New cattle slaughter rules and their aftermath

SC had taken varied positions on cattle issue

Strength in numbers A man on the move with his cattle in Delhi on Thursday. Sushil Kumar Verma  

For years, the Supreme Court has struggled for consistency in its judicial pronouncements regarding cattle, leaving it ultimately to the Centre and States to devise an appropriate policy.

While Supreme Court banned the bull-running sport jallikattu as cruel, it refused to intervene with States to frame a uniform policy on cattle slaughter. Neither did the court deem it fit to examine a plea to ban animal sacrifices for religious purposes.


“The balance and harmony of all faiths, this court is bound to it. Your petition makes generalised statements on a very, very sensitive matter.. We have to close our eyes to centuries and centuries old traditions,” Chief Justice of India (as he was then) H.L. Dattu orally observed in court to a petition filed by a journalist, Varaaki, in September 2015.

The petition had contended that “faith, religion, customs and practices should not take precedence over lawful rights, human or animal. This being true for all religious communities, whether it be Durga pooja, the slaughter of lambs for Easter, turkeys for Thanksgiving or goats for Bakri-Eid.”

Again, in 2017, a Bench led by Chief Justice of India J.S. Khehar declined a plea by Delhi resident Vineet Sahai to direct the States to frame a national policy as contradicting laws ensured a favourable clime for illegal inter-State transportation of cattle.

Extending rules

In April 2017, the apex court had asked the Centre to extend to India-Bangladesh border areas its rules framed to counter the smuggling of cattle to territories in Nepal.

Legal precedents also show that the court had differed on the question whether beef was a “poor man’s diet”.

Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Dec 6, 2021 9:19:51 PM |

In This Package
Cattle trade ban rules were not placed before Parliament
Public slaughter of bull: 8 IYC workers arrested
New restrictions on cattle slaughter
MoEFCC directive on cattle market sparks row over beef ban
Cattle traders cry foul
‘Covert bid by Sangh forces to ban cattle slaughter’
New rules for cattle sale irk farmers
Slaughter ban goes against pluralism, says Stalin
You are reading
SC had taken varied positions on cattle issue
Kerala sees 'beef fests' in protest against ban on sale of cattle for slaughter
‘Ban on cattle slaughter should not lead to conflict’
Uncertainty looms over livestock sector
‘Curbs on cattle sale will affect minorities, farmers’
New rules make cattle traders jittery
Curbs on cattle slaughter meet stiff resistance
Cattle sale ban infringes on freedom, says Raju
Public slaughter by Congress activists kicks up a row
Cattle row: Bengal leather industry moots legal recourse
Cattle trade rules go against 1960 law
West Bengal will not abide by notification on cattle slaughter, says Mamata
State backs writ in HC against cattle sale ban
Beef festivals raise Adityanath ire
Kerala village fears the music will stop
Puducherry not to impose curbs on sale of cattle
Pinarayi writes to CMs on new cattle trade rules
Cattle slaughter sees a decline
IIT-M students organise beef fest, discuss govt. provision
Madras High Court stays Centre’s notification on sale of cattle for slaughter in animal markets
IIT-Madras scholar beaten up for eating beef during protest
Ban on sale of cattle for slaughter: Congress walks tightrope
‘Curb on cattle sale anti-constitutional’
Curbs on cattle sale a violation of human rights, says S. Selvagomathy who obtained stay on cattle slaughter ban
States rights violated, say parties
Next Story