Twitter Inc is coming under increasing pressure from its shareholders to negotiate with Elon Musk even though the world's richest person has called his $43 billion bid for the social media platform his best and final offer, people familiar with the matter said on Sunday.
While the views of Twitter shareholders vary over what a fair price for a deal would be, many reached out to the company after Mr. Musk outlined his acquisition financing plan on Thursday and urged it not to let the opportunity for a deal slip away, the sources said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
Twitter's board is expected to find that Mr. Musk's all-cash $54.20 per share offer for the company is too low by the time it reports quarterly earnings on Thursday. Nonetheless, some shareholders who agree with that stance still want Twitter to seek a better offer from Mr. Musk, whose net worth is pegged by Forbes at $270 billion, the sources told Reuters.
One option available to Twitter's board is to open its books to Mr. Musk to try to coax him to sweeten his bid. Another would be to solicit offers from other potential bidders. While it is not yet clear which path Twitter will take, it is increasingly likely that its board will attempt to solicit a better offer from Mr. Musk even as it rebuffs the current one, the sources said.
"I wouldn't be surprised to wake up next week and see Mr. Musk raises what he called his best and final offer to possibly $64.20 per share," one of the fund managers who is invested in Twitter said on condition of anonymity to discuss private conversations with the company.
"He could also drop the whole thing entirely. Anything is possible," the fund manager said about Mr. Musk's offer.
Twitter shares closed at $48.93 on Friday, a significant discount to Mr. Musk's offer that reflects the uncertainty over his bid's fate.
Twitter adopted a poison pill after Mr. Musk made his offer to prevent him from raising his more than 9% stake in the company above 15% without negotiating a deal with its board. In response, Mr. Musk has threatened to launch a tender offer that he could use to register Twitter shareholder support for his bid.
A concern that Twitter's board is weighing is that unless it seeks to negotiate a deal with Mr. Musk, many shareholders could back him in a tender offer, the sources said. While the poison pill would prevent Twitter shareholders from tendering their shares, the company is worried that its negotiating hand would weaken considerably if it were shown to be going against the will of many of its investors, the sources added.
Mr. Musk, the chief executive of electric car maker Tesla Inc. has been meeting with Twitter shareholders since he unveiled his offer on April 14, seeking support for his bid. Mr. Musk has said Twitter needs to be taken private to grow and become a genuine platform for free speech.
Representatives for Twitter and Mr. Musk did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The Wall Street Journal reported earlier on Sunday on some of Mr. Musk's meetings with Twitter shareholders. The newspaper also reported that Mr. Musk and Twitter would hold a meeting on Sunday to discuss the acquisition offer.
Intrinsic value
The price expectations among Twitter shareholders for the deal diverge largely based on their investment strategy, the sources said. Active long-term shareholders, who together with index funds hold the biggest chunk of Twitter shares, have higher price expectations, some in the $60s-per-share, the sources said. They are also more inclined to give Parag Agrawal, who became Twitter's chief executive in November, more time to boost the value of the company's stock, the sources added.
"I don't believe that the proposed offer by Elon Musk ($54.20 per share) comes close to the intrinsic value of Twitter given its growth prospects," Saudi Arabia's Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, a Twitter shareholder, tweeted on April 14.
Short term-minded investors such as hedge funds want Twitter to accept Musk's offer or ask for only a small increase, the sources said. Some of these are fretting that a recent plunge in the value of technology stocks amid concerns over inflation and an economic slowdown makes it unlikely Twitter will be able to deliver more value for itself anytime soon, the sources added.
"I would say, take the $54.20 a share and be done with it," said Sahm Adrangi, portfolio manager at Kerrisdale Capital Management, a hedge fund that owns 1.13 million shares in Twitter, or 0.15% of the company, and has been an investor since early 2020.
One silver lining for Twitter's board is that Mr. Musk's offer did not appear to convert his army of Twitter followers into new shareholders in the San Francisco-based company who could back his bid, the sources said. Twitter's retail investor base has increased from about 20% before Musk unveiled his stake on April 4 to some 22%, according to the sources.
