Why a single bypoll in Andhra Pradesh has gained national significance and could affect the government at the Centre.
Rarely has so much money been spent in an election just to reduce a candidate's winning margin. (Or to increase it, depending on whose side you are on). Seldom have two major political parties fought so hard, knowingly, for second place, as the Congress and the Telugu Desam Party have in the Kadapa parliamentary constituency bypoll (voting tomorrow). And while rival parties often claim the same leader's legacy, it isn't often that one of them first abuses that leader as corrupt and then seeks votes in his name. Which the Congress has done in Kadapa, in a massive effort to humble Jaganmohan Reddy of the YSR Congress (son of Chief Minister Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy who died in 2009).
As many as 14 Ministers have campaigned in this Lok Sabha seat with over 13 lakh voters in Andhra Pradesh's Rayalaseema region. There is a Minister in charge of each of its seven Assembly segments running the campaign round the clock, while several others, including Chief Minister Kiran Reddy flit in and out. In the Pulivendula segment, YSR's own brother (Agriculture Minister till the elections), is pitted against YSR's widow Vijayamma in a bypoll to the State legislature. The Congress candidate challenging Jagan Reddy, D.L. Ravindra Reddy, is presently Health Minister. The joke here is that the Andhra Pradesh Cabinet meets more often in Kadapa than in Hyderabad. Factor in Chiranjeevi, and the firepower deployed by the Congress is awesome. In the process, what might have been just another bypoll now commands national significance.
TDP chief Chandrababu Naidu has tried lifting the spirits of his party's cadre and boosting their candidate, M.V. Mysoora Reddy. The party publicly claims a coming victory. As its leaders point out: “a vertical split in the Congress — which is what Jagan's party represents — can only favour us.” In 2009, a united Congress with YSR at the helm saw Jagan beat his TDP rival with a margin of 1.78 lakh votes in an almost straight fight. Mr. Chiranjeevi's PRP bagged just 63,000 votes. “With Chiranjeevi joining the Congress, even if that party retains a third of its own vote, it means our man will beat Jagan.” That's the TDP's seductive logic.
Yet, party leaders know they are fighting for the second place. Mr. Chiranjeevi's votes have faded. Major local TDP leaders have joined the Congress in recent months. Most significantly, large numbers of people across many mandals in Kadapa are voting not so much for Jagan as for his father. “People are voting for YSR,” says Shankar Reddy, a four-acre cotton grower in Cherulopalli village of Pendlimarri mandal. He believes the TDP will come third in his segment. “When Naidu was Chief Minister, life was a constant harassment. The authorities would cut off our electricity and water when the crops most needed it, demanding payment of bills on heavily raised rates we could not afford. Many of us were ruined that way, our crop wasted. YSR treated us better.” Everywhere, there are references to the latter's welfare programmes, rice at Rs. 2 a kilo and more.
Meanwhile, farmers like Ramanjaneyulu Reddy in Mallepalli village of Vempalli mandal are amused: “We are getting seven hours of electricity every day now for our fields. Only because there is a bypoll on.” And, says a cynical voter in Chapadu town: “It will end on the evening of polling day. Then it will be back to two or three hours in the fields.”
“We are getting barely Rs. 60 (less than half the wage),” say labourers at an MGNREGS site in Cheemalapenti village in Pendlimarri Mandal. Women workers say they get even less. However, Dalit labourers are most reluctant to discuss the polls. This feudal district's history of repression of Dalits has taught them caution. Even so, those from the Mala community seem to favour Jagan Reddy, again on account of his father, not the candidate himself. There are also complaints of intimidation by local authorities. Many with old case records, some of them trivial, have been summoned to police stations and are on a leash till the polls end. Since ordinary folk have also had cases foisted on them in the past in a region notorious for arbitrary abuse of power, they see this as persecution by the Congress government.
The Congress has charged Jagan Reddy with gross corruption and highlighted his rapid amassment of wealth. (His election affidavit declares his worth, along with his wife, at Rs. 430 crore). Yet, this hasn't cut much ice, even with those acknowledging the seriousness of the charges. For them, these bypolls are about doing justice to YSR's memory. That the corruption charges come from a Congress party swimming in scams reduces their weight. In Kadapa town, the Congress office sports a huge picture of YSR. But in the villages, hostile voters have told its campaigners to replace his posters with those of Sonia and Rahul Gandhi “when you are fighting his family.”
