Return to frontpage
  • ePaper
Return to frontpage
15
Return to frontpage
  • Today's Paper
  • News
    • India
    • World
    • States
    • Cities
  • Opinion
    • Cartoon
    • Columns
    • Editorial
    • Interview
    • Lead
    • Readers' Editor
    • Comment
    • Open Page
    • Letters
  • Business
    • Agri-Business
    • Industry
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Budget 2022
    • Stock Quotes
  • Sport
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • Tennis
    • Athletics
    • Motorsport
    • Races
    • Other Sports
  • Entertainment
    • Art
    • Dance
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Reviews
    • Theatre
  • Crossword+
  • Science
  • Life & Style
    • Fashion
    • Fitness
    • Food
    • Motoring
    • Travel
    • Homes and gardens
    • Luxury
  • thREAD
  • Get Trial
  • SUBSCRIBE NOW
  • Log In
Return to frontpage
Strongman who took Singapore to the First World
    Share On
  • Opinion
  • Cartoon
  • Columns
  • Editorial
  • Interview
  • Lead
  • Readers' Editor
  • Comment
  • Open Page
  • Letters
  • Opinion
  • Comment
CLOSE THIS MENU
TRENDING TODAY
  • Chennai
  • Hyderabad
  • Bengaluru
  • Videos
  • Entertainment
  • Subscription
  • Latest News
  • Today's Paper
  • ePaper
  • Housing
  • Coupons
  • News
    • National
    • International
  • Coronavirus
    • Video & Podcast
    • Expert Speak
    • All Reports
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
    • Other States
  • Business
    • Agri-Business
    • Industry
    • Economy
    • Markets
    • Budget 2022
  • Real Estate
  • Crossword+ "Free Games"
  • Cities
    • Bengaluru
    • Chennai
    • Coimbatore
    • Delhi
    • Hyderabad
    • Kochi
    • Kolkata
    • Mumbai
    • Kozhikode
    • Madurai
    • Mangaluru
    • Puducherry
    • Thiruvananthapuram
    • Tiruchirapalli
    • Vijayawada
    • Visakhapatnam
  • Elections
    • Goa
    • Manipur
    • Punjab
    • Uttar pradesh
    • Uttarakhand
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Lead
    • Comment
    • Columns
    • Interview
    • Cartoon
    • Open Page
    • Readers' Editor
    • Letters
  • Sport
    • Athletics
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Hockey
    • Motorsport
    • Other Sports
    • Races
    • Tennis
  • Entertainment
    • Art
    • Dance
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Reviews
    • Theatre
  • Society
    • Faith
    • History & Culture
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Authors
  • Children
  • Life & Style
    • Fashion
    • Fitness
    • Food
    • Motoring
    • Travel
    • Homes and gardens
    • Luxury
  • Technology
    • Gadgets
    • Internet
  • Sci-Tech
    • Science
    • Technology
    • Health
    • Agriculture
    • Environment
  • Education
    • Careers
    • Colleges
    • Schools
  • Multimedia
    • Photos
    • Videos
    • Podcast
  • Data
  • Specials
  • Resources
  • Tags
  • thREAD
  • Theatre - Fest
  • November Fest
  • Lit for Life
  • Tamil Nadu Smiling
  • Newsletter
  • Archive
  • Classifieds
  • eBooks
  • Subscribe
  • Social
  • About Us
  • CONNECT WITH US
CLOSE THIS MENU
Comment

Strongman who took Singapore to the First World

Sanjaya Baru
March 24, 2015 01:17 IST
Updated: April 02, 2016 12:53 IST
Sanjaya Baru
March 24, 2015 01:17 IST
Updated: April 02, 2016 12:53 IST

What truly set him apart was his obsessive social engineering. He rebuilt Singapore virtually brick by brick…

    Share Article
  • PRINT
  • AAA

What truly set him apart was his obsessive social engineering. He rebuilt Singapore virtually brick by brick…

As an Indian, I wish Lee Kuan Yew had lived to be at least 97. He may then, in 2020, have taken a more positive view of India before finally signing off. In 2007, he endeared himself to Indians when he wrote admiringly about “India’s Peaceful Rise” in a column in Forbes. By 2012 he was writing India off as a “nation of unfulfilled greatness.”

