Lockdown displaces lakhs of migrants

Failing to perform as a constitutional court

As India, along with the rest of the world, grapples with the public health crisis caused by COVID-19, it faces many unique challenges. The most acute problem is faced by migrant labourers: they have no work, no source of income, no access to basic necessities, no quality testing facilities, no protective gear, and no means to reach home. Every day, we hear of migrant labourers walking hundreds of miles, many dying in the process. The saddest is the apathy shown by the institutions meant to look out for their interests. I refer here to the Supreme Court, which has failed to satisfactorily acknowledge that the fundamental rights of migrant labourers have been violated, and ignored these workers when they most needed protection.

Full coverage: Lockdown displaces lakhs of migrants

Undeniably, the state must ensure that adverse consequences of this pandemic are minimised. But any duty performed by the arms of the state, even during emergency, must always be bounded by constitutional propriety, and respect fundamental rights. The judiciary becomes the all-important watchdog in this situation.

No relief for workers

In this lockdown, enough and more evidence points to fundamental rights of citizens having been grossly violated, and especially those of vulnerable populations like migrant labourers. But instead of taking on petitions questioning the situation, the Supreme Court has remained ensconced in its ivory tower, refusing to admit these petitions or adjourning them. By effectively not granting any relief, the Court is denying citizens of the most fundamental right of access to justice, ensured under the Constitution. In doing so, it has let down millions of migrant workers, and failed to adequately perform as a constitutional court.

Also read: Migrant workers in U.P. find meagre solace in shovels

In one of the strictest lockdowns in modern India, the Centre issued many directives, but designated the States as the implementing authorities. But the issue of migrant labourers is inherently an inter-State issue, and States have had to tackle it both internally as well as inter-se. Who will guarantee safe transport for the return of migrant workers? When in quarantine, who will grant them a sustenance allowance, or look after their health issues, or look after needs besides food? Who will ensure job loss compensation? Who will conduct regular and frequent testing? Only the Supreme Court can enforce accountability of the Centre in these matters.

In rejecting or adjourning these petitions, the Court has made several questionable remarks: the condition of migrant labourers is a matter of policy and thus, does not behove judicial interference; or, governments already provide labourers with two square meals a day, so what more can they possibly need (surely, ‘not wages’); or, incidents like the horrific accident where migrant labourers sleeping on railway tracks were killed cannot be avoided because ‘how can such things be stopped’. Equally, lawyers have been castigated for approaching the Court ‘merely’ on the basis of reports. But the Court has rarely insisted on such formality: its epistolary jurisdiction (where petitions were entertained via mere letters) is the stuff of legend, so its reaction here, during an emergency, seems anomalous.

Also read: Coronavirus package | Will migrant workers benefit from the Centre’s measures?

Many of the so-called excuses of the Court have been tackled by previous judgments, notably the question of policy and non-judicial interference. There are numerous judgments where it has laid out matters of policy: for instance, the Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment in the workplace; the right to food; and various environmental protection policies. In these cases, the Court formulated policies and asked the States to implement them. Today, there is an unfortunate presumption discernible in the Court’s response that the government is the best judge of the situation. In believing thus, the Court seems to have forgotten that the Constitution does not fall silent in times of crises. Similarly, nothing prevents the Court from monitoring the situation itself directly, especially regarding the state’s obligations: it could easily direct bureaucrats to collect empirical data on the ground, as it has done before.

One is struck immediately by the lack of compassion or judicial sensitivity in handling this situation, and it prompts two observations. First, the Court is not merely rejecting or adjourning these petitions; it is actively dissuading petitioners from approaching the courts for redress because the Court determines that it is the executive’s responsibility. Ordinarily, the Court would have at least nudged petitioners towards the High Courts, but here, even that choice is not available — the Court is practically slamming the door shut.

