India ignored as Pakistan takes charge of Afghan-Taliban talks

As representatives of the Afghanistan government prepare for another round of talks in Pakistan with Taliban representatives on Friday, India is being frozen out of the talks. The official stand of the government is that it is “supportive of the peace process” provided “it brings genuine peace and internationally accepted red lines”.

However, officials in Delhi and Kabul have told The Hindu that India is far from comfortable with the “direction the talks are taking”, saying that “all red lines have been violated so far”.

In 2010, former President Hamid Karzai had listed these “red lines” as an acceptance of the Afghan Constitution; peace or a ceasefire as a pre-condition for talks; and following an “Afghan-owned, Afghan-led” process, which had been endorsed by the UPA government.

ISI presence

In contrast, the current round of talks initiated by President Ashraf Ghani is happening without a ceasefire in place, where Taliban representatives are pushing for the re-establishment of an Islamic Emirate, rather than the Constitution. In addition, the talks are being hosted by the Pakistan government, with senior ISI intelligence officials sitting in on all the discussions that were held on July 7 in the Pakistani hill station of Murree between Afghan officials and Taliban leaders produced by Pakistan.

Pakistan Army Chief Raheel Sharif has also been credited by U.S. Generals as well as the Ghani government for “facilitating” the talks. “Far from Afghan-owned, these talks seem to be ISI-controlled and ISI-led,” one official told The Hindu .

The next round of talks is expected to be held in Pakistan on July 31, according to a representative of the Afghanistan Peace Council.

Initial negotiations between Afghanistan peace envoys and various Taliban leaders in this round began in May, with representatives of the U.N., the U.S. and China attending as observers at a meeting in Doha in early May. This was followed by a second round of talks in Urumqi in China’s Xinjiang province in the third week of May. However, the “Murree peace talks” of July 7 and 8, as they are referred to by the Pakistan government, were the first officially acknowledged round of talks from all sides.

Unlike other abortive attempts for talks, officials in the U.S. and China characterised the Murree talks as a success.

India has made no official statement about the talks, which have blindsided the government with their speed.

“With each round of talks, both Afghanistan and the international community are accepting that the Taliban is a legitimate representative of Afghans, when in fact they are a terror group under Pakistani control,” said a senior diplomat.

However, officials in New Delhi and Kabul concede that given that India has little say in the outcome, the government will take a more “realistic” position. “We will convey our unease and concerns,” one official told The Hindu , “but quietly, and only to those willing to listen.”

U.S. and China term the Islamabad-hosted ‘Murree talks’, attended by ISI officials, a success

Recommended for you