Kulbhushan Jadhav: the story so far

The strange case of Kulbhushan Jadhav

“The current cycle of bilateral engagement and acrimony runs from the dramatic visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Lahore on Christmas in 2015.” The two leaders on that visit. PTI  

The military trial and summary sentencing to death of Kulbhushan Jadhav in Pakistan, with the Indian High Commission denied consular access to him, has plunged India-Pakistan relations into a crisis again. Mr. Jadhav is not the first Indian to be caught and sentenced as a spy by Pakistan, but the first retired middle-level naval officer. The context and background of this need examination.

A diplomatic leap in the dark

The current cycle of bilateral engagement and acrimony runs from the dramatic visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Lahore on Christmas in 2015. The occasion was Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s granddaughter’s wedding, but really it was a diplomatic leap in the dark. As in the past, beginning with Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s Lahore bus journey, theatrical moves rattle anti-India forces in the Pakistani military and jihadi organisations, who then unleash retributive terrorist acts. Within a week of Mr. Modi and Mr. Sharif socialising, the Pathankot airbase was attacked. Tragically, within days of that, Mufti Mohammad Sayeed, the Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir, who headed the Peoples Democratic Party’s alliance with the Bharatiya Janata Party, died. The stage was set for instability in the Kashmir Valley.

While Mufti sahib’s daughter Mehbooba Mufti dithered for nearly three months whether or not to succeed her father, the situation in Pakistan was drifting too. Prime Minister Sharif, marginalised by his namesake, the Pakistani Army chief, undermined by the Panama Papers revelations and suffering from heart trouble, left for the U.K. for medical treatment in April 2016. He returned to Pakistan in July. By then, Ms. Mufti had barely been in office when Burhan Wani, a self-styled commander of the Hizbul Mujahideen, was killed, inflaming an already restive Valley. From that point onwards, Indo-Pak relations slid downwards.

Kulbhushan Jadhav alias Hussein Mubarak Patel was arrested by Pakistan in March 2016, allegedly in Balochistan, for espionage and abetting terror. This was a windfall for Pakistan as since the 2008 Mumbai attacks and the confessions of Pakistan-born American operative David Headley, it had been seeking moral equivalence by alleging complicity of India’s external intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW), in almost every major attack, particularly by the renegade Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan. In fact, the joint statement of Prime Ministers Manmohan Singh and Yousaf Raza Gilani at Sharm el-Sheikh in 2009 was widely condemned in India for unnecessarily allowing Pakistan to introduce Balochistan in the statement to discuss an alleged Indian hand in the Baloch uprising.

Gaps in stories

There is the usual Indo-Pak disagreement over facts. India claims Mr. Jadhav was conducting business out of Chabahar, Iran, for many years after retiring from the Navy, and that he has been abducted by Pakistani state or non-state actors from within Iran. The fact that despite specific provisions in the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations, India was denied access to Mr. Jadhav only confirms that Pakistan does not want the truth to be revealed about the place and manner of arrest. India also argues that spies and operatives are not sent carrying their own passports. On the other hand, it is unclear why Mr. Jadhav was operating under a Muslim name, and if he did convert, why the government keeps referring to him by his earlier name. India has not challenged the authenticity of his passport, implying that it was not obtained by fraud or faked by Pakistan. With the debate in India now enveloped in jingoism, such lacunae in stories paraded by both sides are beyond examination.

The truth may never be known, but “Doval-isation” of India’s approach to Pakistan has been obvious for some time. Prime Minister Modi’s espousal of the cause of Balochis and the residents of Gilgit from the ramparts of the Red Fort on August 15, 2016 only confirmed Pakistani fears that India abets terror and secession in Pakistan. However, recent signals from Pakistan via Track II events were that the new Army chief, Gen. Qamar Javed Bajwa, wanted to reorient his Army’s approach towards India and would endorse the civilian government’s lead in crafting its India policy. He was apparently getting a pushback from entrenched interests raised on India baiting. There were unconfirmed reports that National Security Adviser Ajit Doval had spoken to his Pakistani counterpart to acknowledge the signal and create an environment for resuming political contact. Why then did Pakistan change tack and with sudden alacrity, devoid of transparency, sentence Mr. Jadhav?