Second, there is the matter of how the Court is treating such public interest litigations. PILs are a specific instrument designed to ensure the protection of the rights of the poor, downtrodden and vulnerable, and “any member of the public” can seek appropriate directions on their behalf. This lies at the heart of the PIL. The concept of a PIL is to be non-adversarial, but the Court is treating these as adversarial matters against the government. PILs, in fact, ought to be a collaborative effort between the court and all the parties, where everyone comes together in seeking a resolution to the problem. Today, we find ourselves with a Supreme Court that has time for a billion-dollar cricket administration, or the grievances of a high-profile journalist, while studiously ignoring the real plight of millions of migrants, who do not have either the money or the profile to compete for precious judicial time with other litigants.

Role of High Courts

At this stage, I must acknowledge the stellar role being played by some High Courts, even though governments have tried to discourage them on grounds that since the Supreme Court is not interfering, High Courts need not do so either. At least four High Courts (Karnataka, Madras, Andhra Pradesh and Gujarat) have started asking questions about migrant rights. This is almost a replay of what happened during Emergency, where High Courts boldly stood up and recognised violations, but were overruled eventually by the Supreme Court. The Madras High Court, for example, has quashed criminal defamation cases against media houses, stating that democracy cannot be throttled this way. Contrast this with the Supreme Court’s reaction to the bizarre claim of the Solicitor-General who argued that the exodus of workers was due to fake news: the Court seemed to have accepted this, and media houses were advised to report more responsibly.

In such times, High Courts come across as islands of rationality, courage and compassion. However, in truth, the subject matter of migration is inherently an inter-State issue, not an intra-State one. This is a time when the apex court must intervene and monitor the calamitous situation, instead of taking the government’s word as gospel. Justice Brandeis’ words quoted by Justice H.R. Khanna in ADM Jabalpur ring especially true in these times: “Experience should teach us to be most on our guard to protect liberty when the Government’s purposes are beneficent … [the] greatest danger to liberty lies in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but lacking in due deference for the rule of law.”

Ajit Prakash Shah is former Chief Justice, Delhi and Madras High Courts and former Chairperson, Law Commission of India

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | May 11, 2021 9:14:02 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/failing-to-perform-as-a-constitutional-court/article31665557.ece

