Parliament proceedings | September 17, 2020

Lok Sabha passes two farm bills; Harsimrat Kaur Badal quits as Union Minister.

Updated - September 18, 2020 08:24 am IST

Published - September 17, 2020 08:54 am IST

Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla conducts the proceedings during the monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi on September 17, 2020.

Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla conducts the proceedings during the monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi on September 17, 2020.

A day after the Rajya Sabha kicked off spirited discussions on India's response to the coronavirus pandemic, Health Minister Dr. Harsh Vardhan addressed the House on the criticisms and concerns of the Opposition.

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh updated the Upper House with regard to the India-China border row, primarily in Ladakh. The House expressed solidarity with the soldiers and the government on this issue.

The Lok Sabha passed two farm bills — Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020 and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020. SAD chief Sukhbir Singh Badal announced in the House that his wife Harsimrat Kaur Badal would quit as Union Minister in protest against the bills.

(For a concise report on the daily going-ons in the Parliament, subscribe to our political newsletter. Subscribe here and get it in your inbox.)

Here are the live updates:

9.55 pm | Lok Sabha

Lok Sabha passes two farm bills

Voting begins on Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020 and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020.

Statutory Resolutions against ordinance defeated. All amendments suggested so far, most of them by MP N.K. Premchandran of RSP were rejected by the lower House.

Thus the two farmer's Bills has been passed in the Lok Sabha. Members of Congress and DMK walk out during bill passage

The House is adjourned till 3 p.m. on Friday.

9.40 pm | Lok Sabha

Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury responds to Agriculture Minister

Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury responds to Agriculture Minister's speech.

He asks, Why couldn't State governments be taken into account while introducing such Bills?

If we compare de-regulated farmer market of Bihar and regulated farmer market of Punjab, you will understand which one is better, he says.

Also, if e-Nam is already there, then why do we need this reforms, asks the Congress MP. 

He also appreciated the stand of Harsimrat Kaur to resign from the cabinet .

9.25 pm | Lok Sabha

Farmers will get better prices now, says Agriculture Minister

This bill will lead to more traders competing for farmers producition, so farmers will get better prices now, says Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar.

The Minister further adds that this will bring an end to license, Inspector Raj and corruption. Farmers and traders will be free to buy and  sell anywhere in country.

In the  National Agriculture Market  (eNAM),1000 mandis joined and monetary amount of ₹35, 000 crore was traded, adds Mr.Tomar.

Contract farming is not meant to help corporates, but to help farmers as many services will reach small farmers, he says.

9.00 pm | Lok Sabha

Agriculture Minister responding queries on Farm Bills

Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar, starts responding to queries on Farm Bills.

He claims that this Bills will bring revolution in lives of farmers.

He further goes on for a while recounting some schemes, allocation, packages given by Central government to agriculture sector.

In the second UPA government, ₹12,00 crore, was allocated for the agriculture ministry, whereas now under PM Modi's leadership, the budget has been increased to ₹1,34,000, he says.

8.45 pm | Lok Sabha

Harsimrat Kaur Badal quits Narendra Modi government to protest farm bills

Harsimrat Kaur Badal has tweeted that she has quit the Union Cabinet over the farm bills.


Says she is “proud to stand with farmers as their daughter and sister.”


8.35 pm | Lok Sabha

TRS opposes Bill

TRS MP Bheemrao Baswanthrao Patil said that by bringing in corporate players, the government is putting farmers at risk who rent farm lands from owners on feeble verbal contracts with little bargaining power.

The MP said that landowners will clearly prefer corporates over poor farmers who are ploughing fields. 

Lok Sabha session extended for another half an hour.

8.15 pm | Lok Sabha

Farm Bills to boost economy of Tamil Nadu, says AIADMK MP

P. Raveendranath Kumar of AIADMK says the Bill will boost the economy of Tamil Nadu.

Farmers will not have to depend on any sort of middle men and can sell their products anywhere in the country, he adds.

He further asks the government to emphasize on electronic trading.

Farmers need to be trained in electronic trading so they can be prevented from frauds, they will also need subsidized support for transportation of produce, he says.

8.05 pm | Lok Sabha

How will the Bill ensure rights for farmers, asks Congress MP

Congress MP S. Jothimani asks how the bill will ensure farmer's rights.

What if the company rejects production on grounds of quality, these questions have no clear answer, she says.

The government is not taking comprehensive approach to improve the situation of farmers and is only going for just cosmetic changes, she adds.

7.50 pm | Lok Sabha

Farmers condition continuously deteriorating in the country: AIMIM MP

AIMIM MP, Syed Imtiaz Jaleel, says, farmers condition are continuously deteriorating in the country.

In the last 70 years, the country had heard a lot of promises to farmers, but has there condition even changed a little, asks Mr. Jaleel.

