Features » Magazine

Updated: September 7, 2013 19:19 IST

Fantasy in verse

Indira Parthasarathy
Comment (7)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
Illustration: P. Manivannan
The Hindu
Illustration: P. Manivannan

Bharati’s Kuyil Paattu doesn’t offer lessons. It’s simply a remarkable illustration of the poet’s private voice.

Once a saint was cursed to be a pig. He felt humiliated. So he asked his son to kill him soon after the transformation. The moment his father became a pig, his obedient son approached him to put an end to his ‘cursed state’. But his father had second thoughts. He told his son ‘Let me experience being a pig. You may come after a few months to kill me.’

When the son came after six months to carry out his father’s order, the saint-turned-pig told him that he really enjoyed being a pig and that he was revelling in the company of other boisterous pigs. ‘If you feel ashamed, you may kill yourself,” he added.

This is a story from one of the Upanishads, which Mahakavi Subramania Bharati narrates in a poem addressed to the goddess of poetry. He likens himself to the saint in the story. He says, “When I was a young poet, I was committed to the Muse totally. But circumstances have led me to renounce my absolute dedication to pure poetry.”

What does Bharati mean by ‘pure poetry’? Apparently, Bharati had two voices in him and one was his private voice, rhapsodic, lyrical and spontaneous and the other, his public voice that led him to identify himself with the political and social causes of his slumbering nation.

In a poem addressed to Parasakthi (Primeval Power) he says: “When I pray to you with the burning fire of intense love and appeal to you to bless me with words of power that will usher a new era of social progress, you tell me with a mysterious smile on your face that a poem well written is by itself the message and it should have no other thematic burden.”

What is Parasakthi? Bharati describes it variously as ‘the sparkling soul of the Dark Night’, ‘wisdom in stone’, ‘when time has a stop, the Eternity of the Moment’ and ‘pure ecstasy well-expressed’. When he is in this mood, his voice is free-flowing, not given to any homiletic pressure. This is his private voice, which has been, unfortunately, least studied by most of the Bharati scholars.

Kuyil Paattu (Cuckoo’s Song) remarkably illustrates his private voice. It deals with neither a political nor a social issue. The poem reads as though it wrote itself. It is in direct conversation with the reader, emanating as it does from the inner voice of the poet. Bharati calls it ‘a dream’ and mischievously adds, which reads like a challenge, “if the learned Tamil scholars are able to find a philosophical meaning for this poem let them tell me.”

And ‘the learned Tamil scholars’ did not disappoint him! One tried to find ‘the Paramatma and Jivatma relationship’ syndrome in the poem and another called it ‘the poet’s spiritual journey from the known to the unknown’. More such stuff and nonsense followed, while interpreting this poem.

What, then, does the poem tell us? It reads like a fairy tale not committed to logic or reason. It is a fantasy, a dream à la Coleridge’s Kubla Khan. The dream constructs a story and there is a story within that story. The whole thing is an illusion and there are illusions within that illusion. It is like a wheel within a wheel and one is at a loss to know which is an illusion and which reality. The reality comes at the end, as the poet wakes up to find himself ‘living in his old house, surrounded by his ancient mat, writing pen and scattered manuscripts and magazines.’

The recurring theme of love is expressed in exquisite poetry in a universal language, unburdened by thematic or critical conventions. It is a pure poem of sheer aesthetic charm that does not assume the moral responsibility of offering any message to the reader.

The medium is the message.

An excerpt from an English translation

The cuckoo sings its love for the monkey:

‘Oh! My divine Monkey-Lover!

Can any woman resist your love?

Man thinks he is the Lord of the Earth!

Maybe, he is for such mundane matters

As institutionalising things!

But look! Your incomparable hairy chest

And gentle speech,

And your bewitching hunch that adds a gait

To your walk and stature

Of no less charm

Can man be equal to you?

True, he competes with you

Covers his body with umpteen clothes

To match your silken charm from head to foot,

Apes his face and chin with hairy growth

In poor imitation calling it beard and moustache!

Leaps and jumps as you do

But, he does in a drunken state,

But, yet, tell me

Where will he go for a god-given tail?

More In: Magazine | Features

I have a lot of respect for Indira Parthasarathy. I believe in this
explanation of Bharathiyar's Kuyil Pattu he got it totally wrong.

As he says, "More such stuff and nonsense followed, while interpreting
this poem."... This is one such stuff.

Expect great things from the author.

from:  Srivathsan
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 19:15 IST

If Kuyil Paattu does not give any lessons, what does bharati mean by the following line in
Kuyil Paattu? -"Vedanta maratthiloru veraik kanden" isn't he alluding something here?

from:  Ganesh V
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 14:02 IST

Long Live Bharathi!!
Undoubtedly, his writings are immortal!!

Bharathi - Elixir of Life

from:  Vikram K
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 10:20 IST

Very nice write up about kuyil pattu. Initially I was not keen to read kuyil pattu,after reading
once I have indulged in many times in reading kuyil pattu. He is poetic genius, spiritual
prodigy,. Thanks for the author .

from:  Pn
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 08:31 IST

i had never heard of "bharati" before i read it here in Hindu.the
article is thought provoking and more.thanks to this,i know another
amazing indian poet now. :)

from:  ashish sharma
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 06:44 IST

No one can equal Bharati. Long time back I attended in Calcutta a "Patti Manram" asking Is Bharati a Scholar, Poet, Saint, Musicians or a patriot ? But alas no one was able to describe him fully. He is all in all that's all.

from:  Mani Iyer
Posted on: Sep 8, 2013 at 04:21 IST

Wonderful article about the Mahakavi and his fantasy poem "Kuyil Paatu".
Thank you Mr Indira Parthasarathy.

from:  Ashwin Seshadri
Posted on: Sep 7, 2013 at 23:09 IST
Show all comments
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Amandeep Sandhu, Manjul Bajaj, Manu Joseph and Sonora Jha read from their novels that were shortlisted for The Hindu Prize for Fiction 2013. Ziya Us Salam introduces them and moderates the session. <... »



Recent Article in Magazine


What an idea!

At Vikalp Sangam, everyone has a story. Mari Marcel Thekaekara is impressed with the impact their ideas make on society. »