Anti-Sterlite protests: the story till now

Thoothukudi firing: Entirely preventable

There must be a thorough inquiry into the lead-up to the deaths in Thoothukudi

The protest against the copper smelter plant of Sterlite Copper in Thoothukudi has witnessed its deadliest turn so far, with the death of 12 people in police firing. It was clear the movement would put up a show of strength on May 22, the 100th day of this phase of protests — in fact, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court had predicted that it was “likely to trigger a law and order situation” and declared that the “protesters do not have any intention of conducting a peaceful protest”. Yet, the Tamil Nadu government failed to gauge the intensity of what was coming. It is a tragic irony that such an angry and violent demonstration could have been staged at a time when the plant is not operational and after the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board refused to renew its consent to operate. It raises questions about the government’s failure to drive this point home forcefully, and casts a doubt about the real intent of some of the protesters, possibly a small section comprising hardline groups. The immediate task is to compensate the public for its losses and end the alienation of the affected communities through talks. But the commission of inquiry headed by retired judge Aruna Jagadeesan must examine why 12 lives were brutally snuffed out, more specifically, the chilling accusation that snipers were deployed by the police force to pick out protesters in a premeditated manner. Any police response must be commensurate with the gravity of the situation; there is no place for heavy-handedness and a disproportionate use of force. The inquiry must establish who gave the orders to fire and on what basis. Also, why the police failed to intervene well before the protest developed an angry head of steam.

Sterlite stakes claim to be India’s largest copper producer and is a major presence in Tamil Nadu’s industrial mix. But it has had mixed fortunes over the two decades of its production, including periods when it was under administrative orders of closure, a ₹100-crore fine imposed for pollution by the Supreme Court in 2013, and consistent opposition from fishermen. Now, there is a fresh injunction and the Madras High Court has restrained it from a proposed capacity expansion plan. This, together with the decision to not renew consent for operation, gives a moment for pause for all sides. An urgent process, such as an all-party meeting, is needed to heal the wounds, and infuse confidence in the community. A credible environmental audit should be undertaken, without compromising on the ‘polluter pays’ principle. The TNPCB, which usually scores poorly on transparency, should commission credible experts to assess the quality of air and water in Thoothukudi. Only such verifiable measures will build public confidence, and make orderly industrialisation viable.

Why you should pay for quality journalism - Click to know more

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Feb 23, 2020 8:27:31 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/entirely-preventable/article23971795.ece

In This Package
The Hindu explains: Sterlite protests
Infiltration of anti-social elements into peaceful protest led to Thoothukudi violence, says Rajinikanth
‘Who are you,’ youth asks Rajinikanth in Thoothukudi hospital
Continuous protests will turn Tamil Nadu into a graveyard: Rajinikanth
T.N. to take back land allotted to Sterlite
CM accuses DMK of instigating Sterlite protesters
G.O. won’t stand up to legal scrutiny: Stalin
‘G.O. to close Sterlite plant inadequate’
Governor visits firing victims in hospital
Three officers in the rank of deputy tahsildar issued firing orders in Thoothukudi, say FIRs
Industrialists concerned over decision on Sterlite
Closure evokes mixed feelings
Government Order an eyewash: Stalin
OPS visits victims, terms firing tragic
Sterlite Copper to be permanently closed, says Tamil Nadu government
Anti-Sterlite protests: In Thoothukudi, how copper came a cropper
Exiting Thoothukudi not on the cards, says Sterlite CEO
CM evades question on who ordered firing
Thoothukudi police firing: Why Narendra Modi is silent, asks Congress
Plea seeks CBI probe into firing
‘Preserve bodies of police firing victims’
Anti-Sterlite protests: Protesters court arrest over firing
Vested interests behind anti-Sterlite protests, says Tamil Nadu CM Palaniswami
Cong., CPI (M) to join DMK bandh
Lift prohibitory orders immediately, says Ramadoss
‘Lack of planning and leadership led to firing’
Tamil Nadu CM says Sterlite will be shut
TNPCB orders closure of Sterlite plant in Thoothukudi
Anti-Sterlite protests: T.N. invokes ‘public emergency’, sounds high-level alert
10 killed in police firing as anti-Sterlite rally turns violent in Thoothukudi
You are reading Thoothukudi firing: Entirely preventable
One more killed in fresh firing in Thoothukudi
Cease construction of unit II of Sterlite copper plant, Madras High Court directs Vedanta
Vedanta shares drop 6% after protests in Tamil Nadu
Situation necessitated use of force, says DGP
HC had predicted the stir could take a violent turn
Jury still out on what triggered the violence
Police fired under unavoidable circumstances: T.N. CM
Victims with bleeding injuries and gunshot wounds at Thoothukudi GH
Sterlite Copper unit: TNPCB faces flak
‘No question of closing down Sterlite unit’
Newly-wed couple turn up at anti-Sterlite protest venue
Vedanta’s ‘realty plan’ kicks up a row
Sterlite protesters seek RTI reply in 48 hours
Two children injured in anti-Sterlite protest
Kollywood’s show of solidarity
Anti-Sterlite protest in 16 U.S. cities
Kamal Haasan supports anti-Sterlite protest
T.N. govt. not responding to protests over Sterlite: Rajinikanth
Sterlite Power may invest $10 bn
Next Story