manipur video

As the chorus of protests against the sexual assault of two women in Manipur grew louder, the arrested men were remanded in 11-day police custody on July 21 while the house of another suspect was set on fire by angry locals in the second such incident in connection with the case.

Amid the stalemate in Parliament over holding a debate on Manipur violence, MPs of various opposition parties have planned a protest on July 24 near Mahatma Gandhi’s statue in the Parliament complex to press for the Prime Minister’s statement on the issue in both houses.

Also read | SC ‘deeply disturbed’ by Manipur video, orders Centre, State govt. to act

A 26-second video that surfaced on Wednesday and went viral showed the two women stripped naked, groped by a violent mob and taken towards a paddy field on May 4, a day after violence erupted in the northeastern State, sparking a nationwide outrage.

  • July 22, 2023 19:51
    Will present our view on Manipur incident in Parliament, says Union Minister Rijiju

    The Centre will present facts on the Manipur incident in the Parliament, Union Minister for Earth Sciences Kiren Rijiju said in Chennai on Saturday and declined to speak on the viral video that showed two women being paraded in the north eastern state. Refusing to be drawn into any controversy over the May 4 incident that took place in Kangpokpi district, he indicated that it would be inappropriate to discuss the issue outside the Parliament.

    “Whatever matters are to be discussed in the Parliament we will present our point of view. But right now, I can’t say anything outside on the matter,” Mr. Rijiju told reporters here when his comments on the issue were sought.

    “I have come here (today) for the Rozgar Mela. I will not make any (other) comments,” the minister further said. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 19:50
    Students from Manipur University urge authorities to transfer them to other varsities

    A group of students from Manipur University has written to authorities demanding they be transferred to other central varsities due to the prevailing situation in the north eastern state, Delhi Congress chief Anil Kumar said on Saturday.

    The group of 99 students, who hail from Delhi and other parts of the country, met the Delhi Congress president on Saturday and conveyed their concerns. “A group of 99 students has written a letter to the authorities, demanding they be transferred to other central universities. The reason they have written this letter is because the Manipur situation is not going to improve anytime soon,” Mr. Kumar said.

    The students said their parents are not willing to send them back and neither can they opt for online method of studying due to unavailability of internet. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 19:48
    Manipur incident is sad: BJP MP Brij Bhushan

    Outgoing Wrestling Federation of India President Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh, who is on bail in connection with a sexual harassment case filed by women wrestlers, said that the recent incident in Manipur is condemnable as well as called it a sad incident in independent India.

    In a recent incident in Manipur, two women were paraded naked and sexually assaulted before being set free by the mob comprising the majority community. The incident allegedly took place on May 4, a day after ethnic clashes broke out in Manipur.

    “The situation in Manipur was difficult. Union Home Minister Amit Shah also camped there...The Manipur incident is very sad. This is a very sad incident which has happened in Independent India. Prime Minister has taken cognisance of the matter. He has also made remarks on the matter. I condemn this incident,” Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh said while speaking to media. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 18:29
    Violence in Manipur caused by ‘vicious agenda’ of communal forces, says Kerala CM

    Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan on Saturday termed the accounts of violence emerging from Manipur as “horrifying” and alleged that the ongoing strife in the northeastern state was caused by the “vicious agenda of fuelling communal tensions”. All secular and democratic forces should demand the restoration of peace and normalcy in Manipur, he urged through his social media handles. “Horrifying accounts of violence from #Manipur have shattered the conscience of every Indian. The ongoing strife in the state is caused by the vicious agenda of fueling communal tensions. All secular & democratic forces should demand the restoration of peace & normalcy in Manipur,” he tweeted.

    In a detailed Facebook post, the CPI(M) veteran said the ethnic violence, which has been continuing in Manipur for more than two months, can be viewed only with apprehension.

    Horrifying visuals that haunt human consciousness keep coming from that state, he said adding that the women belonging to the Kuki community were hunted down by the mob of rioters in the most despicable and brutal manners.

