Economy

Coronavirus | Pandemic fallout revives talk of universal basic income

A homeless encampment is seen near a dried up river bed in Stockton, California on February 7, 2020. The city went bankrupt in 2012 but has been recovering and recently began an 18-month trial run of universal basic income. The scoffed-at idea of paying everyone a basic income as machines take people’s jobs is getting a fresh look as a possible remedy for economies cratered by the coronavirus pandemic.

A homeless encampment is seen near a dried up river bed in Stockton, California on February 7, 2020. The city went bankrupt in 2012 but has been recovering and recently began an 18-month trial run of universal basic income. The scoffed-at idea of paying everyone a basic income as machines take people’s jobs is getting a fresh look as a possible remedy for economies cratered by the coronavirus pandemic.   | Photo Credit: AFP

The massive recovery package being considered in the U.S. Congress to offset the tremendous hit to the economy would move a step closer toward idea of a “universal basic income”.

The scoffed-at idea of paying everyone a basic income as machines take people's jobs is getting a fresh look as a possible remedy for economies cratered by the coronavirus pandemic.

Coronavirus | Congress demands implementation of Nyay scheme in view of nationwide lockdown

Lambasted until recently as too costly or too “socialist”, paying people for simply being alive and trusting they will be productive has new support as jobs vanish.

The massive recovery package being considered in the U.S. Congress to offset the tremendous hit to the economy would move a step closer toward idea of a “universal basic income”.

Aspiring Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang argued for it on the campaign trail, even as his opponents and economic pundits shot down the idea as idealistic and impossible to finance.

Also read | Ensure a minimum income for all

Now, with the U.S. economy crippled as people hunker down at home, the likes of conservative Republican Senator Mitt Romney are raising the idea.

Peace of mind

UBI has been tested in the northern California city of Stockton for about a year, with 125 residents in a community considered economically disadvantaged getting monthly payments of $500 each to see whether it helps alleviate poverty.

Also read | Think universal basic capital

Stockton is in a part of the State where agriculture dominates, and the city was so devastated by the 2008 financial crisis that it declared bankruptcy.

Preliminary results indicate people in the UBI experiment spend about 40% of the money on food.

Single mom Lorrine Paradela was able to cut back from two jobs to working just one, and manage unexpected expenses such as car trouble. “It's a huge help,” Ms. Paradela said of the UBI programme. “This money gave me a little peace of mind.”

She recalled getting home after working two jobs with her mind racing, bills to pay, and relentless pressure to earn more money. “Sometimes, I would shop for food but only for my children, not for me,” Ms. Paradela recounted.

Also read | When growth is inclusive, a universal basic income is not necessary: Rathin Roy

The UBI programme in Stockton is showing that a small boost in income can make a tremendous difference to people on tight budgets, according to Mayor Michael Tubbs. “I think, over the long run, we'll see good in terms of people living longer; living happier, less sick, more productive and more able to do all the things you need for society to thrive,” Mr. Tubbs told AFP.

People vs. Machines

The UBI programme in Stockton is backed by an Economic Security Programme created by Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes.

Ideas floated by the project include rebuilding the middle-class by providing allowances to augment incomes of people US households earning less than $50,000 annually.

The cost of living in California is so daunting that workers can't live on pay of $1,000 monthly, contended Steve Smith, a spokesman for a federation of unions.

One in three American workers are at risk of losing their jobs to technology in the coming 12 years, Mr. Yang has argued.

Also read | Basic income works and works well

“To avoid an unprecedented crisis, we're going to have to find a new solution, unlike anything we've done before,” Mr. Yang reasoned while campaigning. His remedy started with a “no strings attached” UBI for all American adults.

Avoiding a new Depression?

In a recent National Public Radio interview, Mr. Yang said the economic impact of the coronavirus pandemic has caused many politicians and analysts to reconsider their opposition to UBI.

“It has completely muddled and transcended party lines where Republicans have enthusiastically come out for cash directly to Americans,” Mr. Yang said of UBI. “Which is the obvious and, frankly, only move that we can make that could keep our economy from collapsing into a new Great Depression.”

Also read | The return of targeted cash transfers

However, cheques sent out as part of the emergency aid plan would involve a temporary measure, while actual UBI would be ongoing and costly to the government.

Public money would need to be spent more wisely, with a retreat from the trend of tax gifts to the wealthy, UBI supporters maintain.

“I haven't always been a fan of universal income,” said Edward Alden, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. “But, its irresistible virtue is its simplicity. It gets money to individuals in need, and out into the wider economy, more quickly than any other alternative.”

Why you should pay for quality journalism - Click to know more

Related Topics
Recommended for you
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Apr 11, 2020 1:00:31 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/business/Economy/coronavirus-pandemic-fallout-revives-talk-of-universal-basic-income/article31166728.ece

Next Story