Narendra Modi's visit to Israel

‘Moshe doesn’t know how his parents died’

Moshe with Modi. PTI  

Moshe, the young survivor of the Chabad House killings during the 26/11 Mumbai attacks of 2008, could grow up one day to return to Mumbai and continue his parents’ work at the Jewish centre, his grandparents said here on Wednesday.

“Yes, he is studying like his parents did, and will one day serve as his mother Rivka and father Gavriel did,” said Mr. Holtzberg, his paternal grandfather, who flew in with his wife from New York ahead of a meeting with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Israel PM Benjamin Netanyahu. Rivka and Gavriel Holtzberg, who were working in Mumbai at the time, were gunned down by LeT terrorists who stormed the Chabad House and took them hostage first.

Echoing the sentiment, his maternal grandparents Rabbi Shimon and Yehudit Rosenberg also told The Hindu: “Yes, Moshe will return to Mumbai, his parents’ home is his home. Maybe, one day he will be the chief Rabbi [Jewish priest] of Mumbai.”

The family, along with Moshe’s nanny Sandra Samuel, who escaped from the Chabad House at Nariman point with an infant Moshe and then moved to Israel to help bring him up, met the two Prime Ministers for an emotional meeting at the PM’s hotel. During the meeting with Moshe, now 11 years old, Mr. Modi offered him and the family long-term visas to visit India “any time.”

During the 26/11 Mumbai attacks of 2008, Sandra Samuel escaped from the Chabad House at Nariman point with baby Moshe and then moved to Israel to help bring him up. Moshe’s parents Rivka and Gabriel Holtzberg were killed in the terror attack.

Ms. Samuel, who has been recognised as an honorary citizen of Israel for saving Moshe, said she was grateful for the gesture from Mr. Modi, offering them long-term visas to visit India “any time.”


Asked whether she had ever reconsidered her decision to move to Israel with Moshe, leaving her own family in India, she said: “My children were grown up and didn’t need me as much. I couldn’t have sent Moshe alone,” said Ms. Samuel, who now works in Jerusalem with children with special needs and visits Moshe at weekends.

Asked whether she had followed the investigation and trial of the 26/11 attacks in India and Pakistan, Ms. Samuel said she preferred not to, nor had anyone told Moshe of how his parents died. He now attends a Yeshiva (religious school) and is being brought up as an orthodox Jew by his grandparents, who hope to bring him to Mumbai for his Bar Mitzvah or Jewish confirmation ceremony.

“I have my life which is very busy, and Moshe boy is here. If I get involved [in the latest news of the 26/11 investigation and trial], if at all I put a step [forward], he will follow [me]. And I don’t want that,” she said.

Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Oct 27, 2021 3:02:54 AM |

In This Package
Narendra Modi pays homage to Indian World War I heroes at Haifa
Prime Minister Narendra Modi takes a stroll with his Israeli counterpart Benjamin Netanyahu at the Olga Beach near Hadera on Thursday
Modi bids 'shalom' after business end of his trip
Indian, Israeli defence firms join hands
At Haifa, a salute to Indian heroes of Great War
Visit marks rupture in stance: CPI(M)
Narendra Modi’s Israel visit: Top quotes
Jewish community has enriched India with their contribution, says Modi
Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks during a reception for the Indian community in Israel, in Tel Aviv.
People of Indian origin in Israel to get OCI card: Modi
India, Israel to set up $40 mn research fund
You are reading
‘Moshe doesn’t know how his parents died’
Come and stay in India, Modi tells 26/11 Israeli child survivor
We waited 70 years, Bibi tells Modi
Narendra Modi and Benjamin Netanyahu in Jerusalem.
Indian cultural centre in Israel soon
Narendra Modi and Benjamin Netanyahu giving a statement ahead of dinner with the Israeli PM
Modi in Israel: Of Gujarati businessmen and flowers
Prime Ministers Narendra Modi and Benjamin Netanyahu at the Danziger Flower farm.
New Israeli flower named after PM Modi
Remembering Holocaust victims
Modi and Netanyahu visited the grave of Theodor Herzl
Modi makes impromptu visit to grave of Zionism’s founder
Spices, masala chai, Bollywood in the promised land
Israel Prime Minister Benjami Netanyahu accords a red carpet welcome to Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Tel Aviv airport.
Modi in Israel: 'we have been waiting for you for 70 years,' says Netanyahu
Israel backs India's fight on terror
Israel to work on food security in India
Indian Embassy will remain in Tel Aviv: Modi
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas being received by President Pranab Mukherjee and PM Narendra Modi at Rashtrapati Bhavan in May 2017.
On the eve of PM’s tour, Palestine hopes to keep India ties firm
Mission Maccabiah: this year in Israel
‘India-Israel ties on a steady upward trend’
Modi to call on Israeli boy who lost parents in 26/11
Narendra Modi, Amarnath Yatra pilgrims
Israel to roll out red carpet for Modi
Diaspora groups promote India-Israel-U.S partnership in security, technology cooperation
India's policy shift reflects improvement in ties: Israel envoy
From startup nation to orthodox state
Namaste Israel
Homes that don't belong
Israel’s many flashpoints
Hummus with roti, anyone?
Next Story