    Charging that a deliberate attempt to target the Christian community is happening in Manipur, Mr. Vijayan, a member of the CPI(M) politburo, said the churches of the tribal communities are widely attacked and destroyed there.

    He accused the Sangh Parivar of having an agenda to turn the state into a riot zone for the sake of power politics and urged the secular community in the country to realise this.

    The BJP-led Union government’s silence on the issue and the Sangh Parivar agenda behind the violence have been strongly criticised in the country now, he said.

    It is the duty of the people believing in democratic principles to resist and defeat such deliberate attempts to strengthen communal polarisation, the Chief Minister added. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 18:11
    Northeastern gender activists call for action against perpetrators

    Gender activists from all the Northeastern states have called for action against the perpetrators of sexual assault but without politicising the issue.

    The incident that came to light via the viral video is “shocking, unfortunate and a gross violation of human rights,” Manipur gender activist and secretary of Women Action for Development (WAD) Sobita Mangsatabam told PTI.

    “In a conflict situation, it is the women and children who are used as weapons and the same is happening in Manipur. The state has a long history of violence against women and children, but it is a sad state-of-affairs that they receive no justice,” she said.

    The state is suffering from a crisis for nearly three months but it took a ‘‘shocking viral video for Prime Minister Narendra Modi to speak. Besides this incident, he did not say a word about the sufferings of the people in the state who have lost their families, homes and are living in distress in relief camps since violence broke out,” she said.

    “Action must be taken against the perpetrators of crimes against women but it should also be ensured that those women whose human rights have been violated are not again subjected to humiliation with such videos being widely circulated,” the activist said.

    Ms. Mangsatabam also appealed to the authorities not to politicise the issue.

    Associations demand justice

    The Mizoram State Commission for Women (MSCW), the Arunachal Pradesh Women’s Welfare Society (APWWS) and Naga Mother’s Association (NMA) have also written to the National Commission of Women (NCW) and the Manipur government demanding justice for the victims and a safe environment for all women and vulnerable communities.

    MSCW chairperson Lallawmchhungi also appealed to the authorities to stop all kinds of violence against women and ‘‘request all males in the NE states and India as a whole not to use muscle power against women in different forms of violence by taking advantage of such crises situations.” APWWS president Kani Nada Maling told PTI that the authorities must ensure justice swiftly so that such acts are not repeated.

    This particular incident would not have occurred had the central government taken action on time as “unrest in the state has been ongoing and the people of Manipur have been left crying since the first week of May.” “This incident, however, should not be used as a tool by any political party to gain sympathy. It is a human rights issue and failure of the present government to provide safety to women. We cannot sit as mute spectators when our sisters are raped but dealing with such sensitive cases, we must ensure peace and tranquility in society,” Ms. Maling said.

    The Naga Mothers Association, in their letter to the NCW chairperson, called for her immediate intervention into the violent crimes against women in the ongoing Manipur violence.

    “It is a matter of shame that women and young girls have been made the target and are subjected to merciless violence, include rape and killings,” the letter stated.

    ‘Government institutions remained mute’

    The North East Network (Assam, Meghalaya and Nagaland chapters) said that the government institutions mandated to provide safety to women remained mute spectators despite complaints and statements by the women and affected communities.

    It is one state which is witnessing such violent crimes today but similar crimes against women continue unabated in every community, in homes, workplaces and public spaces across the country, NEN spokesperson Anurita Pathak Hazarika told PTI.

    “As the conflict rages, women continue to bear the brunt, sandwiched between state and non-state actors. The targeted gendered attack on the two women and more such sexual crimes reveal a picture of failed governance and lack of a political public consciousness to treat its women as equal rights holders, and not just as victims,” she added. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 17:49
    MWSAP, ALSF to hold blood donation camp for people of violence-hit Manipur

    The Manipur Welfare Society of Arunachal Pradesh (MWSAP) and Arunachal Life Saving Foundation (ALSF) on Saturday announced a three-day mega blood donation camp for the people of violence-hit Manipur.

