Debate turns vitriolic in Brazil as impeachment vote nears

Barbs like "putschists" and "thieves" fly freely between Dilma Rousseff's friends and foes.

April 17, 2016 11:59 am | Updated November 17, 2021 04:36 am IST - BRASILIA:

A stencil image of Brazil President Dilma Rousseff created by a t-shirt artist is seen at a 'Carnival for Democracy' on Saturday in Rio de Janeiro. The President's friends and foes called each other “putchists” and “thieves” ahead of Sunday’s vote in Congress’ lower house on whether to proceed with her impeachment

A stencil image of Brazil President Dilma Rousseff created by a t-shirt artist is seen at a 'Carnival for Democracy' on Saturday in Rio de Janeiro. The President's friends and foes called each other “putchists” and “thieves” ahead of Sunday’s vote in Congress’ lower house on whether to proceed with her impeachment

Friends and foes of Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff called each other “putschists” and “thieves” ahead of Sunday’s vote in Congress’ lower house on whether to proceed with her impeachment, as unprecedented levels of vitriol sparked fears of violence.

Emotions have been running high since the impeachment proceedings began in the Chamber of Deputies on Friday, with lawmakers holding a raucous, name-calling session. Outside the legislature, waves of pro- and anti-impeachment demonstrators are expected to flood the capital of Brasilia on Sunday. A metal wall was installed earlier this week to keep the rival sides safely apart.

Mantle may pass on to Temer

If 342 of the lower house’s 513 lawmakers vote in favour of the impeachment on Sunday, the proceedings move to the Senate, where a separate vote could suspend Ms. Rousseff and hand over the top job to Vice President Michel Temer, who Ms. Rousseff has blasted in recent days as being part of the push against her.

If lawmakers vote against impeachment, this particular bid to oust Ms. Rousseff would be dead and any subsequent process would have to start over again.

Too close to call

Newspapers have been updating their tallies on an almost hourly basis. With the result appearing to hang on the votes of a couple dozen undecided lawmakers, it’s too close to call.

Brazil’s President is facing impeachment over allegations she broke fiscal laws. Her detractors describe the sleight-of-hand accounting as a bid to boost her government’s floundering popularity amid a tanking economy and a corruption scandal so widespread it has taken down top public figures from across the political spectrum, as well as some of the country’s richest businessmen.

Denies wrongdoing

Ms. Rousseff denies wrongdoing, pointing out that prior presidents have used similar accounting techniques. The allegations, she insists, are part of a “coup” spearheaded by Brazil’s traditional ruling elite to snatch power back from her left-leaning Workers’ Party, which has governed the nation for the past 13 years.

The key vote comes as Latin America’s largest nation is dealing with problems on many fronts. The economy is contracting, inflation is around 10 percent and an outbreak of the Zika virus, which can cause devastating birth defects, has ravaged parts of north-eastern states. Rio de Janeiro is gearing up to host the Olympics in August, but sharp budget cuts have fuelled worries about whether the country will be ready to host.

Case of doctor cure thyself

As Ms. Rousseff’s impeachment has gone from a remote to a concrete possibility, concern about her potential replacements has grown. There has also been increasing anger over the irony that many of the people pushing to oust her face serious allegations of corruption themselves.

Mr. Temer, a 75-year-old with the Brazilian Democratic Movement -- a party bereft of any concrete ideology that has a reputation for backroom-wheeling and dealing – and he has tried to cast himself as a statesman above the fray and a unifying force that can heal a scarred nation.

Or, will it be Eduardo Cunha?

The second in line to replace Ms. Rousseff is Chamber of Deputies Speaker Eduardo Cunha, the driving force behind the impeachment and a long-time enemy of Ms. Rousseff. He’s facing money-laundering and other charges for allegedly accepting some $5 million in kickbacks in connection with the Petrobras scheme and could also be stripped of his mandate over allegations he lied when he told a congressional committee he didn’t hold any foreign bank accounts. Documents later emerged linking him and his family to Swiss bank accounts.

May be, Renan Calheiros

The third in line, Senate head Renan Calheiros, is also facing multiple corruption allegations in the Petrobras probe; more than half the 65 members of the committee in the lower house that endorsed the impeachment are also facing corruption and other charges, as are some 60 per cent of the country 594 members of Congress.

Under the special legal status afforded to Brazilian legislators and other top politicians, they must be tried by the Supreme Court, largely shielding them from prosecutions.

Holier than thou

Ms. Rousseff has made much hay of the corruption allegations dogging her enemies, insisting that she’s the only one not besmirched by corruption.

The argument appears to have struck a chord, even with the ardent impeachment supporters.

“I would feel much more comfortable if someone clean with no charges, no allegations were leading this process, but that’s hard to find in the Brazilian Congress,” said Douglas Sandri, a 25-year-old electrical engineer who traveled from the southern city of Porto Alegre to take part in pro—impeachment demonstrations. “If Temer is found to be corrupt, he will have to go, and all the others too.”

But while much of the public appears to share Sandri’s toss-them-all-out attitude, the corruption allegations casting a pall on Ms. Rousseff’s potential substitutes don’t appear to bother the impeachment’s backers inside the Chamber of Deputies.

Presumption of innocence

“The presumption of innocence is a fundamental clause of our Constitution. Being charged or being the defendant in a case doesn’t make a person dishonest,” said Hiran Goncalves, a representative from the Amazonian state of Roraima who has come out in favour of impeachment.

Deputies planning to vote against impeachment have highlighted the alleged corruption of their colleagues, particularly Mr. Cunha, during the debate over the weekend.

Ms. Rousseff is “an honest woman and Cunha is corrupt,” said Moema Gramacho, a representative from Salvador who wore a sash with the words, “Out with Cunha!”

0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in

Comments

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.