One trigger could have been the disappearance of an ex-ISI Pakistani military officer in Nepal. Another may be a desire to stoke further unrest in the Kashmir Valley. It could also be some re-balancing between the civilian and military authorities as Prime Minister Sharif awaits court judgement on the Panama Papers charges. At any rate, Pakistan has succeeded in capturing media space and the Indian government’s attention and thus mainstreaming its grouses even as a new U.S. president shapes his foreign policy.

The Indian opposition has adopted a jingoistic pitch to entrap a government mixing politics, religion and nationalism. If assurances in Parliament are that the government will do “all” in its power to rescue Mr. Jadhav, either it is confident of a Cold War-style exchange of spies, provided they have managed to secure the asset that went missing from Nepal, or it is upping the ante hoping that Pakistan will not want to escalate tensions further.

India’s perception of Pakistan

India misperceives Pakistan, as the 19th century French statesman Talleyrand said the world did Russia, as it is neither as strong as it seems nor as weak as we think. For instance, it is not isolated, as policymakers in South Block assume. Pakistan would have seen rising Chinese rhetoric over the Dalai Lama’s visit to Tawang. It also would read U.S. President Donald Trump’s intervention in Syria and the dropping of the ‘mother of all bombs’ in Afghanistan as the U.S. returning to business as usual and restoring the primacy of its Sunni allies, i.e. Turkey, Saudi Arabia, plus the Gulf Cooperation Council, Pakistan, and Egypt. Pakistan is familiar with the generals now ruling the roost after White House chief strategist Stephen Bannon’s fall.

A Sino-Pak alliance now fed by China’s open hostility and not countered by the U.S.’s words of restraint may entrap India into a regional morass. Many assumptions on which the Modi government has functioned in diplomacy are being rewritten. The challenge is to steer India through this maze with more than jingoism, theatre, and domestic electoral needs.

K.C. Singh is a former diplomat.

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Feb 24, 2021 8:40:44 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-strange-case-of-kulbhushan-jadhav/article18072135.ece