If government thinks so much about farmers, then why export of onion not allowed. Crude oil prices fell all over world, but prices rose in India, which directly affects the farmers, says Mr. Jaleel

7.45 pm | Lok Sabha

Union Minister Harsimrat Kaur Badal will quit Modi govt.  to protest farm bills: SAD president

Shiromani Akali Dal president Sukhbir Singh Badal announced in Lok Sabha on Thursday that party leader and Union minister Harsimrat Kaur Badal will quit the Modi government in protest against the three farm bills tabled by the Centre in Parliament.

In his speech during a discussion on two of the farm bills -- the Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, Sukhbir Singh Badal said the proposed laws will “destroy” the 50 years of hard work done by successive Punjab governments to build the farm sector.

He recalled Punjab’s massive contribution in making India self-sufficient in food grain production as he vehemently opposed the bills.

“I announce that Harsimrat Kaur Badal will resign from the government,” he said in Lok Sabha.

She is the only SAD representative in the Modi government. The Punjab party is the oldest BJP ally.


7.40 pm | Lok Sabha

Bills will create road towards 'one nation , one market' , says Dushyant Singh

Dushyant Singh of BJP says, the Bill will create road towards 'one nation , one market'.

Private organisation will create jobs as well, thus will help in employment, he adds.

Also, farmers now can sell their crops through out India and will not be limited to their residence areas.

7.30 pm | Lok Sabha

BJP ally Akali Dal opposes farm sector bills

Sukhbir Badal, SAD MP, says farmers are going to be affected if the Bills are passed.


Punjab has spent its last 50 years to develop State's agriculture condition. The Bill will allow corporate and private companies to interfere in this, which Akali Dal will never allow, says Mr. Badal

7.15 pm | Lok Sabha

Government undermining authority of state, attacking federalism, says Trinamool MP Mahua Moitra

Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra that the government through the Bills is undermining authority of state, hampering the federal structure.

 The Bills create two trade areas, one trade area under the new Bills, and the other existing APMC. So there is ample confusion on this, says Ms. Moitra.

Further the Bills doesn't mention of any license in this new trade area, which will make farmers vulnerable to unscrupulous practices, as states will not be able to regulate it, adds the Trinamool MP.

7.05 pm | Lok Sabha

How APMC will be integrated in new Bills, asks TDP MP

Ram Mohan Naidu, of TDP says their party support ordinances, but have some concerns.

Only State can make laws, it needs to be checked if Parliament has competency to make laws regarding this, he asks.

"On the other hand, Agricultural Produce & Livestock Market Committee (APMC) is already in place, so how will this be integrated. There's no clarity on it, " he asks.

6.50 pm | Lok Sabha

Congress didn't take any action on suggestions of Swaminathan report: BJP MP

The BJP MP further states that the Congress speaks about the Swaminathan report on farm sector reforms every now and then but the Congress-lead UPA government didn't take any action on the suggestions made in the report.

The report was released in 2006, finalised in 2008 and the Congress lost power in 2014, Mr. Pal said. 


6.40 pm | Lok Sabha

Farmer's Bill will provide independence to farmers: Jagdambika Pal

BJP MP Jagdambika Pal says the Bills will provide independence to farmers as they can now sell their products anywhere.

He further adds that MSP will be there, thus he finds no reason for the opposition parties to object the Bills.

The Bills will provide profit to farmers, so people who don't want to take farming as occupation will change their mind.

Farmers will have mutual understanding with the corporates before sowing, so they will not face any risk.  Earlier farmers have to go around for seeds and other resources  but now, those entering into the contract with farmers will provide them these services, as they also want profit.

He says that in future farmers will observe this day as Farmer's day.

6.25 pm | Lok Sabha

 Government promoting corporate interest, says  Congress MP Gurjeet Singh Aujla

Gurjeet Singh Aujla of Congress opposes the Bills, stating that the farmers who fed 80 crore people during the COVID-19 outbreak were now our on the streets protesting against the government's move

The government is promoting corporate interest, to the disadvantage of farmers.  The Member opposes the provision of contract based farming.

Private mandis will come up, if contract farming is being introduced, how will you ensure MSP to the farmers, asks the Congress MP.

6.15 pm | Lok Sabha

Government did not take any action against price rise, says SP MP

This government has said a lot of words, but still farmers are ending their lives. Why is it happening, asks Dr. S.T. Hasan. 

The Samajwadi Party MP further states that the government did not take any action against price rise, did not put a cap on stock limit, the government should rather take measures to reduce the cost incurred by farmers.

 It should not allow the corporates to enter the agriculture sector, saying that it will later control the market rates. The SP opposes the Bills.

