SEARCH

Opinion » Comment

Updated: March 10, 2010 23:37 IST

Encore for the old Obama magic

Narayan Lakshman
Comment (2)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Protesters supporting U.S. President Barack Obama’s healthcare reform during a demonstration on Monday. - PHOTO: AFP
AFP Protesters supporting U.S. President Barack Obama’s healthcare reform during a demonstration on Monday. - PHOTO: AFP

Should Obama seek to go toe-to-toe with would-be maligners across the aisle? Or, should he retreat once again to his role as a thoughtful yet hesitant President?

Finally, it happened. It was no more than a flash, of burnished, steely determination glinting in the sun. But it was there and no mistaking it for anything other than the old Obama magic

What was so startling about President Obama's fiery, provocative speech at Arcadia University in Glenside, Pennsylvania on Monday was the powerful surge of déjà vu that it brought, the invocation of a stirring within every member of the audience. By the end of it, all of them were swept away in the crescendo of his words as he roared, “And if you share that belief, I want you to stand with me and fight with me” to thunderous applause. The General had returned.

The “belief” that the President referred to, of course, was America's faith in the urgent need for healthcare reform. Why did it evoke déjà vu? Because after weary, interminable months of tackling the relentless siege of opposition obstructionism, the memory of Candidate Obama had, unbelievably, faded.

And faded not just for those all-important swing voters in what is still very much a polarised American polity. It had faded for even his strongest base of supporters, the so-called Millennial voters, who until today the polls indicated were disillusioned with the President's inability to deliver change.

So low is the ebb of hope today that few would readily recall that this was the man who brought a tired, frustrated and internationally unappreciated America back up to its feet with a renewed sense of purpose.

Yet finally, after more than thirteen months of gentlemanly conduct, he stepped out on the front foot and no apologies. Finally, after more than a year of putting his faith in quiet persuasion and patient interlocution, he did more than just block a punch. He rolled up his sleeves (literally, he did). He took off his jacket, saying “It's hot up here!” And, lo and behold, the man started punching.

First an uppercut: “When you're in Washington, folks respond to every issue, every decision, every debate, no matter how important it is, with the same question: What does this mean for the next election?”

Then a jab: “Every year, insurance companies deny more people coverage because they've got pre-existing conditions. Every year, they drop more people's coverage when they get sick… Every year, they raise premiums higher and higher and higher. Just last month, Anthem Blue Cross in California tried to jack up rates by nearly 40 per cent. Anybody's paycheck gone up 40 per cent?”.

A feint to the left: “The other day, there was a conference call that was organised by Goldman Sachs… in which an insurance broker was telling Wall Street investors… that insurance companies know they will lose customers if they keep on raising premiums, but because there's so little competition in the insurance industry, they're okay with people being priced out.”

And finally that killer hook: “So what should I tell these [chronically ill] Americans? That Washington is not sure how it will play in November? That we should walk away from this fight, or [that] we'll do it incrementally, we'll take baby steps? [AUDIENCE: “No!”] So they want me to pretend to do something that doesn't really help these folks.”

Of course when Obama fights, it ain't no brawl — so he took some time with the Arcadia crowd, as he did for seven and a half hours in a recent summit with Republicans, to carefully lay out the reasons why his reform would help the healthcare system cut costs, increase coverage, reduce its deficit impact and end the tyranny of insurance companies enriching themselves to the detriment of ordinary Americans.

The experience was salutary. Obama could not have missed that fact. His audience certainly did not. Yet with all eyes, including Democrats', on Congressional elections in November, Monday's speech and the reaction bring an important behavioural question to the fore: should Obama seek to go toe-to-toe with would-be maligners across the aisle? Or, should he retreat once again to his role as a thoughtful yet hesitant President?

In truth the answer may well not matter, because regardless of the stormy weather November may bring, it will be followed by a whole two years during which possibly 30 million more Americans will be returned to a life of dignity, security and affordable, quality healthcare. And they will not forget their President when he needs them.

In Obama's own words, he would have put doing what is right before doing what is politically expedient. If that high moral choice might also result in the transformation of a purely exploitative system, then Republican objections become irrelevant. Let them kick and scream.

More In: Comment | Opinion

There goes America! Obama and radical left has done a huge favour to their vote bank, viz, handout seekers and illegal immigrants, at the expense of hard working Americans

from:  Robnadar
Posted on: Mar 22, 2010 at 12:10 IST

Reading the opinion,anyone living outside the United States of America might think that hundreds if not thousands of Americans have no healthcare and that they are left to suffer . On the contrary , all Americans are enjoying the blessings of a great nation. No American who is sick is kicked out of a hospital or is denied any care. Having worked in the healthcare field for the past 15 years , I can truly say that even the poorest of poor is able to receive the same if not better health care . President Obama and the democrates are like most politicians,they promise big things to satisfy the people ,and the way they do that is to burden the people working hard . The republicans are not against reform,they want reform .They want reform to be in the manner of fiscal responsibilities. They want to cut spending and worthless handouts. If the people of America want this healthcare reform that Presedent Obama promises a major portion of them will be in favor of it. Recent polls however indicate just the opposite.

from:  franklin
Posted on: Mar 12, 2010 at 08:02 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor


O
P
E
N

close

Recent Article in Comment

WHAT LIES AHEAD? The real test of the ‘grand alliance’ will come towards the end of 2015 when the State goes for Assembly polls. Picture shows Rashtriya Janata Dal chief Lalu Prasad (left) and Janata Dal (United) leader Nitish Kumar at an election meeting in Hajipur, Bihar. Photo: Ranjeet Kumar

An inconclusive victory

More evidence is needed before the ‘grand alliance’ in Bihar is termed a success, as strong indications of communal polarisation exist despite its victory in the by-elections »