In Depth
No second consular access planned for Jadhav: Pakistan
Pak forcing Kulbhushan Jadhav to parrot false narrative to help its case
India accepts Pakistan’s offer of consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav
Kulbhushan Jadhav to meet Indian officials on September 2
Pakistan silent on granting consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav
India seeks unimpeded consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav
Pakistan grants consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav
Review Kulbhushan Jadhav sentence, grant consular access, ICJ tells Pakistan
International Court of Justice to deliver verdict in Kulbhushan Jadhav case on July 17
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: Pakistan committed to implementing ICJ’s decision in, says Official
Kulbhushan Jadhav ICJ hearing | Live updates: Jadhav tried under espionage law in military court, says Pakistan
Kulbhushan Jadhav ICJ hearing day 3 | As it happened
Pakistan's counsel Khawar Qureshi speaking at the second day of the hearing in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case at the International Court of Justice on February 19, 2019.
As it happened: Day 2 of the hearing in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case at the International Court of Justice
As it happened: Day 1 of the hearing in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case at the International Court of Justice
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: World court to hold four-day public hearing from February 18, 2019
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: Pakistan to file second counter-memorial in ICJ on July 17
Kulbhushan Jadhav to undergo another trial
Kulbhushan Jadhav
ICJ fixes time-limits for India, Pak. in Jadhav case
Jadhav’s family harassed: India
Friends rally support for Kulbhushan Jadhav
Kulbhushan Jadhav meets his mother, wife; meeting a humanitarian gesture, says Pakistan
Wife and mother to meet Kulbhushan Jadhav on Monday
Pakistan issues visas to Kulbhushan Jadhav’s wife and mother
Pakistan files counter in ICJ
Pakistan directs its High Commission in Delhi to issue visas to Jadhav’s family
Pakistan allows Jadhav's wife, mother to meet him on Dec. 25
Can Pak. ensure safety of Jadhav kin, asks India
Jadhav letter was sent to Pakistan, says India
Pakistan’s Jadhav dilemma
Friends, family elated over Jadhav meeting wife
Pakistan offers a meeting of Commander Jadhav with his wife on humanitarian grounds
Kulbhushan Jhadav case: Pakistan designates ad hoc judge at ICJ
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: Pakistan prepares to file plea in ICJ
India rubbishes Pakistan claim on swapping Kulbhushan Jadhav for jailed terrorist
Proposal made to swap Kulbhushan Jadhav for terrorist: Pakistan Foreign Minister
Former AG, ex-Jordanian PM top contenders for Pak’s ICJ ad-hoc judge choice
Jadhav mother's visa application being studied: Pakistan Foreign Office
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: India denied consular access again
Full text of Kulbhushan Jadhav's alleged second confession
Kulbhushan Jadhav files mercy petition before Pakistani military chief
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: ICJ asks India to make submission by September 13
Kulbhushan Jadhav case: Pakistan Attorney-General to lead team to ICJ on June 8
Pakistan claims to have fresh evidence in Jadhav case
ICJ Ruling doesn’t change status of Jadhav case: Pakistan
Pakistan should not execute Kulbhushan Jadhav till our final verdict, says ICJ
Pakistan should not execute Kulbhushan Jadhav till final verdict, rules ICJ
ICJ verdict on Kulbhushan Jadhav at 3.30 p.m. today
Kulbhushan Jadhav’s trial farcical, says India at ICJ
The Indian delegation at the International Court of Justice in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case.
Not one jot of evidence provided by India, says Pakistan at ICJ
Jadhav case: Hope justice in the form of provisional measures will be given, says Harish Salve
The Hague battle for Kulbhushan Jadhav on Monday
Surprised by ICJ order, Pak. mulls next move
ICJ writ may not be applicable to Pakistan
Hope and joy over reprieve for Kulbhushan Jadhav
Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. File photo
Nawaz Sharif discusses Jadhav issue with Pak Army chief
India approached ICJ as Jadhav is in illegal detention: MEA
International Court of Justice stays Kulbhushan Jadhav's execution
India asks Pakistan for certificate on Jadhav’s health condition
A mom’s plea to to save her son reaches Pak. doorsteps
Recourse to ICJ ‘carefully considered’
India again demands consular access to Kulbhushan Jadhav
Jadhav: No breach of pact, says Pak.
India again seeks consular access to Jadhav
Pakistan army refuses consular access to Jadhav
You are reading
The strange case of Kulbhushan Jadhav
Iran’s silence on Jadhav baffling
Pak. readies dossier on Kulbhushan Jadhav
Kulbhushan Jadhav: Indian ‘agent’ in Pakistan
Amid row over Jadhav, India cancels maritime talks with Pak
India to appeal against Jadhav’s death sentence, seeks consular access again
Indian envoy to meet Pak’s Foreign Secretary on Kulbhushan Jadhav’s case
Kulbhushan Jadhav issue: No compromise, says Pakistan
Kulbhushan Jadhav's sentence: Like the LaGrand brothers
Many options to save Jadhav
Kulbushan Jadhav death sentence: Risky, ill-considered
Nepal link to Jadhav verdict?
Pakistan Defence Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif
Jadhav has 60 days to appeal before President: Pak. Defence Minister
A passport (No. L9630722), purportedly belonging to Kulbhushan Jadhav.
Legality of death award for Jadhav questionable, say intelligence sources
In protest against death for Jadhav, India not to release 12 Pakistan prisoners
A passport (No. L9630722), purportedly belonging to Kulbhushan Jadhav.
Who is Kulbhushan Jadhav?
Full text of Kulbhushan Jadhav's alleged confession
Parliament unites to save Jadhav
Pakistan sentences former Indian naval officer to death
Aziz admits ‘insufficient evidence’ on Kulbushan Jadhav
A passport (No. L9630722), purportedly belonging to Kulbhushan Jadhav.
Arab envoys briefed on arrest of ‘spy’
A passport (No. L9630722), purportedly belonging to Kulbhushan Jadhav.
Pak. summons envoy on ‘spy’ arrest, India rejects claims
Next Story