    The blood donation camp would be organised from August 8 to 10 in collaboration with the state health department and Ramakrishna Mission Hospital (RKMH) in Itanagar, Arunachal Life Saving Foundation chairman Ramesh Jeke told reporters at Press Club, Itanagar. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 17:25
    Ongoing strife in Manipur is caused by the vicious agenda of fueling communal tensions: Kerala Chief Minister
  • July 22, 2023 17:17
    National Federation of Indian Women stage demonstration in Chennai, condemning BJP government

    Members of National Federation of Indian Women staged protest against violence in Manipur by tying black ribbon around the mouth at Panagal Maligai in Saidapet on Saturday.

    The National Federation of Indian Women’s (NFIW) general secretary, Annie Raja, on Saturday, led a demonstration with the participation of members of other frontal organisations of the Communist Party of India (CPI), condemning the BJP-led Central government and and the State government in Manipur, for allowing the situation to escalate in the violence-hit Northeastern State, and for the brutality perpetrated on the women in Manipur.

    Read more here...

  • July 22, 2023 17:14
    Tribal belt in Gujarat to observe bandh on July 23; Congress extends support

    A bandh will be observed in the tribal belt of Gujarat on Sunday in protest against the ethnic violence and atrocities on women in Manipur, a tribal leader said.

    The opposition Congress has decided to support the bandh in protest against the ruling BJP’s “failure” to control the situation in the north-eastern State, a party spokesperson said on Saturday.

    Several tribal outfits, including Adivasi Ekta Manch, have come together to call for a shutdown in the tribal-dominated districts of Gujarat.

    “On Sunday, a bandh will be observed in the tribal belt in Gujarat as per the call given by the tribal community to protest against violence and atrocities against women in Manipur; Madhya Pradesh urination incident, and atrocities on tribals in Gujarat,” said tribal leader Praful Vasava, who recently resigned from Aam Aadmi Party (AAP).

    He said the call for a shutdown is not announced under the banner of any single organisation or a political party but with the consensus of various tribal and other socio-political organisations.

    - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 16:35
    “PM Modi, Manipur CM not willing to accept accountability over Manipur”: TMC Minister Shashi Panja

    Trinamool Congress MLA and West Bengal Women and Child Welfare Development Minister, Shashi Panja, on Saturday voiced concern over the Manipur viral video, asking Prime Minister Narendra Modi to clear his stand on the incident.

    Speaking to reporters on Saturday, Panja said, “Yesterday, from the podium of our July 21 rally, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and (MP) Abhishek Banerjee cleared our state on the Manipur incident. We had been tracking events in Manipur over the past 88 days, waiting for the PM to speak up. It wasn’t until the day before yesterday that he finally opened up on Manipur, making a brief statement expressing his sorrow (over the viral video). We demand that all other listed businesses in Parliament be suspended or set aside and the PM make his stand clear on the Manipur issue.”

    - ANI

  • July 22, 2023 16:18
    Manipur incident is very unfortunate and reprehensible: Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh

    The outgoing Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) chief Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh is currently out on bail in a case of sexual harassment that has been filed against him and suspended WFI assistant secretary Vinod Tomar by six women wrestlers.

  • July 22, 2023 15:55
    Opposition MPs to hold protest in Parliament complex on Monday to press for PM’s statement on Manipur

    Amid the stalemate in Parliament over holding a debate on Manipur violence, MPs of various opposition parties have planned a protest on Monday near Mahatma Gandhi’s statue in the Parliament complex to press for the Prime Minister’s statement on the issue in both houses.

    Sources said leaders of various opposition parties who have now formed the INDIA alliance will meet in the chamber of Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge and will discuss their further strategy in Parliament.

