The seven days of jallikattu protests

For Centre and T.N., the options are tricky but worth a try

Protesters continue to throng the Marina beach promenade where thousands are streaming in to protest the ban on jallikattu. Families with children in tow were a sight on the waterfront on Thusday night.

Protesters continue to throng the Marina beach promenade where thousands are streaming in to protest the ban on jallikattu. Families with children in tow were a sight on the waterfront on Thusday night.   | Photo Credit: R. Ragu

As Tamil Nadu witnesses a popular upsurge in favour of jallikattu, the State government is under pressure to find legal means to ensure that the traditional event banned by the Supreme Court is revived soon.

The Centre’s January 7, 2016, notification — introducing some regulations and exempting it from statutory restrictions on the use of bulls as performing animals — was stayed by the Supreme Court. The final verdict is yet to be pronounced. Against this backdrop, what are the legal options that the State and Central governments could explore, and what is the flip side of these options?

Option 1: It is quite apparent that only an amendment to the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (PCA) is the way out. The most immediate way to do this is for the Centre to promulgate an ordinance incorporating the regulatory features of its earlier executive notification in the parent law itself. It may also remove ‘bulls’ from the list of animals that cannot be used in performances.

Drawback: The Supreme Court may take a dim view of the ordinance as an attempt to circumvent its 2014 verdict holding that the conduct of jallikattu itself amounts to cruelty as defined in the PCA. The Centre, which drew the court’s wrath last year itself when the notification was challenged, may be reluctant to take such a step.

Option 2: The State may request the Union government to permit it to promulgate an ordinance to introduce a Tamil Nadu-specific amendment to the PCA. As ‘prevention of cruelty to animals’ falls under Entry 17 of the Concurrent List, the State Assembly may amend the central law, subject to the President’s assent. Under Article 213 of the Constitution, the State Governor may promulgate an ordinance on a subject in the Central list with the prior assent of the President. This amendment may seek to exempt jallikattu as an event based on tradition and custom, subject to regulation, from the PCA’s purview.

Drawback: The Union government will have to advise the President to grant assent, and therefore, in terms of how it would be viewed by the court, there is no difference between helping TN issue an ordinance and promulgating the ordinance on its own. The court may also view the amendment as contrary to the main objectives of the PCA.

Option 3: The State may await the Supreme Court’s verdict on the validity of the January 2016 notification and give an assurance to the agitators that it would thereafter, in the event of an adverse order, enact a State amendment in the Assembly and refer it to the Centre for the President’s assent.

Drawback: This option would mean a politically costly delay and may not find favour with the protesters.

Why you should pay for quality journalism - Click to know more

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Feb 19, 2020 11:24:30 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/For-Centre-and-T.N.-the-options-are-tricky-but-worth-a-try/article17063859.ece

In This Package
The end of a protest
The sea of enthusiastic protesters on the Marina.
Anatomy of a protest
Centre says it is monitoring situation in Tamil Nadu
Chennai streets turn a battleground
Pro-jallikattu protests in Coimbatore end with agitation, violence
WhatsApp message from Ukraine triggered the Tamukkam protest
Train services through Madurai junction resume
Rail blockade earned wrath of people: Chamber
Protest for jallikattu at Tamukkam ends
Jallikattu protests end on peaceful note
Public transport in Chennai grinds to a halt
Violence forces schools, colleges close early
Stir at Alanganallur ends with violence
Violence breaks out in Alanganallur after eviction of protesters
Jallikattu protesters firm on permanent solution
Supporters of Jallikattu stage a demonstration with National Flags outside of Tamukkam grounds in connection with Jallikattu issue in Madurai on Monday.
Policeman on duty killed by bull at jallikattu in village of Virudhunagar district; Assembly passes Bill
Indications were clear that event couldn’t be held at Alanganallur
Protesters put up stiff resistance in Coimbatore
A movement to reclaim Tamil pride
Software companies in Mysuru join pro-jallikattu protest
Rajnath assures action on promulgation of jallikattu ordinance
List of cancelled and diverted train services
SC agrees to Centre’s plea to delay Jallikattu verdict
Tamil Nadu to take ordinance route for conducting Jallikattu
Political parties support bandh call
Seven students faint
Lorries to stay off roads
Hotels, shops to down shutters
Residents stage agitations
Apolitical groups extend solidarity as protest enters third day
Vaiko
‘Youths’ protest will script resounding victory’
Women show up in large numbers at protest
A show of strength and solidarity
Tamil Nadu to shut down today
A.R. Rahman and Viswanathan Anand.
Celebrities lend star power
Ramadoss marches towards PM’s residence, detained
Sasikala’s claims are misleading, says PETA
TNAU Management Board member resigns
‘From sport, jallikattu has transformed into cultural identity’
You are reading
Protesters continue to throng the Marina beach promenade where thousands are streaming in to protest the ban on jallikattu. Families with children in tow were a sight on the waterfront on Thusday night.
For Centre and T.N., the options are tricky but worth a try
Alanganallur unmoved by CM’s Delhi visit
Lawyers’ fora call for court boycott
Centre is anti-Tamil: Opposition
PIL against policeexcess dismissed
Tamil Nadu to shut down today
All traders in Madurai to down shutters today
Southern Railway cancels trains
Students’ protest attracts more crowd at Tamukkam
Traffic thrown out of gear for second day in Chennai
Techies protesting in between shifts, after work
Attorney-General Mukul Rohatgi
TN can enact law to treat jallikattu as traditional sport: Rohatgi
As jallikattu protests snowball, TN to shut down
Celebrities welcome, till they grab the mike
Naam Tamilar Katchi cadre climb up mobile tower
Thousands of passengers stranded as trains stop at Dindigul
Jallikattu protesters get more backing
Jallikattu ban: Students force train to a halt in Madurai
Students’ protests attract more crowds
‘Protest will not end till a bull runs on to the ring’
Jallikattu: MHA awaits reply from Environment Ministry
Cannot direct Centre, TN to frame special law on jallikattu: HC
Govt would reach decision on jallikattu by weekend: Dave
A simmering resentment
The bull is trending
When two eras overlap
Jallikattu protest: Changes in train timings
More people throng pro-jallikattu protest venue
Jallikattu protests
The limits to popular sentiment
Jallikattu: protests continue in Kancheepuram
Protest rocks Tiruchi, Thanjavur districts
Closure of college: Students hold talk with management
Ban PETA, say protesters
Traffic hit on many roads
College students join protest for jallikattu in Vellore
Protests continue in Tiruvannamalai
Students show solidarity with jallikattu supporters
Thousands gather at Tamukkam demanding jallikattu
Seeman
Seeman begins separate protest
Protest for ‘jallikattu’ gains greater momentum
Protest on Marina brings traffic to a standstill
Stir intensifies at Alanganallur
Protests for jallikattu spread far and wide
Next Story