In This Package
Migrant workers vulnerable again, say activists
Migrant workers face debt, job loss and separation from families
Coronavirus | Amid lockdown talk, migrant movement spikes on Mumbai-Agra road in Indore
Children of migrant labourers in Odisha face an uncertain future
Toll-free number launched to help children of migrant labourers
The migrant worker as a ghost among citizens
Labour Bureau study gleans migrant data
Data on migrant worker deaths | Madras High Court judge questions Centre
Govt. has no data of migrant workers’ death, loss of job
Coronavirus | Centre asks States to conduct free testing on migrant workers for COVID-19
An invisible humanitarian crisis in India
The urban migrant and the ‘ritual’ tug of home
These Odisha migrant workers in Tamil Nadu are glad to have missed the train
Coronavirus lockdown | No clarity on ration for returning migrant workers
Re-enfranchise the forgotten voter
After turning their backs during lockdown, cities now want migrant workers back
Heading home: Migrant workers waiting at MGR Central Railway Station, in Chennai. File
For better conditions of work
60 lakh migrants took 4,450 Shramik specials to reach their home States: Railways
From HIV to COVID-19, Ganjam’s migrant workers remain undocumented
Yoked together, migrant workers and farmers are back in Punjab’s fields
Look back in relief: On the migrant labour crisis
Coronavirus lockdown | Migrant workers should not be prosecuted, says Supreme Court
Coronavirus lockdown | Union Home Ministry blames ‘fake news’ for migrant workers gathering at bus stations
Migrant workers | A boat ride home ends with a train journey back to work
Coronavirus lockdown | ‘Guest workers’ want to stay back, Kerala tells Supreme Court
Migrant workers waiting to board the Shramik special bound for Odisha at Chittoor railway station. File
Coronavirus lockdown | Deaths in Shramik trains not due to lack of food, water, says government
Coronavirus lockdown | 26 lakh migrant workers in halfway houses, says official data
Axing the economy’s trunk
A rude welcome for Odisha’s migrants as villages lack basic facilities
The waning of subaltern solidarity for Hindutva
How will govt. help migrant workers when it doesn’t have basic data about them: Cong.
Belated, but welcome: On Supreme Court move on migrant workers
People with serious ailments, pregnant women must avoid travelling on Shramik Special trains: Piyush Goyal
A moment for civilisational introspection
Migrant workers | Reports of ‘lost’ trains fake, says Railways
Coronavirus lockdown | Jharkhand flies its migrant workers back from Leh
Coronavirus lockdown | Muzaffarpur rail station incident shocking: HC
NHRC issues notice to government on migrant worker deaths
Coronavirus lockdown | ‘Runaway’ trains haunt migrant workers
Coronavirus lockdown | Don’t charge migrant workers bus or train fare, says Supreme Court
Use Central forces to send migrants home safely, petition urges PM
Migrant workers | Video of baby with dead mother in Bihar railway station goes viral
Coronavirus lockdown | Migrant workers returning to Bihar jump off trains to flee isolation
Coronavirus lockdown | 5 persons on Shramik Special trains die in U.P.
The echo of migrant footfalls and the silence on policy
Supreme Court orders Centre and States to immediately provide transport, food and shelter free of cost to stranded migrant workers
You are reading
Failing to perform as a constitutional court
The need for a million worksites now
Coronavirus lockdown | Railways to run 2,600 Shramik Specials over next 10 days
The eternal longing for the distant home
Flawed stimulus is justice denied
Migrants trigger spike in U.P. cases
Soren seeks permission to fly back workers
Desperate migrants keen to return home
Two held for ferrying migrant workers on forged pass
Bihar-bound Shramik Rail leaves Chittoor with 1,440 workers
A callous response
Workers returning to Bihar caught between poverty of their villages and starvation in cities
Migrant workers assaulted by brick kiln owner in Tiruvallur
Coronavirus lockdown | 9 migrant workers die in Bihar road accident
Coronavirus lockdown | U.P. government locks horns with Congress over buses for migrant workers
Coronavirus lockdown | State nod not necessary for Shramik trains
Our families need us in this tough time, migrant workers say as they struggle to go home
Coronavirus lockdown | Image of a weeping Rampukar Pandit becomes symbol of India’s migrant worker tragedy
Coronavirus lockdown | Truck ditches ill man on road, friend stays back till his death
Coronavirus package | Will migrant workers benefit from the Centre’s measures?
Coronavirus lockdown | Centre tells States to upload details of migrant workers online
Coronavirus lockdown | Rahul Gandhi interacts with home-bound migrant workers