Regrettably, those were his last recorded views on India before ill health slowed him down. He told Robert Blackwill, former United States Ambassador to India and the co-editor of a volume on Mr. Lee’s view of the world, ( Lee Kuan Yew: The Grand Master’s Insights on China, the United States, and the World by Graham Allison, Robert D. Blackwill and Ali Wyne, 2013): “Look at the construction industries in India and China, and you will know the difference between one that gets things done and another that does not get things done, but talks about things…” — words that many believe still ring true about India.

Hot and cold on India Mr. Lee seems to have come to the conclusion that India, a great civilisation, would never be able to equal China as a modern nation. China was determined to regain its status as the world’s number one power. India, Mr. Lee felt, would do well if it managed to somehow get to number two. But, Mr. Lee wished India well because, as he wrote in Forbes , “Singapore and Southeast Asia, sandwiched between these two behemoths, need China and India to achieve a balanced relationship, one that allows both to grow and prosper, pulling up the rest of Asia-East, Southeast and South with them.”

>Mr. Lee always blew hot and cold about India . India was the country he first reached out to, in the mid-1960s, as he set about liberating Singapore and creating an island Republic. In his own country he was fighting the communists, so he couldn’t reach out to Mao’s China for help. Breaking off from Muslim majority Malaysia, and in an awkward relationship with most of his other neighbours, Mr. Lee saw India as his nation’s natural partner. He even retained the island’s Sanskrit origin name — Simhapura that became Singapore — and actively sought India’s diplomatic recognition and military assistance.

In his salad years, as the leader of a new nation, he admired Indira Gandhi’s tough personality. He went out of his way to make Mrs. Gandhi’s first official visit to Singapore a great success. He entered into a defence cooperation agreement with India that has only become stronger with time. But India’s self-important political and diplomatic leadership, while initially helping him, ended up spurning his entreaties and even his suggestion that India become a founding member of the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN).

Caught in the web of its own Cold War and post-colonial rhetoric, India seemed unable to see the wood for the trees in rising Asia. Rebuffed by an imperious India, Mr. Lee became its critic and shunned it, till Prime Minister Narasimha Rao launched his post-Cold war “Look East” Policy. It was left to Mr. Lee’s successor, Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong, to revive the relationship with India. Where Mr. Lee and Mrs. Gandhi failed, Mr. Goh and Mr. Rao succeeded, and the credit for the new India-Singapore relationship ought to go to them.

Rebuilding Singapore Mr. Lee was unique. Alone among the developing, post-colonial nations, Mr. Lee made bold to define his nation’s destiny as that of moving, within one generation, from being a Third World country to becoming a First World country. He achieved it.

Mr. Lee’s critics will draw attention to his dictatorial tactics and the stifling of dissent and the media. His admirers, however, view him a benign dictator who, in fact, actively sought democratic legitimacy and ensured that he secured it by running a welfare state, in which he sought to instil hope in the future for every citizen.

It is not just phenomenal economic growth and modernisation that marks Mr. Lee’s Singapore out. What truly set him apart was his obsessive social engineering. He rebuilt Singapore virtually brick by brick, tearing down the old, changing social behaviour and creating an ‘air-conditioned’ metropolis in the middle of a green, manicured garden island. As Singapore modernised, it also invested in the arts and in culture, always emphasising the diversity of its cultural roots.

Mr. Lee had strong views about how society ought to be organised and how governments ought to function. He had the opportunity and the space to put his thoughts into action and used social engineering to create a plural nation with four official languages and a housing policy that ensured the intermingling of races.

Minister Mentor Having completed his work in Singapore, >Mr. Lee straddled Asia and tried to shape China. His advice was not ignored. Inspired by Singapore’s economic success, China’s Great Moderniser, Deng Xiao Peng, invited Mr. Lee to help build a new China. Deng turned Shanghai into a “Manhattan of the East,” learning from Singapore.

