Writer Nayantara Sahgal on Friday refuted the Sahitya Akademi’s claim that she had agreed to take back the award she had returned in protest against “growing intolerance” in the country.
“Let me make it clear: I am not taking back either the award or the cheque, which is now invalid anyway. My protest against the crushing of dissent stands, and I shall continue to speak and act for the freedom of expression,” she said in a statement published in the website
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
“I have just been informed by the Sahitya Akademi that their policy does not allow them to keep returned awards, and that they are returning the cheque I sent them in October 2015. The cheque is now invalid. It has taken the Akademi three months to inform their awardees of such a policy,” she said.
Earlier on Friday, the Sahitya Akademi said that some of the writers, including
“The Sahitya Akademi has started sending back the awards to the writers... It has already been sent to Nayantara Sahgal. Another writer Nand Bhardwaj has also agreed to take back the award. It will be sent to other writers as well,” Sahitya Akademi president Vishwanath Prasad Tiwari said.
He said the Akademi was also sending a copy of its resolution, which was passed in the October meeting, to all writers mentioning that there was no provision in its constitution to return the honours.
About 40 writers had returned their awards in the past few months to the Sahitya Akademi in the backdrop of the Akademi’s silence on the murder of fellow writer M.M. Kalburgi as well as against the “communal” atmosphere in the country following the Dadri lynching incident.
On October 23, the Sahitya Akademi passed a unanimous resolution appealing to State and Central governments to take steps to prevent such incidents and asked authors to take back the awards they had returned to protest against “rising intolerance”.
“The Akademi strongly condemns the killing of writer Kalburgi and appeals to the State and Central governments to take steps to prevent such incidents in the future,” Krishnaswamy Nachimuthu, an executive committee board member had said, after the nearly two-hour meeting.
Meanwhile, a Culture Ministry source said, “There is a list of 10 writers who have agreed to take back the awards they had returned. Sahgal and Bhardwaj are two confirmed names on the list.”
According to the source, Ms. Sahgal decided to take back her award as there was no provision to return the award, while Rajasthani writer Bhardwaj was “satisfied” with the response of the Akademi, condemning incidents of violence against writers.
After agreeing to take back the Sahitya Akademi award that he >returned , writer and former Doordarshan director >Nand Bhardwaj , on Friday said the Akademi cannot be held responsible for the rising intolerance in the country.
Speaking to reporters, Mr. Bhardwaj said: “The situation in the country was different when we returned the award. At that time writers and rationalists were being killed. [Kannada writer] Kalburgi was with the Sahitya Akademi and that is why so many award-winners objected to the Akademi’s silence over his killing.”
Mr. Bhardwaj, a Rajasthani and Hindi writer, said the Akademi held a meeting when the awards were being returned and condemned the killing. “The Akademi has stated that it would stand with the writers. I respect the Akademi’s decisions. Intolerance and other issues remain, but now I wouldn’t hold the Akademi responsible since that’s not its mandate,” he said.
Welcomes decision
Meanwhile, Culture and Tourism Minister Mahesh Sharma welcomed the decision of the writers to take back the awards. “This is a welcome step,” he told reporters when asked about the move by some of the writers. Asked about the number of writers who had agreed to take back the awards, he said, “I don’t know the number, but if the writers have decided to take back the awards, I welcome their decision.”
(With additional inputs from Kavita Upadhyay and PTI)
ADVERTISEMENT