‘Returning migrants a threat to rural areas’

Fatal mistake:The report stated that workers travelling in large numbers defied social distancing norms.APAltaf Qadri

Fatal mistake:The report stated that workers travelling in large numbers defied social distancing norms.APAltaf Qadri  

MHA status report to SC says that movement of masses might make pandemic ‘unmanageable’

Days before State governments led by Uttar Pradesh arranged buses to bring back migrants, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) informed the Supreme Court that “so far rural India has largely remained safe from this disease” and if migrants returning on foot are permitted to conclude their journey “there is a serious and imminent potential of the disease penetrating in rural India also.”

In a status report filed in the Supreme Court on April 12, Union Home Secretary Ajay Kumar Bhalla said in case of movement of large group of persons travelling together, “the epidemic, which has already taken the form of a pandemic would manifest itself in its still most severe form making it unmanageable.”

The country was initially placed under a lockdown on March 24 in wake of the pandemic that was extended till May 3. With all forms of public transport suspended and State borders sealed, lakhs of migrant workers in urban areas started walking hundreds of kilometres to reach their homes. On March 28, MHA issued guidelines and asked States to organize relief camps and arrange food for them.

‘Migration unnecessary’

“There is no necessity for migration of workers to shift from place of occupation to the place of their residence and rush back to their villages. Their daily needs are being taken care of wherever they are working and the daily needs of their family members were being taken care of at their respective villages…. It is submitted that migrant workers travelling barefoot or otherwise in large numbers inevitably and unknowingly defy the social distancing norms which is one of the globally accepted norm for preventing COVID and put their lives and others lives in danger,” MHA’s status report said.

Uttar Pradesh was one of the first States to announce that it would arrange for migrant workers stuck across the country to return to their homes. On Sunday, a batch of workers in Haryana were brought back to Etah in Uttar Pradesh on buses arranged by the State government and were sent to quarantine centres.

The April 19 guidelines issued by MHA asserted that there will be no inter-State movement of labourers. Following U.P, other States like Punjab, Odisha, West Bengal, Maharashtra were also coordinating for inter-State movement of labourers who wanted to return home. Bihar has been requesting the Centre to change its guidelines and allow students and workers to return home.

A senior Home Ministry official said there were no fresh guidelines allowing such movement and States were coordinating among themselves.

Delhi incident

On March 29, two Delhi government officers were suspended and a showcause was slapped against two other officers for dereliction of duty as thousands of migrants congregated at the Delhi-U.P. border in buses, in a bid to go home.

On March 28, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath had tweeted that a 1,000 buses were being arranged to help the migrants reach home.

The MHA’s status report, without specifically mentioning the Delhi incident, said, “with a view to initially disperse gathering of such migrant workers at the State borders, some State governments did make arrangement for their travel by bus but eventually a final decision was taken not to permit further movement of such migrant workers.”

Recommended for you