Law Minister Kapil Sibal’s proposal that the government have a say in judicial appointments, if implemented, will set a bad precedent. It would be much against the principle of separation of powers enshrined so thoughtfully in the Constitution. It could seriously undermine the independence of the judiciary.

The appointment of public prosecutors and government pleaders on political and other considerations has already had a telling effect on the effective functioning of courts.

Ramakrishna Thakur,


Today, the judiciary is the only strong pillar of democracy. Whimsical appointment of judges will sound the death knell for the justice delivery system.

K. Pradeep,


Is Mr. Sibal’s observation a prelude to creating a “committed judiciary,” a pet theme of the Congress during the Emergency days?

V. Padmanabhan,


More In: Letters | Opinion