Each time a political leader makes a benign comment on North India’s infamous khap panchayats, it gives these archaic residues of community-based justice systems a life-saving booster shot. This time it is the turn of the party with a difference. The Aam Admi Party (AAP) turned a soft gaze on them when its leader, Arvind Kejriwal, said recently that there is no need to ban these bodies because they serve a cultural purpose.
He was countered by Union Finance Minister P. Chidambaram, who, while speaking to students of the Shriram College of Commerce said that khap panchayats are retrograde organisations that cannot be a part of India’s culture. “I am appalled to see somebody say it is a part of India’s culture,” he said. But his fellow Congressman and the Chief Minister of Haryana, Bhupinder Singh Hooda, was quick to defend these bodies that have drawn adverse national attention on his State time and again through their approval of honour killings and misogynistic diktats. Mr. Hooda told reporters at a function in Haryana that khap panchayats “are like NGOs” who work in the social sphere, and are certainly a part of our culture.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
In the olden days,
To say that they serve a “cultural purpose” is debatable in the modern, liberal democratic country that India now is. The politicians who are soft on khap panchayats with an eye on Jat votes have perhaps forgotten the 2011 judgment of the Supreme Court that declared these bodies as “illegal” and unconstitutional.
Besides approving honour killings, in recent years,
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Against the marginalised At the height of the Manoj and Babli honour killing case, when the khaps threatened to disrupt law and order in Haryana if the mastermind behind the killings was arrested (he was honoured with the award of “Jat Gaurav”) they got their first taste of the political clout they have come to wield. A helpless administration watched a succession of khap panchayats being held in support of the killers. But the adverse publicity that the khaps got as a result of their support for honour killings, triggered some course correction and there is now, a conscious effort to refurbish their much dented image by projecting a socially responsible facade. But this change is more cosmetic than fundamental.
One such effort was undertaken last June in Bibipur village in Jind district where the local sarpanch held a women driven sarvkhap panchayat comprising several major khaps of Haryana. The agenda was to combat female foeticide and scores of women were invited to participate. But as soon as some women activists tried to raise the issue of equal share of girls in ancestral property and how women are being denied this right, they were shooed off the stage. It is another matter that Mr. Hooda presented the Bibipur panchayat with Rs. one crore for its efforts. A spate of similar panchayats on female foeticide followed, prompting Dada Baljeet Malik, head of the Malik khap to say, “We hope that now none will term us as Talibanic or kangaroo courts.” Some khaps have also decreed against extravagant marriages and alcoholism.
But when it comes to substantial issues of women’s rights, or to supporting the case of an oppressed woman against her husband and family members, khap panchayats almost always take the patriarchal view. Neither does a khap panchayat ever oppose Dalit oppression or atrocities against the marginalised. On the contrary, khaps have stood against Dalits in the couple of incidents of violence against Dalits that took place in Haryana in the last few years. Says D.R. Chaudhary, academic and prominent crusader against khaps , “Mere passing of resolutions against social evils will not make a difference. Instead of imposing restrictions on girls, khap panchayats should fight the anti-social elements responsible for crime against women and support the right of girls to choose their life partner and ensure them a share in their parental property.”
Last year, after a couple was brutally hacked to death in Rohtak for defying marriage norms, a large khap panchayat banned girls in their area from using mobile phones and wearing jeans. The khap heads decided that such a restriction will end honour killings as it will prevent young girls from interacting with boys. No such restrictions are imposed on the boys.
So, whenever a politician justifies their activities by terming them as cultural institutions rooted in the past, s/he gives them a new lease of life. What was a dying institution a decade ago, has been revived and given some legitimacy by vote bank politics to enable it to emerge in a retrograde avatar. Now, Mr. Kejriwal too has a hand in this endeavour.
chander.dogra@thehindu.co.in