Today's Paper Archive Classifieds Subscriptions RSS Feeds Site Map ePaper Mobile Apps Social
SEARCH

National » Karnataka

Updated: March 12, 2012 20:00 IST

Mourning an ‘illegal' treasure trove

ANINDITA MUKHERJEE
Share  ·   Comment (1)   ·   print   ·  
ANINDITA MUKHERJEE
ANINDITA MUKHERJEE

There is an angry, disgruntled buzz in several universities across India as students discover that their rock of refuge during research has been shut down by the order of a court in Munich.

Library.nu, the website in question, functioned as a veritable Makkah of “illegal” online knowledge, where an eclectic collection of rare monographs, recent academic books and lengthy treatises could be downloaded for free. A coalition of 17 of the world's largest publishing houses put paid to this venture, describing it as “one of the largest pirate Web-based businesses in the world”.

The website was definitely engaging in “illegal” activities: making over 4,00,000 copyrighted books available online without permission and for no charge is undeniably against the law as it stands today. However, as the outpour of public anger about this decision indicates, there are deeper questions involved.

While Tom Allen, president and chief executive officer, Association of American Publishers, considers the injunction “a significant step in shutting down two major rogue websites stealing content from publishers and others”, and an indication of the need for additional tools to expedite such action, the ends achieved by the injunction remain suspect.

Library.nu, for innumerable users, was a source of otherwise inaccessible research material. The claim of publishing houses that this e-book piracy was leading to mammoth losses is, therefore, questionable. Shutting library.nu only makes a huge mass of research inaccessible to a global audience.

The Internet, since the time of Napster, has served as a marvellous platform to facilitate dissemination of information. Presuming that the aim of academia is to further scholarship and provide insights, such a platform would seem god-send. Instead, there is a call from a gargantuan international alliance of publishers to develop tools to prevent “piracy” while no moves are made to ensure that concerns of accessibility are addressed.

The concept of open access could apply just as well to any academic material. Once it is acknowledged that royalties are not the only ends of academic scholarship, the obvious plus point of an enhanced readership becomes important. Studies of open access journal entries indicate much higher readership and a greater likelihood of being cited.

Further, while there is no direct evidence showing a fall in sales of books when they are pirated online, several authors have found interest in and sales of their books being boosted because of the buzz created by pirated e-versions: Paulo Coelho being the most obvious example. This makes for an interesting middle-ground between open-access scholarship and its closed-access counterpart. Could publishers continue to sell books while turning a blind eye to free “pirated” versions of the same book being available online for people to avail of? Recent events show that this probably is the most plausible option available. In either case, given the nature of the Internet, the publisher coalition seems to be set on fighting a losing battle. The angry buzz in colleges is quickly being replaced with the name of a newly-discovered treasure trove of free knowledge.

(The author is pursuing a BA. LL.B. (Hons.) degree at Nalsar University of Law, Hyderabad.)

The Point is NCERT and IGNOU in India provide free access to their materials/booklets/books and there has been no sign of slow down in their actual hard-copy sales.Flipkart and Infibeam have convinced publishers to give concessions and achieve greater sales. Even if someone has an e-book for free, If s/he would like to read as a printed copy then the higher chance is to get it from Flipkart or Infibeam rather than printing it from the local cyber cafe. The price of international books need to suit Indian requirements and Indian editions should be published. By closing down Library. The gain is for the big publishers who prepare books for elite libraries not for individual/student readings.Free materials by NCERT and IGNOU have helped many of us in preparation of competitive exams and they should be thanked for their great service to learning.

from:  Kamala Kanta Dash
Posted on: Mar 14, 2012 at 15:03 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Bangalore

Mangalore


O
P
E
N

close

Recent Article in Karnataka

B. Janardhana Poojary

No fatigue, candidates back in action

A day after polling, key contenders for the Dakshina Kannada Lok Sabha seat were back to their regular activity, with one of them even s... »