    After the meeting at 10 AM on Monday, July 24, the leaders will hold a protest near the Gandhi statue before entering both houses.

    The government has agreed to hold a short-duration discussion on the Manipur issue with the Home Minister replying to it, but the opposition is adamant on its demand for the Prime Minister’s statement first, especially after a video of two women being paraded naked and assaulted in a Manipur village appeared on social media.

    Also, the opposition wants a debate allowing all parties to speak without any time restrictions and has been holding protests on the issue since the Monsoon Session started on Thursday.

    - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 15:23
    At least 60 Meitei people leave Mizoram fearing outrage over May 4 incident

    Fearing a backlash after the outrage over the incident of two Kuki women being paraded naked by a mob in Manipur on May 4, some 60 Meitei people left Mizoram’s Aizawl by flight on July 22, many said to have left for Assam by bus/taxi

  • July 22, 2023 14:44
    Meghalaya women’s commission demands action in Manipur video incident

    The Meghalaya State Commission for Women on Saturday urged the Centre and the Manipur government to take immediate action against those involved in the incident of two women being paraded naked in the ethnic strife-torn State.

    The commission also appealed to authorities concerned in Manipur to ensure that all victims of the ethnic clash there are given the necessary help and rehabilitation.

    “We urge the Centre and the Manipur government to take immediate action against those involved in the horrific act of human depravity that threatens the dignity and safety of every woman and child of the nation,” the commission said in a statement.

    The women’s commission in Meghalaya also said any attack on a woman’s modesty is not acceptable in a democracy.

    “We are saddened to see this gross violation of human rights, especially of minorities and the vulnerable,” it said.

    - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 14:31
    BJP should have asked the Manipur CM to step down: Tamil Nadu Finance Minister Thangam Thennarasu
  • July 22, 2023 14:16
    Rajasthan CM Gehlot says PM Modi visiting poll-bound States but not Manipur

    Rajasthan Chief Minister, Ashok Gehlot, on Saturday launched a scathing attack on Prime Minister Narendra Modi, accusing him of refraining from visiting violence-hit Manipur.

    “For the first time, I have seen that a Prime Minister is visiting Karnataka, Rajasthan and other places for elections, but not Manipur. It is his government in Manipur, just imagine what would he have said if it was a Congress government there,” CM Gehlot said while speaking to the media at his residence in Jaipur.

    The Senior Congress leader also criticised PM Modi for allegedly making a reference to incidents in Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh while commenting on a video of women being paraded naked and molested in Manipur and said that Modi’s remark has hurt the sentiments of Rajasthan.

    - ANI

  • July 22, 2023 14:10
    Editorial | Belated outrage: On the Manipur violence and the top political response

    After two and a half months of widespread and continuing violence in Manipur, which included a conflagration in early May, Prime Minister Narendra Modi finally broke his silence, after video images of tribal women being paraded naked in Thoubal district on May 4 once again showed up the heinous nature of the conflict in the State.

    Read the full editorial here...
  • July 22, 2023 13:55
    Women’s Associations lead protests in Tamil Nadu districts against violence in Manipur

    Members of National Federation of Indian Women staged protest against violence in Manipur by tying black ribbon around the mouth at Panagal Maligai in Saidapet on Saturday.

    All India Democratic Womens Association members staging a protest against the violence in Manipur in front of the collector office in Udhagamandalam on Saturday.

  • July 22, 2023 13:52
    Movie named ‘Manipur Files’ should be made: Sena (UBT)

    Slamming the BJP governments at the Centre as well as in Manipur over the ethnic violence in the State, the Shiv Sena (UBT) on Saturday said a movie titled ‘Manipur Files’ should be made.

    Attacking Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Manipur Chief Minister N Biren Singh, an editorial in Sena (UBT) organ ‘Saamana’ said the violence and atrocities in the north-eastern State are worse than Kashmir.

