Activists arrested in nationwide raids: the story so far

Shock arrests: on activists' arrest

 

If the arrest of five prominent activists by the Pune police in a coordinated operation across four States has resulted in such indignation, it is because of the widespread suspicion that this is part of an orchestrated crackdown on political dissent. The intervention of high courts and later the Supreme Court has given rise to the hope that they will not be put away without sufficient basis, and that the case for proceeding against them will be properly scrutinised. The focus will now be on the next hearing of the Supreme Court, but the dramatic development — which has come months after some Left-leaning activists were arrested in a case relating to the Bhima-Koregaon violence — has raised a fundamental question. Namely, whether the arrests were the culmination of a legitimate probe into a Maoist plot, as the police claim, or whether this is yet another clumsy failure to distinguish between those who indulge in or actively support violent activity, and those who attempt to understand or empathise with the social conditions that breed extremism and insurgency. It is nobody’s case that activists or intellectuals are above the law, but the Maharashtra police carry the enormous burden of proof, having accused the activists of doing much more than inciting the violence that broke out in Bhima-Koregaon, near Pune, this year. What began as a controversy over allegedly provocative speeches made at a Dalit conference relating to the 200th anniversary of an iconic battle site has inexplicably morphed into a larger conspiracy involving the CPI (Maoist).

 

Human rights activists, particularly those working in conflict-prone areas, have been harassed and even arrested on the suspicion of being in league with extremists. While action against them routinely makes the headlines, the bald truth is that successful prosecutions are rare. Charges such as sedition, waging war against the government and promoting disaffection against the state rarely end in conviction. One reason for the failure is that prosecuting agencies typically believe in guilt by association; they confuse empathy with incitement and compassion with collaboration. Also, cases are often filed with utter disregard for the principle that charges such as ‘unlawful activities’ and ‘terrorist acts’ should not be invoked in the absence of actual acts of violence or incitement to violence; mere verbal expression of support cannot and should not be the basis for arrest. The Pune police claim that the five who have now been arrested were raising funds for the Maoists, and indulging in unlawful activities; that they had a nexus with other unlawful groups and, ominously, were plotting to “target high political functionaries”. Given the sweeping allegations of unlawful activity and the enormity of implicating them in unverified assassination plots, the burden of proof on the police is extremely high. Unless proven, it will only confirm suspicions that the law has been bent with the sole purpose of targeting dissent.

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jan 13, 2021 11:36:00 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/shock-arrests/article24813620.ece

In This Package
Pune court defers hearing on activists Surendra Gadling, Shoma Sen's bail pleas till September 14
Supreme Court extends house arrest of rights activists till Sept. 12
Activists arrest: Pune Police seek more time to file chargesheet
Why are CBI, NIA not involved if it’s bid to assassinate PM, asks Congress
Pune police take activists back home
Bail sought for activists
A Pune resident’s FIR was trigger for activists' arrests
Activists arrests an ominous pointer, says CPI (M) mouthpiece People’s Democracy
Democracy, Constitution under threat: Arundhati Roy
Activist Vernon Gonsalves: A morning under house arrest
Five arrested for ‘Maoist links’ in nationwide raids
Who are the activists who were arrested for 'Maoist links' in nation-wide raids?
Activists to be under house arrest, says SC; Arpinder Singh gets gold in Men's Triple Jump, and other top news of the day
Activists’ arrest: It's a more serious situation in country than Emergency, says Arundhati Roy
The crackdown on civil society
You are reading Shock arrests: on activists' arrest
Crackdown on activists disturbing: Amnesty
Activists arrest: Pune court orders police to comply with Supreme Court direction
Release 10 activists charged in Bhima Koregaon; repeal UAPA: Activists
Activists’ arrest: They were conspiring against govt., says Pune police
SC allows rights activists to remain under house arrest
Activists arrest a diversion tactic, says Sharad Pawar
Arrested activists did not organise Elgar Parishad, say former judges
Activists' arrest: It’s undeclared emergency, says Anand Teltumbde
Next Story