Mozart’s last work was as mysterious as it was moving

Mozart’s Requiem, a choral masterpiece, was performed recently at the Chowdiah Memorial Hall by Swedish and Indian musicians

January 30, 2024 06:18 pm | Updated January 31, 2024 06:41 pm IST

The huge choir group that presented the evening of music.

The huge choir group that presented the evening of music. | Photo Credit: Siva Raj

Swedish mezzo soprano/conductor Maria Forsstrom and pianist Bengt Forsberg, who delighted audiences in Bengaluru last year with Faure’s Requiem, were again in town, primarily for a performance of Mozart’s Requiem, a far more ambitious venture than their previous offering. They generously provided audiences with solo performances as well.

Given that the Swedish visitors were here for a short time prior to the main performance, great practical hurdles had to be overcome. Rehearsals required the assembling of two choirs of 47 people, and the Bangalore School of Music’s Chamber Orchestra, all people with full-time occupations. So it is even more creditable that such a production was undertaken and played to a full house at the Chowdiah Memorial Hall recently.

The Mozart evening started with individual contributions: Abendempfindung K523 was a strangely lugubrious opening. Though written at the same time as ‘Don Giovanni’ and ‘Eine Kleine Nachtmusik’, it had neither the dramatic melodiousness of the opera’s arias nor the light charm of the latter. Instead, the melancholy piece dealt with a lover’s failed relationship and thoughts of death. But Maria’s feeling rendition could not have the desired effect on the audience, unfamiliar with German.

The mood was soon leavened with the Piano Concerto #12 in A Major. Joined by the strings of the BSM Chamber Music Orchestra, with Bengt masterful at the piano, and Maria conducting, this example of the composer’s early work was enjoyable, though not as substantial as his more mature work. As always, the second movement ‘Andante’ was most appealing, its wistful melody, perhaps, an epitaph to Mozart’s former mentor Bach, who had just died. In the third movement ‘Allegretto’, the strings had a more active role, picking up some of the piano’s phrases. The evening’s main attraction, Mozart’s Requiem came after the intermission.

The programme notes (though the font was very small!) gave deserved credit to all the individual performers, besides being very informative.

Swedish mezzo soprano/conductor Maria Forsstrom and pianist Bengt Forsberg with Indian musicians at the show.

Swedish mezzo soprano/conductor Maria Forsstrom and pianist Bengt Forsberg with Indian musicians at the show. | Photo Credit: Siva Raj

It is ironic that this popular work is known as Requiem, for Mozart died before it was completed and many composers have claimed its creation, or parts thereof. Mozart’s pupil Süssmayer was left with specific instructions for its completion. He collated his master’s sheet music but falsified the date of completion, adding the inscription “di me (“by me”) W. A. Mozart /1792”, and rewrote the entire composition in his own hand, making it impossible to identify the Mozart sections definitively. But Beethoven was dismissive of such doubts: “If Mozart did not write the music, then the man who wrote it was a Mozart”, and Beethoven’s admiration of the work is probably the reason it was played at the younger composer’s Memorial Mass.

The choice of von Spengel’s arrangement for strings and organ of the Requiem was dictated by the difficulty of assembling a full orchestra, underlining the drawbacks of launching an amateur production. The Introitus — a subdued opening at the best of times — made even less impact, with only string accompaniment. In the poignant sections of the work, Mozart used woodwind; and brass and timpani for the baleful Confutatis, though the choir provided the same formidable equivalent in the Dies Irae, where Mozart uses the choir’s homophonic and homorhythmic texture to convey the desperation of the text. In the Tuba Mirum [“Hark the Trumpet”], one missed the trombone that buoys up the wonderful bass voice. The electronic organ provided basso continuo, but did not compensate for the lack of brass and woodwind.

Maria Forsstrom conducting the choir.

Maria Forsstrom conducting the choir. | Photo Credit: Siva Raj

Soprano Payal John, though lovely in voice, was rather soft when she started [though mics were judiciously interspersed] and lacked impact.

However, the four soloists were a pleasure to hear, particularly in the Recordare, the adverse drama of the previous sections alleviated by their lovely intertwined melodies.

Conducting the ensemble seemed challenging for Maria. Though the chorists [who had to convey Mozart’s intricate contrapuntal strata] were more aware of the many layers that create unified music. For, she found that the orchestra had insufficient training in that individual players be cognisant not only of their instrument, but also what every other member is doing and how they mesh together, the conductor’s job being to pull everything together into musical cohesion. Both Maria and Bengt gave master classes at the BSM but did not find anyone studying to be a conductor, so perhaps classes should be initiated in music conducting, as it seems a role begging to be filled.

Maria’s labours were rewarded as the Requiem was a great success, and it is to be repeated at St Mark’s Cathedral in March, and it may also be taken to Puducherry.

0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.