    In recent times, Saamana said, movies like the ‘Tashkent Files’, ‘The Kerala Story’, and ‘The Kashmir Files’ have been made.

    “The same people should now make a movie named ‘Manipur Files’ on the violence in the State,” it said.

    The party said had there been a non-BJP government in the State, it would have been dismissed by now.

    - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 13:02
    Protests under way in Imphal
  • July 22, 2023 12:59
    Cannot let tribals in Manipur be treated in barbaric way: Jharkhand CM to President Murmu

    Jharkhand Chief Minister Hemant Soren on Saturday wrote to President Droupadi Murmu, expressing his anguish over the “unspeakable torture” of women in violence-hit Manipur and urged her to take steps to ensure peace in the northeastern state. The country cannot let tribals in Manipur be treated in a “barbaric way”, he said in the letter days after a video of women being paraded naked in the northeastern state surfaced.

    “Silence in the face of cruelty is a terrible crime and so I am compelled today to write to you with a heavy heart and profound anguish over the ongoing spate of violence in the state of Manipur...I am deeply distressed and concerned about the spiralling situation in Manipur... unspeakable torture and sexual exploitation of women....” Manipur is “burning for two months, heart-wrenching videos are surfacing” and there is an “unparalleled breakdown of democratic governance” in the northeastern State, Mr. Soren said in the letter.

  • July 22, 2023 12:11
    Cops arrest fifth accused in women disrobing case

    Police have arrested the fifth accused in connection with the video that surfaced on July 19 showing two women being paraded naked by a mob in strife-torn Manipur, police said. The accused has been identified as a 19-year-old, police said.

    The four who were earlier nabbed for disrobing and parading two women in Manipur on May 4 were remanded to 11-day police custody on Friday, police said. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 11:55
    Manipur Naga groups demand immediate justice for women paraded naked

    Several Naga civil society organisations in Manipur, including the powerful United Naga Council, All Naga Students’ Association Manipur (ANSAM) and Naga People’s Front, have strongly condemned the inhuman act committed against the two women by a mob on May 4.

    The UNC asked the Manipur government to take up the case in a fast-track court to deliver justice instantly.

    “The government must initiate necessary steps for immediate booking of all the people involved in such dehumanizing crime,” the UNC said in a statement. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 11:43
    Two tribal women stripped naked, tortured in Bengal: BJP

    The BJP alleged on July 22 that two tribal women were stripped naked and tortured a few days ago in West Bengal while police remained a “mute spectator”. In a Twitter post, BJP’s I-T department head Amit Malviya, who is also the party’s co-incharge for the State, said the incident took place in Malda on July 19, with a “frenzied mob baying for her blood”.

    “It had all the making of a tragedy that should have ‘broken’ Mamata Banerjee’s heart and she, instead of merely outraging, could have acted, since she is also the home minister of Bengal,” he said, attacking the State’s chief minister who has been strident in criticising the Manipur incident.

    With Opposition parties targeting the BJP over the incident of two women being paraded naked in ethnic violence-hit Manipur, where it is in power, the party has been highlighting similar cases of atrocities against women in States ruled by its rivals such as the Congress and the Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress.

    Read more here...
  • July 22, 2023 10:45
    Only way forward is to sack CM, impose President’s rule: Sibal

    Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal on July 22 said the only way forward in Manipur is to sack Chief Minister N. Biren Singh and impose President’s rule in the State.

    “The only way forward: Sack Biren Singh; Impose Art. 356; Apologise to the women of our country.” “Nothing has changed since Nirbhaya: Unnao, Hatharas, Kathua, Bilkis (convicts release). Beti bachao PM ji!” Mr. Sibal tweeted.

    More than 160 people have lost their lives, and several have been injured since ethnic violence broke out in the state on May 3 when a ‘Tribal Solidarity March’ was organised in the hill districts to protest against the Meitei community’s demand for Scheduled Tribe (ST) status.

