Chile slams World Bank for bias in competitiveness rankings

In an interview with The Wall Street Journal, World Bank Chief Economist Paul Romer apologised to Chile for changes to the Bank’s “Doing Business” report methodology.

The World Bank headquarters in Washington D.C.

Chilean officials on January 13 criticised the World Bank, saying it treated the South American country unfairly in its closely watched annual “Doing Business” competitiveness rankings.

“What happened with the World Bank’s competitiveness rankings is very concerning,” President Michelle Bachelet, whose four-year term ends in March, tweeted after the World Bank’s chief economist apologised for Chile’s slippage in the rankings under her tenure. “Rankings that international institutions conduct should be trustworthy, since they impact investment and countries’ development,” Ms. Bachelet wrote, adding that the government would formally request a complete investigation from the World Bank.

In an interview with

The Wall Street Journal published on January 12, World Bank Chief Economist Paul Romer apologised to Chile for changes to the report’s methodology that he said “conveyed the wrong impression” about the business environment under Ms. Bachelet.

Chile currently ranks 55th out of 190 countries on the list, down from 34th in 2014, the year Ms. Bachelet took office. Its ranking declined to 41st in 2015, 48th in 2016, and 57th in 2017, the World Bank’s reports show.

Mr. Romer told the newspaper the decline resulted from methodological changes, rather than a deterioration of Chile’s business environment, and may have been the result of the World Bank staff’s political motivations. He told the newspaper he would revise the reports.

In a statement on January 13, the World Bank said it would “conduct an external review” of Chile’s indicators in light of Mr. Romer’s concerns. It said any changes to its methodology undergo “a rigorous consultative process” and that the indicators are based on “hard data” like tax rates and legislation passed.

“The Doing Business indicators and methodology are designed with no single country in mind,” it said. “Objective data is not subject to political influence.”

Chile is one of Latin America’s wealthiest and most stable countries. While Ms. Bachelet introduced progressive tax and labour reforms that the country’s business community said crimped investment, she has not fundamentally altered the country’s longstanding free-market model.

Economic growth decelerated under her watch in large part due to low prices for copper, the country’s main export.

In presidential elections in December 2017, conservative billionaire and former President Sebastian Pinera trounced Ms. Bachelet’s preferred candidate, Alejandro Guillier, in part on promises to slash red tape and boost investment.

Mr. Pinera presided over a booming economy from 2010-2014 amid high copper prices. He had succeeded Ms. Bachelet, who served her first term from 2006-2010. Chile’s Constitution prohibits consecutive re-election.

The World Bank’s Doing Business ranking weighs factors such as the ease of starting a business, obtaining credit, paying taxes and getting construction permits.

“It is rare to see an action this immoral,” Economy Minister Jorge Rodriguez Grossi said in a statement. “We hope it is corrected quickly, but the damage is done.”