Coronavirus lockdown | 8 lakh MT more grains allocated to States for migrant workers
Coronavirus lockdown | Madras High Court directs Centre to disclose number of migrant labourers who died on the way to their home States
Coronavirus lockdown | Eight migrant workers killed in Madhya Pradesh road accidents
Coronavirus lockdown | 25 migrant workers die in Uttar Pradesh road accident
Coronavirus lockdown | 19 migrant workers injured in accident in Telangana’s Adilabad district
Coronavirus lockdown | Police cane migrant workers near Vijayawada
Coronavirus lockdown | M.P. in the middle of a migrant rush
Coronavirus lockdown | Can’t stop migrants from walking home, says Supreme Court
Coronavirus lockdown | Rajasthan moves to deal with huge migrant influx
Coronavirus lockdown | U.P. police warning against helping migrants sparks row
Workers are seen working at Muda Kala village in Sitapur.
Migrant workers in U.P. find meagre solace in shovels
Are India’s labour laws too restrictive?
Stop the return to laissez-faire
Back home in U.P., job offer worries migrant workers
Coronavirus lockdown | 9 migrant workers killed, 50 injured in Madhya Pradesh highway accident
Six migrant workers run over by speeding bus in U.P.’s Muzaffarnagar
Coronavirus package | Migrant workers to get free foodgrains
Coronavirus lockdown | Returning workers fight for food at Bihar railway stations
Coronavirus lockdown | NHRC issues notices to States
Provide income support, restore jobs
Call to set up common data portal for migrant travel
The face of exploitation
Tragedy on the tracks: On the killing of 16 migrant workers
Truck carrying migrant workers overturns in Madhya Pradesh; 5 killed
Coronavirus lockdown | Car runs over migrant worker on his way home to Bihar by bicycle
Lockdown | Cabinet Secretary seeks cooperation of States for transportation of stranded migrants
Coronavirus lockdown | Weary migrant workers lug crashed hopes en route their homes
Coronavirus lockdown | Three migrant workers on way to Uttar Pradesh die on Maharashtra-Madhya Pradesh border
16 migrant workers run over by goods train near Aurangabad in Maharashtra
Opposition slams Centre for Aurangabad migrant workers deaths
Coronavirus lockdown | With no work or food, workers brave the long march home from Uttar Pradesh
Railways ferried over 2.5 lakh people stranded during lockdown in special trains, says MHA
Migrant workers | Maharashtra train accident victims were battling hunger
Second train ferrying migrant workers leaves for Muzaffarpur
Contempt for labour: On dilution of labour laws
Karnataka to restart trains for migrants
4 CMs dial Yogi, want to retain labour from U.P.
Coronavirus lockdown | Back in U.P., migrants stare at an uncertain future
Coronavirus lockdown | Centre urges unions to convince labour to stay, return to work
Migrant workers | Row over sharing of train fares
Who will pay for migrants’ travel, asks HC
Supreme Court must help migrants, says Anand Sharma
Migrant labourers hunt for cycles to go home
100 migrant workers held near Silvassa town of Dadra and Nagar Haveli for rioting
Boost wages to stimulate India’s growth
No relief for the nowhere people
Shramik special trains | Migrant workers, other stranded people to pay ₹50 more to get home
Coronavirus lockdown | Despair packs migrant workers from U.P. into a concrete mixer truck
Coronavirus | Shramik Special train reaches Danapur with 1,174 migrants, students
Coronavirus | Migrant labourers take to the streets across Chennai
Firm up plan to employ 15-20 lakh people: Uttar Pradesh CM Yogi Adityanath
Coronavirus lockdown | India’s first 'Shramik Special' train carrying 1, 200 migrants reaches Ranchi
It’s about food, nutrition and livelihood security
Coronavirus | Odisha to step up screening of those returning to State
Coronavirus lockdown | When a public toilet in Delhi serves as ‘home’
Seal inter-State borders, orders Chief Secretary
TISS team generates data on migrant workers
Coronavirus | U.P., Bihar migrants can now avail ration portability
Making the long journey a tad less painful
Vividly imagining the life of migrant workers
Safe return: On migrant worker distress
Coronavirus | Uttar Pradesh to bring back migrant workers in phases
How will India emerge out of the lockdown?
Locked out of cities, homes and livelihoods
Coronavirus lockdown | In Rajasthan, migrant workers repair and paint government school that sheltered them
Coronavirus lockdown | Plan ahead for transport of migrant workers, Maharashtra tells Railways
Coronavirus lockdown | Close to 6 lakh labourers from State stranded, says Jharkhand govt
Data | 96% migrant workers did not get rations from the government, 90% did not receive wages during lockdown: survey
Opinion | The ‘nowhere people’ of COVID-19 need better legal safeguards
