She wasn’t Hindu after marrying a Muslim, says Delhi temple denying death ritual for woman

Kali Mandir Society in Delhi's Chittaranjan Park tells a woman can no longer be considered a Hindu after marrying a Muslim as a woman adopts the surname and belief system of her in-laws.

August 09, 2018 06:37 pm | Updated 06:42 pm IST - New Delhi

 Google Maps image locates Kali Mandir Society in Delhi’s Chittaranjan Park.

Google Maps image locates Kali Mandir Society in Delhi’s Chittaranjan Park.

A Muslim husband wants to perform a ritual for his dead Hindu wife and a temple society in a New Delhi Bengali-dominated neighbourhood has not allowed because they believe the woman was no longer a Hindu after her marriage even as she hadn’t given up her faith.

Kolkata-based Imtiazur Rahman lost his wife Nivedita Ghatak in the capital after she suffered from multi-organ failure last week — 20 years after the couple married in accordance with the Special Marriages Act that allows inter-faith wedding of couples irrespective of their individual faith.

Ghatak was cremated as per Hindu rites at Delhi’s Nigam Bodh Ghat but the family could not perform shradh — a set of Hindu rituals performed for the deceased.

Mr. Rahman, who is an assistant commissioner with the commercial taxes department of the West Bengal government, said he had booked an August 12 slot at Kali Mandir Society in the Bengali-dominated Chittaranjan Park after paying ₹1,300 for the ceremony on August 6. But he was later told by the temple society that his booking had been cancelled “for obvious reasons”.

Ashitava Bhowmik, the president of the temple society, told IANS that Mr. Rahman’s request could not be taken up for “more than one reason”. He alleged that Mr. Rahman “concealed his identity” and made the booking in his daughter Ihini Ambreen’s name “which doesn’t sound like Arabic or Muslim”.

Mr. Bhowmik said, “We got to know about his religious identity when a priest got suspicious and asked him about gotra.” Gotra is the lineage, which forms an important factor in determining Hindu ancestry.

“Obviously, he had no answers. Muslims don’t follow gotra system. His wife can no longer be considered a Hindu after marrying the Muslim because a woman adopts the surname and belief system of her in-laws and becomes a part of that society,” Mr. Bhowmik told IANS.

He said, “It was done in keeping with and respecting the Hindu traditions and rites.”

Asked since it was the last wish of the woman, who followed the Hindu belief system, Mr. Bhowmik said, “Who knows the man has some ulterior motive and could bring in 50-100 of his relatives inside the temple and start (saying) Namaz.”

He said: “What will we do in that case? Should we allow that?”

Being pressed further that it was only the temple society’s hypothetical fear, Mr. Bhowmik said if Mr. Rahman was too keen on performing the ritual of his wife he should do that at his home. “Why insist on a temple in Delhi? Why doesn’t he do it at his home in Kolkata?”

But Mr. Rahman countered the allegations saying faith was a personal matter for him and it had never hurt his relationship with his “practising Hindu wife” as she would perform any ritual the way she wanted and he would do it his way. “This time I wanted to do it her way because she would have wanted to me do it like that. But am not being allowed.” He has not been able to hold the shradh ritual till now.

Top News Today

Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.