In the Pulivendula Assembly constituency, Vivekandanda Reddy is putting up a spirited fight against his sister-in-law Vijayamma. Here, the contest is keener. YSR's brother is well regarded. “We took our problems to him even when YSR was alive,” said several male voters. However, women see Vijayamma as grievously wronged and could turn out in strength for her. “We are all for her,” says Gangamma, a landless labourer in Thumalapalli village of Tondur Mandal. “She deserves justice.”
Certainly, the all-out effort of the Congress has improved its candidate's position. Only a few days ago, D. L. Ravindra was mocked as “Deposit Loss Ravindra.” He seems to have banished that and picked up steam with some aggressive campaigning. “Too little, too late,” says one senior TDP leader. “Not believing they could win, they started too late. Now their high-voltage campaign has made Jagan a hero. First they cracked down on his yatras and padayatras, making him a Statewide figure. Then they fight him like this, giving this election national significance. Had they said ‘in respect for the memory of our leader YSR, we will not contest against his wife and son,' that would have ended the story. Now, defeat will be humiliating.”
Expenditures have been staggering. Several voters told us they had been paid Rs. 500 each to favour particular candidates. "That's in the villages," scoff people in Mydukuru. "Here in the towns the rate is Rs. 1,000 to Rs. 2,000." Besides, with local community heads being enticed by huge sums, leaders allege that over Rs. 200 crore has already been spent by all those in the contest. Police, under Election Commission directions, have seized nearly Rs. 3 crore during vehicle checks. That sum mounts hourly, while more cases evade detection. Everyone says the day before voting will see the maximum ‘buying’. The EC has ordered the district’s 22 banks to report any transaction of over Rs. 50,000. It has also ordered deployment of 11,100 security personnel, a record for a single constituency (one with an awful history of violence and rigging). Meanwhile, it has served 39 notices relating to “Paid News” on Mr. Jaganmohan Reddy, and four and three respectively on his TDP and Congress rivals. His mother Vijayamma (7) and her rival Vivekananda Reddy (2) have also been served such notices.
Why is the margin of victory so crucial? In 2009, Jagan's lead of 1.78 lakh came in an almost straight fight against the TDP. Now there are three major candidates. Retaining that margin would be hard. Bettering it would be astonishing. Many Congress MPs and MLAs are close to Jagan Reddy, even a few now campaigning against him. The same or bigger margin this time could see Congress MLAs switching sides. More embarrassingly, he might get 20-25 of them and even a few MPs to resign, forcing by-elections in their seats. Which means the Congress could unravel in Andhra Pradesh — from where it has 33 MPs in the Lok Sabha, its highest from any State.
Already, people are restless. Though Mr. Kiran Reddy has tried in recent weeks to galvanise its functioning, many feel there is no government at all. The welfare programmes that did the party proud in 2009 seem paralysed. On Telangana, the Congress has painted itself into a corner. Its internal surveys show the party doing badly across the State, should there be an election. Having staked so much prestige on a by-election they feel they cannot win, Congress campaigners talk of shredding Jagan's margin. Managing that might deflate his tyres and discourage would-be defectors.
The TDP struggles for relevance. Voters have not yet forgiven Mr. Naidu's regime. A third place in both battles, in a district from which they sent members to the legislature, could affect his party Statewide. It needs to nose ahead of the Congress — and cut the winner's margin. As for Jagan, anything short of a big win could disrupt his drive to power.
The Kadapa margin is now a live sport for the State's betting industry, with books opening on the race even in coastal Andhra. The betting is on the margin, not on the result. A margin that could affect not just Kadapa politics but the government at the Centre itself.
Keywords: Congress, Telugu Desam Party, Kadapa bypoll, YSR,



I have read this article after the reults in the bypolls. Amazing Article. In my opinion it is a rarity to read such a well evaluated and interestily written Artilce. Thank you for relevant reporting and maintaining good standards of journalism.
Governing the state is not the main assignment of ruling party. Winning the election game at any cost is their motto. They are mad with money and power.
Geetha Well said, YSR set bar too high in every aspect. It is very hard to find a leader with similar attributes neither in Congress nor in state.
Again for the people who said this election is unnecessary, JAGAN is not forced elections just to prove himself from same party like all TRS KSR did. He resigned and resigned and contested from same party TRS. Jagan formed his own party, he not at all belongs Congress any more. he can't continue as Congress MP/MLA (Viayamma) in the event of having their own party. They need participate in election regardless of win or lose. People neither believe Babu nor Chiranjeevi. We need to wait till May 13 whether JAGAN survives or not. I hope he will win with huge majority and teach lesson to Congress at state and central level for autocratic way of functioning and disrespecting great leader YSR.