6.05 pm | Lok Sabha

JDU welcomes Bill

JD(U) Member Santosh Kumar supports the Bills.

In Bihar, floods, draught happen often takes place, thus farmers suffers loss. This Bill will provide independence to farmers  to sell their production.

6.00 pm | Lok Sabha

Send Bill to Standing Committee: Anubhav Mohanty

Anubhav Mohanty of BJD says there is a clear need for more markets.

Farmers are required to pay fees even when they do not use the services of any Agricultural Produce & Livestock Market Committee (APMC)...the infrastructure at APMCs are poor, he says.

To benefit from the Bills, the farmers will need more capital, information on price fluctuations, there should be better access to credit facilities, storage facilities. The proposed laws will have the impact of gradually abolishing APMCs. Abolition of APMC in Bihar has adversely affected the farmers' interest, the BJD MP adds.

The Member urges the Agriculture Minister to send the Bill to the Standing Committee for scrutiny, the Bill was brought hastily, he says.

5.50 pm | Lok Sabha

Shiv Sena supports Bills

Shiv Sena Member Arvind  Sawant welcomes the Bills.

Seeks clarification from the Agriculture Minister on how the existing infrastructure would be integrated under the new arrangement. The government should include a provision ensuring that no agreement will offer rates below MSP, he says.

5.45 pm | Lok Sabha

Farmers would have hit the streets of Delhi, i f there was no COVID situation : BSP MP Ritesh Pandey

Ritesh Pandey of BSP raises the issue of MSP. The government has promised to double the income of farmers, by that logic, the MSP should also be doubled. However, instead of empowering the farmers, corporate players are being given a free hand.

This Bill will bring foreign companies into agriculture, which will lead to exploitation of farmers. The ordinances challenge the federal structure, to the detriment of State rights, he says.

If there was no COVID situation now, farmers would have been in the streets of Delhi, Mr. Pandey adds.

Contract farming only promotes cash crops, which will  adversely impact the soil quality and bio-diversity, says the BSP MP.

5.35 pm | Lok Sabha

House cannot legislate on subject related to agriculture produce, says Trinamool MP Kalyan Banerjee

Kalyan Banerjee of Trinamool Congress opposes the Bills, says 60% citizens who are  poor and marginal farmers will be affected. 

This Bill is thoroughly unconstitutional, as this House cannot legislate on the issue of agriculture produce. 

"Small and marginal farmers will be forced to enter into agreement. Effect of the Bill is that such farmers will be forced to enter into agreement under the conditions set by the superior bargaining parties, big industrialists. They will be forced into litigation. It  wouldn't be possible for them to pursue litigation up till Supreme Court. The proposed provisions will also lead to hoarding and black marketing, profiteering, consumers will suffer..The entire agriculture industry will move towards privatisation," Mr. Banerjee

The move will also result in loss of revenue for the States.

Every sector is being privatised in this government. Modi government is trying to sell everything, it's has now become the 'bechnewala sarakar' (govt. which sells everything), adds the Trinamool MP.

5.25 pm | Lok Sabha

DMK opposes Bills

DMK Member K. Shanmuga Sundaram says the government should have done away with export restrictions on food commodities.

There is nothing in the proposed laws to ensure that the contract with farmers would be fair, he adds.

5.15 pm | Lok Sabha

Government has taken most beneficial steps for farmers: Virendra Singh

Market forces always seek profit, the government is bringing in law to protect the farmers from them.

The member says the BJP had promised to bring the laws in its election manifesto, and it is implementing the same to honour the mandate.

He further states that he being a farmer understands that the current government has taken most beneficial steps for farmers like the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi.

Mr. Singh says the ordinances enabled easy availability of harvester machines in different States during the Covid-19 outbreak.

5.00 pm | Lok Sabha

Farmer's Bills will strengthen farmers, help us become 'atma nirbhar', says BJP MP Virendra Singh

"Perhaps the previous two speakers are not aware of the ground realities. Being a farmer, I do understand them well. The Agriclture Miinister has brought in the Bills to strengthen the farmers, which will help us become "atma nirbhar". I urge all members to speak in one voice for the farmers' benefit," says BJP MP Virendra Singh.

I talked to the farmers in UP, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh and other States. All of them said the proposed law would facilitate easy transportation of the produces to other States

This is a historic step being taken by the government.

4.50 pm | Lok Sabha

Farm ordinances aim to facilitate interests of corporates: N.K. Premachandran

RSP leader N.K. Premachandran  questions the manner in which the ordinances were brought in. There was no justification for promulgating the ordinances.

What steps are taken to justify the livelihood of farmers? he asks.

The ordinances have been brought in to deregulate agriculture farming. The Member quotes NSSO figures on farmers income, suicide cases, to say that aggressive reforms in the agriculture sector has had an adverse impact of them.