Police intercept migrant workers leaving Delhi, lend help
Leaking pipeline valves, dried streams help migrant workers
Select passenger trains should be run to take migrant workers home, former Railway Minister Dinesh Trivedi
1.31 lakh sugarcane workers in Maharashtra can now travel back home
Coronavirus lockdown | Stranded in various States, Odisha migrants call home for help
Coronavirus | Workers face heat, hunger as lockdown is extended
Coronavirus | Migrant workers protest outside Bandra railway station
Disingenuous and no antidote
Coronavirus lockdown | Odisha youth pedals 1,700 km from Maharashtra to reach home
Coronavirus lockdown | Flight of migrant labour a deep concern for post lockdown revival: Nitin Gadkari
Lockdown | Migrant workers in Surat come out on road demanding salaries
Coronavirus | Migrant workers slip out of Bihar quarantine centres at night, return by day
Coronavirus | Centre files report on migrant workers
Shelters see total occupancy of less than 12%
Google introduces new feature to locate food, night shelters
1.95 lakh migrant workers on govt. radar
Community kitchens reach out to needy during lockdown
Migrant workers in Haryana worry about rent and wages
42% of labourers don’t have even a day’s worth rations left: Survey
Stream of migrant workers leaving Telangana dries up
Govt. may have to present second Budget to deal with COVID-19 aftermath, says Jairam Ramesh
Chennai hotels cater to migrant workers and those in the front lines of the battle against novel Coronavirus
Goa starts counselling for migrant labourers
Coronavirus | Lockdown triggers belated march of migrants from hills in Arunachal
A gruelling journey from Maharashtra that ended on a sweet note
India coronavirus lockdown | Migrant workers and their long march to uncertainty
Coronavirus | U.P. villages tense as many skip quarantine
Coronavirus | Centre releases ₹11,092 crore under State Disaster Risk Management Fund
Quarantined migrants attack officials in Bihar villages; run away from centres
With no help from companies, migrant workers out in the cold
The long and gruelling road did not take them home
Inmates at Gurugram relief camp bored, homesick and restless
A tedious trek to reach home
Trapped migrants in Capital long to be back with their families
Coronavirus | Coimbatore Police intercept container trucks packed with migrants
Namakkal youth dies in Telangana
Coronavirus | Forced to stay back, these workers now battle hunger
Coronavirus | Centre’s extra ration promise yet to be kept at PDS shops
Defiant migrants ready to confront anything that comes their way
Coronavirus | Treat migrants humanely, Supreme Court tells officials
Coronavirus lockdown | Centre again asks States to reach out to persons with disabilities
Coronavirus | At ‘Zero Point’ on Yamuna Expressway, flight from hunger beats fight against virus
Coronavirus | Similar stories, very personal tragedies
An unending journey for the migrants
Stranded non-Delhi residents struggle to return
Coronavirus | An unending journey to their homes
After UP, footage of travellers being ‘disinfected’ in Kerala surfaces; only ‘soap water’ sprayed, claims DGP
Beyond call of duty: police turn saviours for the hungry, homeless
Migrants want to return despite getting amenities at shelters
Ninety migrant labourers arrested in Surat after clashes with police
Coronavirus | With nil hopes at Zero Point, migrants face police batons
Coronavirus: In Bareilly, migrants returning home sprayed with 'disinfectant'
Community kitchens come to the aid of many
Migrant labourers sent back to Mumbai from Igatpuri
Migrants throng KMP Expressway looking for means to go home
Coronavirus | Lal Kuan is the new epicentre of migrant exodus from Delhi
Coronavirus lockdown | Migrant workers not welcome back home in Bihar
Coronavirus lockdown | After night-long ordeal, migrant workers in Rajasthan leaving by buses
Coronavirus lockdown | In Uttar Pradesh, workers made to go round in circles
Coronavirus | Migrant workers stage protest defying lockdown
Migrant labourers from Karnataka left to fend for themselves
Coronavirus | Exodus of migrant workers out of Delhi unabated but police block their entry into Anand Vihar ISBT
Coronavirus | Migrant workers returning to Balarampur village in West Bengal told to live in trees
Coronavirus lockdown | As inter-State buses dwindle, migrants are stuck on Yamuna Expressway with nowhere to go
2,500 workers make a bid to migrate
Coronavirus | Despite U.P. CM’s appeal, migrant workers throng Lucknow’s bus stands
Labourers in camps down to one meal a day as supplies deplete
Youth dies in Maharashtra's Melghat as doctors suspect COVID-19, shunt him from one hospital to another
Sea of humanity engulfs Kaushambi bus depot
Next Story