These days almost everybody seems to have an axe to grind.Sainath's objective,non-partisan,and incisive analyses are therefore like a breath od fresh air.
Can't even imagine that the whole nation is in such a sorry state. But, even in these troubled times there is still some hope when there are persons like P Sainath who constantly highlight issues of the marginalized people.
A recent song "India i cry" by remo fernandes aptly describes the situation in our country.
Congress did a mistake by deploying 14 ministers in the bypoll campaign and giving vigorous hype which made Jagan as hero and made Hindu to write this article. Jagan Reddy has been hell-bent on chief post of Andhra, in that process he is trying to show his strength to Congress high command and to attract his fellow MLA’s and MP’s to bring cracks in central and state government. We have to wait and see the consequences but finally this election increased the vote rate vigorously.
Sainath: Your Analysis is spot on. "First they cracked down on his yatras and padayatras, making him a Statewide figure. Then they fight him like this, giving this election national significance" I completely agree this, I am sure Congress strategists will agree but they are digging the hole deeper rather than thinking how to come out of it hence mistake after mistake is piling on them.Second part of the comment is .Had they said 'in respect for the memory of our leader YSR, we will not contest against his wife and son,' that would have ended the story. Now, defeat will be humiliating. It is impossible for congress to act the way you suggested simply because they lack the able state level leadership ( ..or center may not allow) hence many power centers with competing interests both at state and center level will never allow them to act the way you suggested though it is good one to give a serious thought. The destiny of the A.P congress neither depends on Mr Jagan Reddy nor on so called Telangana issue but it solely depends on Two issues 1) effective administration (fortunately or Unfortunately Late YSR set the bar very high) 2) Providing able leadership and guidance to the party as cohesive unit(here too Late YSR's bench mark is much higher)
Yes the comment made by Mr.Venkataramana is worthy and meaningful. Just for showing his personal capacity Jagan resigned his LS seat. How much public money got wasted by repeat election processes. After all he is planning to bring down elected AP Government to show his strength state wise. After making fools in own constituency also trying to make fools entire state. Has ever he think about how much Public money going to be wasted? How much time going to be wasted?? How much work going to be lost?? Whether he is thinking AP State is like play ground or his personal property ? If somebody wish to resign their elected post, leave. Don't come again into the field.
There will be absolutely no good done to people of Kadapa no matter whoever mentioned above wins this election. Ultimately its a drama where people loose again. Until people realise that their vote is for their future but not for the future of Jagan or Chiranjeevi or someelse change will not be possible in Andhra Politics.
Best of pieces! P Sainath and 'The Hindu', thanks a lot. Sometimes readers get opportunity to read excellent story in 'The Hindu' in lucid style and also in good literary flavour- That is Sainath Style. Readers like me realise how an election report in impartial way is drafted and made by a good craftmanship- readers look so many stories on elections. About Andhra by-poll, Sainath has written everthing what is needed in election report- it automatically makes clear , who is in better position- this should be style of election coverage! Sainath has pointed out everything right from money power menace in the elections to stake of political parties in the elections. As regards Narega, Sainath has rightly stated how the poor people are deprived their full wages In Andhra Pradesh and also electricity provision in the election scheduled areas throughout the country. This has become common practice throughout the country-whereever there is elections, uninterrupted power is provided in the areas and once the election is over- it goes off like anything. About Narega wage, Sainath has said the right thing- In Bihar itself in most parts of rural areas of the state, Narega wages are gobbled up in totality after preparing bogus master roll and many tactics. Corruptions, particularly in Bihar is at the top Bihar with regards to Narega and welfare schemes in rural areas- no work is carried , no listed labour is engaged- and fund meant for the scheme is shiphonned off by officials and panchayat functionaries- this is what happening and I Have studied the problems in rural areas- and uneployed among poor are not getting their due Narega shares!
I just like to know how far we can publish article with this content (Almost mentioneing that Jagan going to win) day before election? Won't it affect public decision making?
Whatever may be the result of this bypoll, one thing is certain. The taxpayers' money is being wasted. These elections are unnecessarily thrust upon the people of the constituency just to show how powerful are they. Now a days it has become a political game to resign at the drop of the hat and to contest immediately for that seat. Election Commission should propose an amendment to the Act that in case of resigning a member to the seat he held without any justifyable reason, then the second in the contest should be elected to that seat.
The Congress is fighting a losing battle. There is little or no governance in the State. It is time that they quit office and Jagan will force them to do it.
Please Email the Editor