After he handed power to a new generation and appointed himself as Minister Mentor, Mr. Lee sought to become a teacher of sorts. He educated himself about world history and travelled its length and breadth educating world leaders. The only institution in Singapore that he willingly lent his name to was the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, underscoring the point that he saw good and active public policy as the key to progress and prosperity.

His intimate knowledge of China and its leadership made him an important link between a still opaque China and an increasingly curious world. Both Prime Minister Narasimha Rao and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh became his willing disciples in their own effort to understand and deal with China. Each time Mr. Lee visited New Delhi during Dr. Singh’s first term, the two would meet over lunch, where the Minister Mentor would tutor his pupil on how to deal with China’s leadership.

Because Singapore’s success has become so closely identified with his personality and politics, even its failures are now attributed to him. Rising income inequality has created an angry under class, and even a frustrated middle class unable to afford the temptations of a prosperous economy. This anger is now reflected in increasing resentment of expatriates and minorities.

The political party Mr. Lee and his compatriots created is losing ground and his critics are finding a new voice. Perhaps, this was the best time for him to leave his paradise on Earth.

Given that Singapore was one of the Asian countries that extended its hospitality to Prime Minister Narendra Modi when he was still Chief Minister of Gujarat, and also given the special relationship between the two countries, it would be a fine gesture on Mr. Modi’s part if he were to attend Mr. Lee’s funeral later this week.

>>‘Lee Kuan Yew didn’t dislike India, he was disappointed by India’

    (Sanjaya Baru was Visiting Professor, Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, Singapore, and is presently Honorary Senior Fellow, Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi.)

    Return to frontpage
    Our code of editorial values

    Related Topics
    politics
    op-ed
    Related Articles
    Lee among the tallest leaders of our times: Modi
    A hero’s funeral for Lee Kuan Yew
    Modi arrives in Singapore to attend Lee’s funeral
    Singapore founding father Lee Kuan Yew dead
    Lee Kuan Yew (1923 - 2015)
    Lee Kuan Yew a lion among leaders: Modi
    Lee Kuan Yew: Singapore's guiding light
    This article is closed for comments.
    Please Email the Editor

    Printable version | May 17, 2022 3:31:09 pm | https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/strongman-who-took-singapore-to-the-first-world/article7024865.ece

    © THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD.

