The fire accident in the AC 3-tier coach of the Bangalore-Nanded Express that killed 26 persons on December 28 last year may have been caused by the negligence of unidentified passengers or persons, the Commissioner of Railway Safety (CRS) Southern Region has concluded.

In the provisional findings by CRS Satish Kumar Mittal, which were released on Wednesday, he said, “Upon careful consideration of the factual, material and circumstantial evidence available with me, I have come to [the] conclusion that the fire in AC-3 tier coach (No. 97105) of train number 16594 between Sri Satya Sai Prashanti Nilayam-Basampalli stations was most probably caused by advertent act or negligence on [the] part of unidentified passenger/s or person/s.”

He classified the accident under the category of “Error in working near Railway Line.”

The report also quotes the findings of the Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory (APFSL) that says no signs of explosion effect were found in the burnt coach. The APFSL’s report of January 3, 2014, also says that the pattern of fire signature was slow and progressive, indicating absence of inflammable substances and sabotage as cause of fire.

The laboratory had taken 81 test samples from the ill-fated coach.

While short circuit in the AC system was initially believed to have ignited the fire, the CRS findings do not support it.

Mr. Mittal’s report, in particular, cites the excessive burning mark near berth no. 7 up to floor level, heat black mark on the bogie bolster near seat no. 7 and charred wood pieces found on the bolster.

The provisional findings of the CRS has been submitted to the Chief Commissioner of Railway Safety, Lucknow, Secretary (Safety), Railway Board, and General Manager of South Western Railways.


Frequent fires point to poor maintenance December 29, 2013

Fire alarm system yet to be installed in most trainsDecember 29, 2013

List of passengers on the AC coach of trainDecember 28, 2013

Forensic experts scour the coach for cluesDecember 28, 2013

Bodies shifted to government hospital in BangaloreDecember 28, 2013

Most victims from Gulbarga and BidarDecember 28, 2013

Railway accidents in 2013December 28, 2013

Kharge orders high-level inquiry into Bangalore-Nanded express fireDecember 28, 2013

Train mishap: Anxious friends, relatives turn up at morgue, railway stationDecember 28, 2013

Chennai family on burning coachDecember 28, 2013

Firefighters help passengers break out of coachDecember 29, 2013

Train mishap: 13 victims identifiedDecember 29, 2013

He rescued many, but is still searching for his mother December 29, 2013

Bangaloreans among those missingDecember 29, 2013

30 passengers survive train fire tragedyDecember 29, 2013

Agonising wait for families of victims of train tragedyDecember 29, 2013

Helplines were of no helpDecember 29, 2013

Fire in Nanded Express still a mystery December 31, 2013

Get serious on safetyDecember 30, 2013

Dear ones scour for informationDecember 30, 2013

Some families prefer to wait for DNA matchingDecember 30, 2013

No clues to inflammable material in AC coachDecember 30, 2013

Train mishap: Their destination was the gurudwara, but they never got thereDecember 29, 2013

Forensic experts rule out blast as cause of fireDecember 31, 2013

Bodies of all Nanded Express accident victims identified December 31, 2013

Short-circuit may have caused Nanded Express blazeDecember 28, 2013