NCRB reports show more than 3 lakh farmers ended their life, in between 1995-2005, he adds.

Farming community will be exploited, he says.  All the ordinances aim to facilitate the interests of corporates, he states.

Worldwide contract farming has failed, he says, adding that he opposes the Billls.

4.35 pm | Lok Sabha

Congress opposes Bills

Congress Member Ravneet Singh from Ludhiana (Punjab) opposes the Bills saying the farmers won't spare the government for the move. During the Covid-19 period, 80 crore people were given ration, if you remove Minimum Support Price (MSP), how will you ensure the required grain stocks in future.

Even your ally Akali Dal opposed the introduction of Essential Commodities Act, farmers are protesting in Punjab, Chhattisgarh.

You brought in the ordinances about six months ago, during which maize was sold at ₹700 instead of the MSP of ₹1,700, adds Mr. Singh.

"75% farmers in Punjab are not so affluent. We collect about ₹3,631 crore at mandis, which are used for the farmers' welfare  infrastructures are created and maintained using the funds. Agriculture does not come under your legislative competence. Under the proposed law, will the small time farmers be able to resolve disputes with big players. Businessmen would set up mandis and operate without any licence. The Food Corporation of India procures grains for the entire country, you are now doing away with it," says the Congress MP.

The farmers may initially get more, but will eventually suffer huge losses due to the system of contract farming.

The member calls on all farmers of North India to join hands on the issue, urges the Prime Minister to withdraw the Bills.

4.20 pm | Lok Sabha

House begins discussion on Farmer's bill

House to discuss the Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill.

Narendra Singh Tomar, Minister of Farmers and Agriculture Welfare says, the Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill 2020, and the Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill will help provide farmers with enough opportunity to develop agriculture.

4.10 pm | Lok Sabha

Zero Hour suspended today

The Speaker turns down the adjournment motions, Zero Hour also suspended today, the members will be allowed to raise their issues later.


4.05 pm | Lok Sabha

Speaker Om Birla extends birthday wishes to PM Modi

Lok Sabha resumes.

Speaker, Om Birla, on behalf of the House, greets Prime Minister Narendra Modi on his birthday.

3.00 pm | Lok Sabha

Lok Sabha mourns demise of Tirupati MP

Lok Sabha assembles. Speaker Om Birla informs the passing away of Tirupati MP Balli Durgaprasad Rao. He died at a private hospital in Chennai on Wednesday.

Mr. Durgaprasad, 64, a native of Venkatagiri town, was earlier with the Telugu Desam Party (TDP) and jumped on to the YSR Congress PARty bandwagon just ahead of the elections.

House pays silent tribute to the departed MP.

House adjourned till 4 pm.

2.30 pm


Opposition party members protest outside the parliament seeking Centre to clear GST dues.

Opposition party members protest outside the parliament seeking Centre to clear GST dues.

Eight regional parties held a joint protest in the Parliament house premises demanding that the GST dues that the centre owes to the States should be given at the earliest.

Parliamentarians from TMC, DMK, TRS, SP, AAP, NCP, RJD and Shiv Sena participated in the protest.

At a meeting of the GST council held on August 27, the Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman had acknowledged that States are likely to face a GST revenue gap of ₹3 lakh crore this year, as the economy may contract due to COVID-19, which she termed an unforeseen “act of God”. The states were asked to borrow to meet the shortfall. So far, five state governments have rejected the centre’s suggestion.

2.00 pm | Lok Sabha

Lok Sabha will assemble at 3 pm.

Bill to be introduced

  • The Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Bill, 2020.

Bills for consideration and passing

  • The Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020
  • The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020.
  • The Appropriation (No.4) Bill,2020.
  • The Appropriation (No.3) Bill,2020.
1 pm | Rajya Sabha

MPs express solidarity with soldiers, govt. on border issue

Leader of Opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad says we are all one when it comes to the integrity and sovereignty of the country. He recalls the times he had visited Siachen military posts.

China should return to where they were earlier, he says.

Different members of the House express solidarity with the soldiers and the government on this issue.

Defence Minister appreciates the expressions of solidarity by the MPs. "I do not want to say thank you, because we are one," he said.

Addressing the concern expressed by former Defence Minister A.K. Anthony wrt the patrolling limits, Mr. Singh says "I want to clarify that the face-off is because China stopping India from patrolling. There will be no change in patrolling pattern. No power on earth can stop our brave soldiers from patrolling along our land. It is to keep it that way that the discussion is on."

"I cannot say more due to operational reasons," he says.

With that, the Rajya Sabha adjourns for the day. The House will reconvene at 9 a.m. on Friday, September 18.