    Trending in Comment

    Comment The technical higher education market dissected
    Comment Focusing on public health engineering
    Comment An eye on achieving SDGs
    Comment Misogyny in the Malayalam film industry
    Comment The Delhi High Court’s split verdict on marital rape needs resolution
    Comment The importance of Lumbini
    Comment Talking to children about untouchability
    Comment Seeking refuge in ‘GotaGoGama’ — a partial journal of protest
    Comment A financial quandary
    Comment Taking a holistic approach to dengue
    Comment Experiments with Gandhi in Putin land
    Comment The new vigilantism
    Comment The road to safety
    Comment T-cell immunity and COVID-19
    Comment Explaining Sri Lanka’s economic crisis
    Comment What Prashant Kishor’s rise says about the state of electoral politics today
    Comment The winners and losers of the war
    Comment How far does a PhD go?
    Comment Can India catch up with China?
    Comment The thread to grasp in the Kitex story
    Top Picks in The Hindu today
    Farooq, Mehbooba blame ‘The Kashmir Files’ for anger in Kashmir
    Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal defends company's count of spam accounts after Musk criticism
    Explained | The Gyanvapi Mosque-Kashi Vishwanath dispute and the current case
    ‘Vikram’ audio launch: Suriya plays a cameo, Kamal Haasan and Pa Ranjith to collaborate
    Daily Quiz | On protest movements
    Thomas Cup victory sparks celebration for Prannoy’s family
    Cheer returns to Mollywood as releases set the cash registers ringing again post COVID-19
    A flamboyant all-rounder who flourished in ODIs departs
    In Frames | Broiling Churu
    Tamil Thai Vaazhthu echoes in Vatican; Stalin hails move
    TRENDING TODAY
    • Russia-Ukraine Crisis
    • Coronavirus
    • IPL
    • Housing
    30K | Adani buys Ambuja, ACC for $10.5 billion
    12K | U.S. Supreme Court declines to stop deportation of Indian citizen
    7K | Nirmala Sitharaman visits Kalena Agrahara Lake in Bengaluru
    18K | Gyanvapi case: Court orders sealing of spot where Shivling reportedly found
    4K | Russia-Ukraine crisis updates | May 16, 2022
    4K | Buy wheat till May 31, Centre tells States
    4K | Back to the drawing board on role of Chief of Defence Staff
    6K | Explained | The Gyanvapi Mosque-Kashi Vishwanath dispute and the current case
    4K | PM Modi lays foundation stone for India International Centre for Buddhist Culture and Heritage in Nepal’s Lumbini
    4K | Stronger India-Nepal ties must to face emerging challenges, says PM Modi
    3K | Change of guard: On BJP's course correction in Tripura
    3K | Explained | Ukraine’s Eurovision win and its significance
    3K | Sri Lanka to probe reports of LTTE regrouping to launch attack
    720 | Crisis and opportunity: On Sri Lanka political crisis
    2K | Hiam Abbass and Slimane Dazi talk of ‘Oussekine’
    3K | Explained | Why is there a fall in India’s foreign exchange reserves? 
    3K | Minority reservations will be abolished in the BJP rule: Amit Shah
    2K | Intelligence agencies alert on regrouping of ex-LTTE cadres
    2K | A school dropout rides high, selling donkey’s milk for ₹7,000 a litre
    509 | Each for all: On India’s men badminton team win in Thomas Cup
    • ePaper
    Return to frontpage
    TRENDING TODAY
    • Adani buys Ambuja, ACC for $10.5 billion
    • U.S. Supreme Court declines to stop deportation of Indian citizen
    • Nirmala Sitharaman visits Kalena Agrahara Lake in Bengaluru
    • Gyanvapi case: Court orders sealing of spot where Shivling reportedly found
    • Russia-Ukraine crisis updates | May 16, 2022
    TRENDING TOPIC
    • economy, business and finance
    • laws
    • Bangalore
    • Russia-Ukraine Crisis
    Trending on our group sites
    Businessline
    • FMCG Companies
    • UPI
    • Germany
    • Home
    • News
      • India
      • World
      • States
      • Cities
    • Coronavirus
      • Video & Podcast
      • Expert Speak
      • All Reports
      • All Reports
      • E-BOOK
    • Opinion
      • Cartoon
      • Columns
      • Editorial
      • Interview
      • Lead
      • Readers' Editor
      • Comment
      • Open Page
      • Letters
    • Business
      • Agri-Business
      • Industry
      • Economy
      • Markets
      • Budget 2022
      • Stock Quotes
    • Sport
      • Cricket
      • Football
      • Hockey
      • Tennis
      • Athletics
      • Motorsport
      • Races
      • Other Sports
    • Crossword+
    • Coupons
    • Entertainment
    • Life & Style
    • thREAD
    THE SITE
    • About Us
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contacts
    • Archive
    • Print Subscription
    • ePaper
    • Digital Subscription
    • Rss Feeds
    • Sitemap
    GROUP SITES
    • The Hindu
    • இந்து தமிழ் திசை
    • Business Line
    • BL on Campus
    • Sportstar
    • Frontline
    • The Hindu Centre
    • RoofandFloor
    • STEP
    • Young World Club
    • Publications
    • eBooks
    • Images
    • Classifieds
    Contact us Copyright© 2022, THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD.
    JUST IN
    • 3 hrs The Congress’s inexplicable lethargy over the presidential poll
    • An eye on achieving SDGs
    • A financial quandary
    • Focusing on public health engineering
    • The technical higher education market dissected
    • Seeking refuge in ‘GotaGoGama’ — a partial journal of protest
    • The road to safety
    • The importance of Lumbini
    • Misogyny in the Malayalam film industry
    • The Delhi High Court’s split verdict on marital rape needs resolution
    • Actions that corrode the steel frame of India
    • Did the RBI wait too long to raise interest rates?
    • Backstories at the seafront
    • There is no getting past the pandemic till we credibly count COVID-19 deaths
    • Telangana farmers caught in political wrangling
    CLOSE