The Economic Survey 2018-19

Economic Survey: Aadhaar aided MGNREGS beneficiaries

A person checks his Aadhaar details on his mobile phone. Picture for representational purposes only.   | Photo Credit: V.V. Krishnan

Refuting criticism of Aadhaar-linked payments and the direct benefit transfer system, the Economic Survey 2018-19 has used the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) as a case study to show the benefits of the use of technology in improving targeting and efficiency in welfare schemes, especially for the most vulnerable groups.

Going forward, the Survey recommends that digital technology and the JAM troika — Jan Dhan, Aadhaar and Mobile — be expanded to other welfare schemes. The Survey cites data on the timeliness of wage payments, worker turnout, demand and supply of work under the scheme before and after Aadhaar-linked payments (ALP) were implemented as a proof for its benefits.

Data show that in 2014-15, less than 27% of wage payments were generated within 15 days. Direct benefit transfers were introduced two years later. By 2018-19, more than 90% of wage payments were generated within 15 days. “Payment delays drive away farmers in genuine distress, while others not in distress take the benefits. A person undergoing economic distress needs immediate and certain liquidity. Working for uncertain promised wages, which are likely to be realised with a substantial lag, presents an unattractive proposition for a person in distress as delayed payments effectively imply zero wages in adverse times,” says the Survey. The Survey also compared the MGNREGS performance in blocks affected by drought versus other blocks, using drought as a proxy for distress. In drought-affected blocks, the number of persons demanding work increased more than 20% after the implementation of ALP, while there was no effect in other blocks. A similar trend is seen in the supply of work. Muster rolls, which are work site attendance registers, show a 19% increase after ALP implementation in most blocks. In drought-affected blocks, muster rolls increased by 44%.

Economic Survey: Aadhaar aided MGNREGS beneficiaries

“It appears that before the implementation of ALP, the rural poor treated MGNREGS as an option to earn additional income during good times rather than a shock absorber during bad times. This actually defeated the purpose of the programme. Post implementation of ALP, there is a reversal of trend, wherein an increase in demand for work under MGNREGS is observed in drought-affected areas,” says the Survey, arguing that effective targeting has been possible because of ALP.

The Survey suggests that going forward, “demand for work under MGNREGS may be used to develop a real-time indicator of distress at the granular district or panchayat level.” Current datasets on rural distress such as the NSSO survey or district-level GDP data is often years out of date, and cannot be used to provide assistance at the time needed. By correlating information on MGNREGS demand with other data, a dashboard tool can be used to signal local distress and enable policymakers to alleviate it in a timely manner. The Survey also recommends that other welfare schemes implement the lessons learnt from Aadhaar linkages in MGNREGS.

Scholarships, pensions, and subsidies for food, kerosene, and gas cylinders should be next in line to implement Aadhaar-based payments, it said.

Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Oct 20, 2021 4:43:54 AM |

In This Package
You are reading
Economic Survey: Aadhaar aided MGNREGS beneficiaries
FDI needed to spur the virtuous cycle in India, says CEA Krishnamurthy Subramanian
Survey calls for tax cuts, space for hotels in infra boost to tourism
Economic Survey moots central welfare database of citizens
India could host ‘Detroit’ of EVs
‘Reward top taxpayers, shame defaulters’
Well-designed minimum wage system required to reduce wage inequality, says Economic Survey 2018-19
Economic Survey 2018-19: Private funds needed for Swachh Bharat
Economic Survey 2018-19 calls for improvement in contract enforcement regime
‘Recovery under IBC higher at 43%’
More than half of start-ups are from tier-2 and tier -3 cities: Survey
Economic Survey: shift focus to water productivity
Economic Survey 2019 in six charts
India must spend $200 billion on infra annually; harnessing pvt. investment a challenge: Economic Survey
No train collisions in 2018-19, fire incidents rise: Economic Survey
Finance Ministry makes progress in strategic sale of 28 Central Public Sector Enterprises
Economic Survey lays out blueprint for $5 trillion economy
Read: Full text of Economic Survey 2019
India needs to increase energy consumption to raise per capita income: Eco Survey
Economic Survey calls for enhanced efficiency in judiciary to help improve ease of doing business
India’s march towards SDGs anchored in investing in human capital, inclusive growth: Economic Survey
Debt recovery mechanism strengthened with IBC, says Economic Survey
Economic Survey 2018-2019 proposes to raise retirement age
Gross tax to GDP ratio dips to 10.9% in FY’19
Economic Survey suggests merging of different datasets held by govt
Economic Survey: Many states became open defecation free since launch of Swachh Bharat
Next Story