12.55 pm | Rajya Sabha

Our soldiers should be allowed to patrol the areas as was the norm: AK Anthony

Congress MP Anand Sharma seeking clarification on the Defence Minister's statement, asks: "do we understand that the restoration of the status quo ante will remain non-negotiable for India."

Samajwadi Party MP Ravi Prakash Verma says the electronic media seems to have created situation of war.

Congress MP and former Defence Minister A.K. Antony says that the nation is totally with the armed forces. "What does it mean when Defence Minister says government will do everything to protect the sovereignty," he asks.

"Galwan Valley was never a disputed site. Now our soldiers not allowed patrol areas they used to earlier. We should be allowed to patrol where we used to," says Mr. Antony.

12.50 pm | Rajya Sabha

Chairperson M. Venklaiah Naidu speaks, in the capacity of Vice President. "India's culture has always preached Vasudaiva Kutumbakam. We have never attacked any country.

"Some international media have written about religious conflicts. We are all united," he says. Mr. Naidu asks the Defence Minister to take suggestions from political leaders, take them into confidence.

Congress member Anand Sharma says the country backs the Army. We are all united in this. Mr. Sharma asks if restoration of status quo will be non-negotiable.

More members express solidarity with the armed forces.

12.30 pm | Rajya Sabha

Rajnath Singh blames China for the situation in LAC

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh briefs Rajya Sabha on the situation along Line of Actual Control, including the Galwan Valley clash and Ladakh stand-off.

He had made a similar statement in Lok Sabha. It can be read here .

China has occupied 38,000 sq km of land, while Pakistan has handed over 5,000 land from Pak Occupied Kashmir to China, he says and also speaks on the 1963 war.

He blames China for the situation in Ladakh. It was Chinese Army that provoked the Indian Army, he says.

After China has upped its infrastructure along the border, we have also ramped up our infrastructure, he says.  He lauds ITBP for its role in protecting the border.

I would like to emphasise, that India remains committed to resolving the current issues in our border areas through peaceful dialogue and consultations, he says.

In the past too we have had situations of prolonged stand-offs in our border areas with China which have been resolved peacefully. We do remain committed to the peaceful resolution of the current situation. At the same time, the House can be assured that we remain prepared to deal with all contingencies, he says and ends the speech praising the armed forces.

12.20 pm | Rajya Sabha

Till a vaccine is available, masks and social distancing is a social vaccine: Health Minister

"U.S. and Brazil have 5-6 times more cases than us. Our mortality rate is the lowest in the world. We will leave America behind in the number of tests soon," Union Health Minister Dr. Harsh Vardhan said.

He added: "Masks are our biggest protector. Ever since unlock, people have assumed that the virus is gone  and they don't need to wear masks or maintain distancing. This is wrong. Virus transmission is happening because of our own irresponsibility. Till a vaccine is available, masks and social distancing is a social vaccine."

Health Minister ends his reply.

12.00 pm | Rajya Sabha

A vaccine should be available in India next year, says Health Minister

Union Health Minister Dr. Harsh Vardhan said that about 1,700 labs were set up in the lockdown.


"The Prime Minister did not see which party was in power when deciding where to deploy equipment. Cobas machines were installed in Delhi, Maharashtra, West Bengal and Noida. We did capacity building in February and March," he said.

He added that the migrant workers did experience problems for some time, but the Home Ministry and Railways took many steps to help them.

On BCG vaccine, he said that ICMR was conducting trials at six sites and PM Modi is closely monitoring the vaccine matter also.

"Going 10 steps forward, detailed plans for vaccination are being made. Three vaccine candidates are being developed in India. We expect that a vaccine should be available in India next year," he added.

11.45 am | Rajya Sabha

'More than 14 lakh cases prevented thanks to lockdown': Health Minister responds to criticism

Health Minister Dr. Harsh Vardhan responds to House discussion on India's COVID-19 response.

"From January 8, the Prime Minister, the Ministers and State health ministers have been addressing the situation," he says. "All Chief Ministers have fought this battle with the PM," he adds.

"All types of advisories and details were given before the first case of COVID-19 in the country on January 30," he says, describing the extensive contact-tracing that was undertaken for that case. "For the first case, 162 contacts were traced. That is how we started our history of contact tracing," he says.

"History will remember Prime Minister Narendra Modi for meticulously monitoring the entire situation himself," says the Health Minister.

Responding to Congress MP Anand Sharma's query, the Minister says that five scientific agencies gave scientific data on the basis of which it was said 14-29 lakh cases were prevented by the lockdown.

11.40 am | Rajya Sabha

Extend insurance to private doctors too, says TMC MP

Union Minister Ramdas Athawale says he gave the slogan of "go, corona go" in February in front of India Gate and woke up the country to the perils of the pandemic.

