News » National

Updated: May 20, 2011 00:06 IST

Poverty, caste and religion to be simultaneously mapped

Smita Gupta
Comment (4)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
A file photo of a census official marking a house in Siligiri. The proposed third round of census will enumerate the socio-economic background of people.
A file photo of a census official marking a house in Siligiri. The proposed third round of census will enumerate the socio-economic background of people.

A nationwide survey that will simultaneously map the economic, caste and religious backgrounds of the entire population was approved by the Union Cabinet on Thursday. The survey marks two firsts: firstly, in a break with past practice, the Below Poverty Line (BPL) Census has been widened to include urban areas; earlier, it was restricted to rural India. Secondly, the caste headcount, which will be conducted simultaneously with the BPL census, will be done for the first time after 1931.

Announcing the Cabinet decision, Union Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni told journalists, “This completely fulfils the assurance given by the government in Parliament to the Opposition parties to have a caste-based census along with the socio-economic profiling.”

In an effort to refine the BPL census, the government has redefined what constitutes poverty: Sanjay Kumar, Joint Secretary in the Rural Development Ministry, said BPL households in urban areas would be identified through an “inclusion criteria,” based on three factors — place of residence, social vulnerability (illiteracy, chronic disability or female headed households etc.) and occupational vulnerability (those in the most informal and least remunerative sectors).

However, the identification of their counterparts in rural areas would be done differently, he said. Here, the population would be divided into three categories — those at the top in rural areas (such as families owning fixed-line telephones, refrigerators and farmers with a credit limit of Rs.50,000) would be excluded, those at the bottom (such as destitutes, manual scavengers and primitive tribal groups) would be automatically included, and finally, for those in between to qualify for BPL status, there would be seven “deprivation indicators.”

Deprivation indicators

At the Cabinet meeting, Ms. Soni said there was a long and thorough discussion on these seven “deprivation indicators,” with Ministers pointing out possible loopholes in those that had been listed. Eventually, Union Rural Development Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh was asked to factor in his colleagues' suggestions before finalising the seven “deprivation indicators.”

The BPL census, Ms. Soni said, would be conducted by the Rural Development Ministry in association with the Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation Ministry and the Registrar General of India (RGI). The actual implementation is to be left to the State governments, who will deploy panchayat workers, patwaris and the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act workers. The entire process would be completed by December 2011, and the results of the BPL census would be utilised in the 12th Five Year Plan (2012-13 to 2016-17).

While the BPL lists would be placed in the public domain in case anyone wishes to challenge inclusions or exclusions, the data on caste and religion would be given to the Registrar-General and kept confidential, Mr Kumar said. The last BPL census was conducted in 2002.

In the past, many Chief Ministers have challenged the BPL figures for their States, claiming that the numbers of the poor were much higher than those computed by the Centre. To a question, Mr. Kumar said that if any State government challenged the figures that emerged from the BPL census, it would have to sort it out with the Planning Commission. These figures were critical in the past, for instance, for foodgrain allocations for the PDS; in the future, allocations under the proposed Food Security law would also hinge on these figures.

More In: National | News

This exercise, if carried out properly, will help in formulation of targeted schemes for the poor. The precarious problems of exclusion as well as inclusion can be handled to some extent and help in better delivery of social services. On the other hand, the exercise might give rise to mandal-politics once again. We must make sure that this data is not used for narrow political gains. It should be used to integrate the country not to divide it once again.

from:  Sanjay Singh
Posted on: May 20, 2011 at 09:13 IST

This census will be really helpful as we will know the economic condition of different people along with their caste.If this census is done on a regular basis we can know how many people are willing to classify their caste as backward caste to gain advantage provided in our constitution. I'am some one who believes in reservation provided on the basis of economic condition of people rather than caste.This census might make it clear if the people belonging to so called backward castes(who are financially stable)need reservation.

from:  Praveen
Posted on: May 20, 2011 at 08:44 IST

The cabinet decision to identify the poor, including their caste and religion in the Census-2011 is likely to be hailed by the 'social-engineers'. Simultaneously, this historic decision to collect data on poverty, caste and religion of the Indians is likely to be disapproved by those who apprehend domino effect in compiling such data even for planning purpose as it has the potential to awaken the power-groups and more demands- legitimate and otherwise. But then there is no meaning in keeping such harsh realities under any artificial garb. Caste and Religion are no longer one's private affair in modern democracies. People want identity politics to be played in the form of affirmative action. Now, no political party including right-wing parties will be able to oppose the affirmative measures and social engineering openly notwithstanding their private views. Given this, there is no meaning in fearing such a Census to collect one’s socio-economic status. Let us face the reality. This will be a dialectic exercise exploring the past and the future of the Social Engineering.

from:  Bichu Muttathara
Posted on: May 20, 2011 at 00:14 IST

World Bank defines, for an underdeveloped country like India, a minimum wage of $1 per day, roughly $365 a year to qualify for being above the poverty line, which amounts to less than Rs. 17,000 per year. Looking at these numbers, almost 70% of population in India is below the poverty line.

from:  Tushar
Posted on: May 20, 2011 at 00:14 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Avian Influenza Outbreak

More Avian Influenza Outbreak »


Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh





Recent Article in National

Rajasthan coop official, family sentenced in graft case

The former deputy manager of Rajasthan Cooperative Dairy Federation, Surendra Sharma, and his entire family were sentenced to six year... »