When disinformation researcher Wen-Ping Liu looked into China's efforts to influence Taiwan's recent election using fake social media accounts, something unusual stood out about the most successful profiles.
They were female, or at least that's what they appeared to be. Fake profiles that claimed to be women got more engagement, more eyeballs and more influence than supposedly male accounts.
“Pretending to be a female is the easiest way to get credibility,” said Mr. Liu, an investigator with Taiwan's Ministry of Justice.
Whether it's Chinese or Russian propaganda agencies, online scammers or AI chatbots, it pays to be female - proving that while technology may grow more and more sophisticated, the human brain remains surprisingly easy to hack thanks in part to age-old gender stereotypes that have migrated from the real world to the virtual.
People have long assigned human characteristics like gender to inanimate objects - ships are one example - so it makes sense that human-like traits would make fake social media profiles or chatbots more appealing. However, questions about how these technologies can reflect and reinforce gender stereotypes are getting attention as more voice assistants and AI-enabled chatbots enter the market, further blurring the lines between man (and woman) and machine.
Scarlett Johansson threatens to sue OpenAI CEO
“You want to inject some emotion and warmth and a very easy way to do that is to pick a woman's face and voice,” said Sylvie Borau, a marketing professor and online researcher in Toulouse, France, whose work has found that internet users prefer “female” bots and see them as more human than “male” versions.
People tend to see women as warmer, less threatening and more agreeable than men, Ms. Borau told AP. Men, meanwhile, are often perceived to be more competent, though also more likely to be threatening or hostile. Because of this many people may be, consciously or unconsciously, more willing to engage with a fake account that poses as female.
Scarlett Johansson declined OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s request to voice the ChatGPT AI program and threatened to sue when the company went with what she called an “eerily similar” voice. OpenAI put the new voice on hold. File | Photo Credit: AP
When OpenAI CEO Sam Altman was searching for a new voice for the ChatGPT AI program, he approached Scarlett Johansson, who said Mr. Altman told her that users would find her voice - which served as the eponymous voice assistant in the movie Her - “comforting." Ms. Johansson declined Mr. Altman's request and threatened to sue when the company went with what she called an “eerily similar” voice. OpenAI put the new voice on hold.
Feminine profile pictures, particularly ones showing women with flawless skin, lush lips and wide eyes in revealing outfits, can be another online lure for many men.
Users also treat bots differently based on their perceived sex: Ms. Borau's research has found that “female” chatbots are far more likely to receive sexual harassment and threats than “male” bots.
Female social media profiles receive on average more than three times the views compared to those of males, according to an analysis of more than 40,000 profiles conducted for the AP by Cyabra, an Israeli tech firm that specialises in bot detection. Female profiles that claim to be younger get the most views, Cyabra found.
“Creating a fake account and presenting it as a woman will help the account gain more reach compared to presenting it as a male,” according to Cyabra's report.
The online influence campaigns mounted by nations like China and Russia have long used faux females to spread propaganda and disinformation. These campaigns often exploit people's views of women. Some appear as wise, nurturing grandmothers dispensing homespun wisdom, while others mimic young, conventionally attractive women eager to talk politics with older men.
Last month, researchers at the firm NewsGuard found hundreds of fake accounts - some boasting AI-generated profile pictures - were used to criticise President Joe Biden. It happened after some Trump supporters began posting a personal photo with the announcement that they “will not be voting for Joe Biden.”
While many of the posts were authentic, more than 700 came from fake accounts. Most of the profiles claimed to be young women living in states like Illinois or Florida; one was named PatriotGal480. However, many of the accounts used nearly identical language and had profile photos that were AI-generated or stolen from other users. And while they couldn't say for sure who was operating the fake accounts, they found dozens with links to nations including Russia and China.
X removed the accounts after NewsGuard contacted the platform.
A report from the U.N. suggested there's an even more obvious reason why so many fake accounts and chatbots are female: they were created by men. The report, entitled “Are Robots Sexist?,” looked at gender disparities in tech industries and concluded that greater diversity in programming and AI development could lead to fewer sexist stereotypes embedded in their products.
For programmers eager to make their chatbots as human as possible, this creates a dilemma, Ms. Borau said: if they select a female persona, are they encouraging sexist views about real-life women? “It's a vicious cycle,” Ms. Borau said. “Humanising AI might dehumanise women.”
Published - June 12, 2024 11:48 am IST