TMC MP Dr. Santanu Sen says Centre should adopt some of the novel efforts of States, citing West Bengal as an example. "Right now, only government doctors are covered under insurance schemes. This should be extended to private doctors working on the frontlines as well," he says.

11.25 am | Rajya Sabha

Economic contraction minimised due to govt's measures, says Rajeev Chandrasekhar

The lockdown was unambiguously necessary, he says BJP MP Rajeev Chandrasekhar, adding that lockdowns are a necessary tools for government and will be there intermittently till a vaccine is available.

"The impact was expected when 60% of the economy was shut down for 8 weeks. It could have led go contraction of 40%, but did only 23% because of steps taken by the government. That's good news," says Mr. Chandrasekhar.

"When there is an economic loss in States due to floods etc, the Centre steps in. But this is a loss for the whole country and there is no else to pass on the losses to, unless China accepts it's responsibility and there is a case for reparations," he says.

He winds up his speech by thanking those fighting against the "China virus", and says that India step up to fill the void created by the world's distrust of China in the current context.

11.15 am | Rajya Sabha

Opposition has become COVID expert in hindsight: Rajeev Chandrasekhar

BJP MP Rajeev Chandrasekhar says the world hasn't experienced anything like this since the 1918 Spanish flu. "While there are many senior members in this House, I suspect none of us have experienced that," he says.


He questions the behaviour of the Chinese government and the origin of the virus, citing a recent report of a Chinese doctor claiming that the virus was made in a lab.

He says the Opposition and the government should work together to solve this, instead of making petty allegations, and says that the Opposition seems to have become COVID experts in hindsight.

11.10 am | Rajya Sabha

Waiting for the vaccine eagerly: TRS MP

"Earlier the county would eagerly wait for Jaya Bachchan's movie release. Now the country is waiting for vaccine release," begins TRS MP K.R. Suresh Reddy.

He asks the government what it has done to speed up the vaccine process, and for clearing bottlenecks.

11.05 am | Rajya Sabha

Allot ₹9,000 crore to Tamil Nadu for tackling COVID: Thambidurai

AIADMK MP M. Thambidurai says meeting the challenges of the pandemic requires coordination between Centre and States.

He requests the Centre to allocate ₹9,000 crore to Tamil Nadu for tackling COVID. He goes on to cite specific areas for which funds are required, including for farmers affecting problems.

On a lighter note, when Mr. Thambidurai was asked to conclude his speech as his allotted time is up, he responds that COVID hasn't concluded yet.

11.00 am | Rajya Sabha

Be ready for last-mile delivery of vaccine: Gulam Nabi Azad

He cites his experience as the Health Minister in 2009-14 Cabinet, and says that he had taken the first shot of the H1N1 vaccine that was delveloped by India in 2010.

We must encourage domestic manufacturers of vaccines, he says. "And we must be ready for the last-mile delivery of the vaccine; it should not be like the lockdown. We can't waste time to formulate vaccination strategy later," he says.

Government should be over-cautious about the efficiency of the vaccine as we have a large and young population, Mr. Azad.

He winds up by saying that since hand-washing has multipled according to WHO's best practise guideline, the price of soaps (particularly Lifebuoy as it is accessible to the poor) and sanitizers should be halved.


10.50 am | Rajya Sabha

Replace the term social distancing with physical distancing: Gulam Nabi Azad

Leader of Opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad says he has 8 to 10 minutes, of which he will give suggestions for nine minutes as many suggestions have come up in the discussion.


He says: "The government lost the golden months in addressing this pandemic. We should have been alert as it was in our neighborhood (China) that a mysterious pneumonia was being seen in December 2019."

Former Congress president Rahul Gandhi had warned of a tsunami that was about to hit the country, he says.

These are my suggestions, says Mr. Azad.

He says: "There should be dedicated infectious disease hospitals and fever clinics, instead of COVID-19 hospitals to reduce stigma. The term social distancing should be replaced with physical distancing."

10.35 am | Rajya Sabha

UP has a population comparable to Brazil, but has done a better job of managing COVID: Trivedi

BJP MP Dr. Sudhanshu Trivedi continues speaking on the Statement made by the Minister regarding the COVID-19 pandemic and the steps taken by the Government of India.

In response to the Opposition questioning the lockdown announced with four hours notice, Dr. Trivedi says one can imagine the crowds at railway stations and bus stops had there been a two-day notice by seeing what happened in Anand Vihar terminal in Delhi and Tilak terminus in Mumbai .

He speaks about procuring the COVID-19 vaccine from Russia, and on indigenous vaccine production. He adds that Uttar Pradesh has a population comparable to Brazil and has done better job of controlling virus spread, managing cases and deaths.