  • July 22, 2023 10:38
    ‘Barbaric, shameful’, say Manipur personalities on sexual violence video

    Eminent personalities of Manipur have denounced the naked parading of two women in Manipur, which has created outrage in the nation after the video on it went viral on social media.

    The personalities - ranging from a film maker, musician, academician to an entrepreneur - have termed the incident as “barbaric, shameful and against the human race” and demanded “strictest” punishment for the culprits.

    “It is an utterly barbaric and shameful incident against the human race. There is no word to express the shock of it,” National Award winning filmmaker Haobam Paban Kumar told PTI.

  • July 22, 2023 10:26
    Social media platforms told to censor posts on Manipur video

    The Central government has ordered social media platforms to censor all posts featuring the viral clip of two Manipur women paraded naked and sexually abused in Manipur.

    The sweep of the orders was wide, with immediate compliance from Twitter, Google, and Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram; the posts deleted include discussions that featured blacked out or blurred screenshots of the clip where it was not possible to identify the victim.

    Read more...
  • July 22, 2023 10:18
    DCW chief writes to Manipur DGP for visit to state racked by ethnic violence

    Delhi Commission For Women chief Swati Maliwal on July 21 wrote to DGP Manipur on her plans to visit the strife-torn State in the wake of surfacing of a video that showed two women being paraded naked by members of a rival tribe.

    In her letter to Manipur DGP, she said she plans to visit the State on July 23 to assess the situation there and submit a fact-finding report.

    Ms. Maliwal had on Thursday written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi too, urging him to take steps in the matter.

  • July 22, 2023 10:11
    More cases of women being assaulted surface in Manipur

    Two days after three women were disrobed and paraded naked, one of whom was raped, in Manipur’s Thoubal district, a 45-year-old woman was stripped and set ablaze in Imphal East on May 6. A photo of the charred body of the woman has now surfaced on social media.

    The incidents are among a series of crimes committed against women since ethnic violence erupted in the State on May 3. After the video of the Thoubal incident went viral this week, despite an Internet ban that has been imposed in the State, four accused were arrested.

    Read more here...
  • July 22, 2023 10:08
    Govt not serious about debate on Manipur in Parliament: Congress

    The Congress on July 21 accused the government of not being serious on having a debate on the situation in Manipur and demanded that President Droupadi Murmu exercise her powers to dismiss the State government.

    Addressing a press conference at the party headquarters, Congress deputy leader in Rajya Sabha Pramod Tiwari said the government wants to merely do a formality of holding a short duration debate on Manipur with restrictions of time while the Opposition demanded a debate without any time limit so that everyone could express themselves.

    “Who is running away from a discussion. They want to make it a formality. I challenge the government, if they are serious, they should start a debate on Monday morning itself. The debate should carry on indefinitely till all parties express their views, including the treasury benches. We want the prime minister to give his statement on Manipur in Parliament,” he said. - PTI

  • July 22, 2023 09:59
    Four accused in Manipur video case sent to 11-day police custody

    As the chorus of protests against the sexual assault of two women in Manipur grew louder, the four arrested men were remanded in 11-day police custody on Friday while the house of another suspect was set on fire by angry locals in the second such incident in connection with the case.

  • July 22, 2023 09:58
    TMC accuses BJP of stalling Parliament, demands PM open debate on Manipur violence

    TMC MP Derek O’Brien has alleged that the BJP was stalling Parliament proceedings and demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi open the debate on the Manipur issue either in Rajya Sabha or Lok Sabha.

    “It is the BJP that is stalling #Parliament. Let’s start the discussion on Manipur on Monday morning at 11 am sharp. Let the PM decide where he wishes to OPEN THE DISCUSSION. His choice. Lok Sabha or Rajya Sabha. Of course we will then all participate,” Mr. O’Brien, the TMC’s parliamentary leader in Rajya Sabha, tweeted.

0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in

Comments

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.