From suo motu to judgment: The arguments for and against triple talaq

Triple talaq: Will SC verdict end personal laws’ immunity?

The Supreme Court’s judgment on the constitutionality of triple talaq may also decide the age-old debate whether personal laws can be brought under the ambit of Article 13 (laws inconsistent with or in derogation of the fundamental rights) of the Constitution.

While the All India Muslim Personal Law Board ( AIMPLB) has argued that the Supreme Court does not have jurisdiction to strike down provisions of personal law, organisations calling for reform and Muslim women from various walks of life across the country have urged the court to declare triple talaq and polygamy as “un-Islamic”.

This is the first time that aggrieved persons — individual Muslim women — themselves have approached the apex court in person to settle the law on whether religious law is immune from constitutional standards enshrined under fundamental rights.

Article 13 includes in its ambit any “ordinance, order, by-law, rule, regulation, notification and even customs and usages” passed or made by the Legislature or any other “competent authority”. It mandates that any law in force in the country before or after the commencement of Constitution should not violate the fundamental rights of citizens enshrined in Part III.

A judicial declaration from a Constitution Bench under Article 13 that personal laws are liable to comply with the fundamental rights guaranteed by Constitution would bring religious law, even uncodified practices, under judicial review.

 

Discordant notes

In the past, courts have made discordant notes about the immunity enjoyed by personal laws.

In 1951, the Bombay High Court in State of Bombay versus Narasu Appa Mali held that personal law is not ‘law’ under Article 13. The judgment was never challenged in the Supreme Court.

In Ahmedabad Women Action Group versus Union of India, the Supreme Court was asked to consider that unilateral divorce by talaq and polygamy violated Articles 14 and 15.

The court rejected the claim, saying it was for the legislature to determine. Whether this Constitution Bench will resolve the age-old dispute or leave it to the legislature to decide is to be seen.

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jan 26, 2021 8:39:30 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/will-sc-verdict-end-personal-laws-immunity/article19535387.ece

In This Package
To clear the path ahead
Supreme Court sets aside instant 'talaq’
United against triple talaq, divided on legal points
Historic day for Muslim women: Shayara Bano on triple talaq verdict
Triple talaq lost staunchest support
You are reading
Triple talaq: Will SC verdict end personal laws’ immunity?
The twists and turns taken during the marathon hearing on triple talaq in SC
Those who resort to instant triple talaq will be ostracised: AIMPLB
AIMPLB against triple talaq, says counsel
Triple talaq is Muslim woman vs man issue, not that of majority vs minority: Centre
Can women be given option of saying ‘no’ to triple talaq at the time of ‘nikahnama’, SC asks AIMPLB
Triple talaq a matter of faith for last 1,400 years, AIMPLB tells SC
Islamic law anglicised: Centre
Will enact divorce law for Muslims: Centre
Triple talaq hearing: ‘If God finds something sinful, can laws validate it’
Polygamy is not a religious practice, government tells Supreme Court
Ban on triple talaq will cause a vacuum: Supreme Court
Judges choose work over vacation
Constitution Bench to decide petitions on triple talaq: SC
Bench would hear debates on the ‘legal’ aspects of triple talaq.
SC is looking at triple talaq, not Uniform Civil Code: CJI
SC to examine if triple talaq is fundamental to religion
Peculiarities of personal laws should be protected: Jamiat
SC intervention in triple talaq amounts to judicial legislation: AIMPLB
Centre’s stand on triple talaq based on gender justice: Ravi Shankar Prasad
Cast asunder by triple talaq, Muslim women see hope in Supreme Court
Triple talaq is sin but Shariat permits it, says AIMPLB
Practices in each religion are unique, according to the All India Muslim
Personal Law Board.
SC can’t decide on triple talaq, says AIMPLB
Supreme Court admits Muslim woman's plea to declare triple talaq illegal
A file photo of senior advocate Salman Khurshid.
SC seeks Khurshid’s assistance in talaq case
Next Story