He claims that the Opposition, which is in power in Punjab (the richest State), West Bengal and Kerala could have done a better job handling the pandemic before questioning the Centre, as health is a State subject. (Isolated shouts as members try to respond to this)

The BJP MP continues: "When Rahul Gandhi was speaking to eminent people on Twitter, Nobel prize winner Abhijit Banerjee said the States should address issues of migrant workers and Centre should support the State."

He winds up by reciting for Prime Minister Narendra Modi as it is his birthday today.

10.25 am | Rajya Sabha

'Was spinning a charkha going to lead to the British leaving?'

BJP MP Dr. Sudhanshu Trivedi says this pandemic is the biggest challenge in documented history.

He hits back at diya-lighting/clapping criticism, and says: "Many of our friends have a problem with lighting of diyas and banging thaalis. They don't know history. Was spinning a charkha going to lead to the British leaving? It was a symbol chosen by Gandhiji."


Without naming the "young, unmarried leader" (making abundantly clear that he is referring to Congress president Rahul Gandhi), Dr. Trivedi says that the leader claimed that he had tweeted about the intensity of coronavirus early in February. "The Centre was criticised for the Namaste Trump event and for not shutting down the airports earlier, but the young leader was tweeting this from a foreign location," says Dr. Trivedi.

As he goes on making political points, MPs protest that the BJP leader is straying from the topic. Deputy Chairman agrees, and says this is applicable to all members of the House.

10.20 am | Rajya Sabha

PM has brought the country together emotionally: Vijaisai Reddy

YSRCP MP V. Vijaisai Reddy says the Centre's approach of balancing life and livelihood post 'Unlock' stage has been appreciated. "The Prime Minister has brought the nation together emotionally," he says.

Mr. Reddy says he suffered from COVID-19, but was able to recover as it was detected early one. He says that the early detection of the virus is key for surviving it. He adds that Andhra Pradesh has highest testing numbers out of States with population of over 3 crore.

10.15 am | Rajya Sabha

Aam Aadmi Party MP Sanjay Singh says the ruling party has been saying the Opposition did not support the PM Modi's "taali, thaali" initiative. "You bring such a foolish idea, and expect the country to be fooled?" he asks, as ruling party MPs protest.


If one COVID-19 patient can be cured of it, we will all sit here and clap and light diyas, he says.

Minor disruption ensues after Mr. Singh strongly rejects allegations of Delhi government mismanaging the pandemic response.

10.05 am | Rajya Sabha

TN has done 'maximum' COVID deaths, says G.K. Vasan

Tamil Maanila Congress MP G.K. Vasan speaks about Tamil Nadu's coronavirus response.


He claims that the State is "effectively managing" the pandemic response by taking "all proactive steps". He says that State has done maximum COVID-19 tests in the country, and that the death rate in the State is one of the least.

BSP MP Veer Singh says unemployment has increased due to COVID-19 and the Centre's lockdown without any preparations affected the poor the most.

10 am | Rajya Sabha

Distribute masks to poor for free: Binoy Viswam

CPI MP Binoy Viswam says it is unfortunate that the Health Minister did not mention Kerala in his statement. Kerala played an exemplary role in fighting COVID-19 right from the word go, he says.

He also commends all frontline workers, specifically mentioning the safai karamcharis, for their service in this regard, and says that the government should distribute free masks to all the poor in the country.

9.55 am | Rajya Sabha

Children are missing crucial immunisations, says Priyanka Chaturvedi

Shiv Sena MP Priyanka Chaturvedi says it was disappointing to see an MP politicise the pandemic issue despite saying it shouldn't be politicised.


She points out that the States are being treated unfairly as it is being deprived of funds. She also says that more than 1 million children have missed crucial immunisation.

TDP MP Kanakamedala Ravindra Kumar says Andhra Pradesh government is under-reporting virus cases and that the Chief Minister is making unscientific claims like saying that paracetamol is the only medicine for COVID-19.

9.50 am | Rajya Sabha

Facing shortage of oxygen cylinders, remdesivir: NCP MP

NCP MP Praful Patel begins by thanking the frontline workers for their service during the pandemic.

He says there is no fixed direction of the pandemic — it started with the cities, and now it has spread across the country. "We have 1 lakh cases a day now and it is set to reach 2 lakh a day," he says.

He says that he read in newspapers that officials are saying that there is not shortage of oxygen cylinders and remdesivir drug , however the ground reality is different.

9.40 am | Rajya Sabha

What is the PM CARES fund for if not for States, asks Sanjay Raut

Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut says he has personal experience with the danger of coronavirus as his elderly mother and younger brother are in the ICU, ailing from COVID-19.


He hits back at BJP MP Dr. Vinay Sahasrabuddhe for his speech in the House on September 16, where Dr. Sahasrabuddhe criticised the Maharashtra govermnment's COVID response. Mr. Raut cites the example of the States successful arrest of spread of the virus in the heavily-populated Dharavi to refute Dr. Sahasrabuddhe's claims.


Maharashtra government has followed the protocol of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, says Mr. Raut.

He says that the Centre has stopped funds for PPE kits, masks and other materials from September 1. "It will cost Maharashtra government ₹50 crore a day. What is the PM CARES fund for if not for States?," he asks.

9.35 am | Rajya Sabha

Discussion on COVID-19 resumes.

Swapan Dasgupta, nominated member, resumes his speech from the previous session.

He asks the government what the scientific basis for a lockdown is and if a uniform guideline can be issued for lockdowns as States have imposed different versions which often are contradictory and causes confusion among the people.

9.25 am | Rajya Sabha

Special mentions begin.

Congress MP K.C. Venugopal asks for a probe into Facebook's interference into India's electoral democracy.

Congress MP Ripun Bora says NEET and JEE exams should be held again as many students could not attend due to COVID-19 pandemic.

BJP MP Satish Chand Dubey raises issue of floods in Bihar every year.

YSRCP MP V. Vijaisai Reddy asks for special trains in Andhra Pradesh, says not a single train running from Hyderabad to Visakhapatnam.

Chairman Venkaiah Naidu reminds the members of special protocols in place wrt the COVID-19 pandemic, including compulsory face masks and seated debates.

9.20 am | Rajya Sabha

Release jailed J&K leaders, says MP

BJP MP Nabam Rebia says Arunachal Pradesh got statehood in 1987, but has not been given Constitutional protection yet. He asks the government to consider the Arunachal Pradesh government's demand of including the State in the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution.

BJP MP Vivek Thakur begins by saying that during the COVID-19 discussion in the Upper House on the previous day, it was made out as though the government has not done anything good during the COVID-19 pandemic. Updating the House on the vaccine status, he says there are three companies working on COVID-19 vaccines that come from the country of origin of virus. Should we entertain them, he asks.

PDP MP Mir Mohammad Fayaz raises the matter of political leaders in Jammu and Kashmir being under arrest for over a year after Article 370 was abrogated. He asks the government to release those who are still under arrest.

BJP MP Surendra Singh Nagar points out that the J&K administration has not included the third most spoken language, Gurjari, in its list of official languages. He asks the Centre to include Gurjari and Pahadi in the list.

9.10 am | Rajya Sabha

Radio collars on Asiatic lions increasing their death rate?

Congress MP Shaktisinh Gohil says radio collars put on Asiatic lions in Gir forest have led to increasing death rate. Chairman Venkaiah Naidu asks that this issue be noted and looked into.

MP Sanjay Raut asks permission to address the House standing up, which Chairman Venkaiah Naidu declines citing COVID-19 protocol.

Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut says  government is planning to privatise Jawaharlal Nehru Port and it will be a loss to the country's exchequer as land and property worth crores will pass on to private hands. He asks that the project be reconsidered.

Congress MP Dr. Amee Yagnik raises issue of patients who suffered from non-communicable diseases being unable to get treatment for non-COVID diseases as the focus is on COVID-19. She cites stalling procedures like chemotherapy, dialysis as an example. She asks the government for separate investment for diseases like cancer, diabetes, hypertension etc.

Samajwadi Party MP Ravi Prakash Verma raises the matter of floods along the Indo-Nepal border, and says the government should take up the matter considering the adverse impact it has on Indian villages.

9 am | Rajya Sabha

Award frontline workers: request raised during Zero Hour

Papers laid on table, including Report of the Committee on Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.

Zero Hour begins. Samajwadi Party MP Vishwambhar Prasad Nishad raises matter of vacancies in reserved government jobs.

AIADMK MP from Puducherry N. Gokulakrishnan says that Scheduled Caste and Schedule Tribe citizens of the country are feeling apprehensive about their future as the reccomendations made in Mandal Commission report is implemented only on paper. He asks for moratorium on creamy layer principle till 27% reservation is filled.

BJP MP Lt. Gen (retd.) Dr. DP Vats says frontline corona warriors should be awarded service or peace-time gallantry awards similar to the ones granted to the military. He cites the example of air hostess Neerja Bhanot as a precedent.


Bill for Introduction

  • Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Bill, 2020

Bills for consideration and passing

  • Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020
  • Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Rajya Sabha

Bills for Consideration and Passing

  • Salaries and Allowances of Ministers (Amendment) Bill, 2020
  • Indian Medicine Central Council (Amendment) Bill, 2020
  • Homoeopathy Central Council (Amendment) Bill, 2020
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Second Amendment) Bill, 2020
0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.