Mumbai Collective 2019 | 'Rafale: Modi's Nemesis?' — N. Ram in conversation with P. Sainath

The Hindu Group of publications chairman N. Ram, along with Magsaysay awardee journalist P. Sainath, talks on the Rafale deal at the inaugural session of “Mumbai Collective 2019”, in Mumbai on March 10, 2019.   | Photo Credit: Arunangsu Roy Chowdhury

The third edition of Mumbai Collective began on Sunday and features sessions on Rafale deal, distortion of history and rise of the surveillance state.

R. Ramakumar, chief organiser, had said that they wanted a mass collective, and different kinds of protests, not just speeches, talks, but also cultural forms of resistance: songs, poetry, paintings, photographs. “We wanted our festival to be more a ‘pol’ fest than a lit fest,” he had said.

The platform took shape in 2016, its first edition a two-day event, entirely volunteer-run with crowd-sourced funds.

The Mumbai Collective 2019 is being held at at Y.B. Chavan centre in Nariman Point, Mumbai.

Our Resident Editor Vikas Dhoot updates from the venue.

Here are the latest updates:

10:45 am

“Rafale: Modi's Nemesis?” — N. Ram in conversation with veteran journalist P. Sainath

Highlights from Mr. Ram's speech:

“In 2014, the BJP came to power after pillorying the congress, painting it as corrupt, and offering Narendra Modi and BJP as the clean alternative. Now the compliment is being returned [by the Opposition].

“Almost everyone will agree that corruption in India is pervasive, omnipresent and multifarious. It is to be encountered especially in the nexus between politics and business.

“Defence is a prime example... When we were doing the Bofors investigation, we were trying to understand if all these commissions being paid out were normal or not.

“We got an informal tip from former President R. Venkataraman, who had earlier held the portfolios of Finance and Defence Ministries. I can share this now...

“He said, 'Don't you know the standard rate of commission on major defence deals is 6%?'

“Indeed, we found that the average commissions paid in many such deals was 6%.

“[Thus] Corruption had become normalised. But there's something called grand corruption that is different from the great and general corruption [where corruption is not an aberration but the system itself].

“Grand corruption affects institutions, manifests in policies..., and in the defence sector, this is the normal condition.

“Grand corruption is not just about bribes but arbitrary decision making, crony capitalism, doing favours, lobbying in the corridors of the ministry, using commission agents to try to fix the deal.

“The Indian Opposition, particularly Rahul Gandhi, has been on an offensive on the [Rafale deal], charging the NDA government and Prime Minister Narendra Modi of bypassing institutions and compromising national security in the deal that is worth 7.87 billion euros [for the aircraft and weapons packages together].

“The story is not over... Offsets need to be looked into.

“This is an area that is being investigated, especially the role of the joint venture of Anil Ambani and Dassault, what it will make and what other offset partners will do.

“The money trail of commission payments is yet to be established. But why on earth would one do away with the anti-corruption clauses?

10:30 am

Ramakumar welcomes the gathering

Chief organiser of the "Mumbai Collective 2019" Ram Kumar speaking at inaugural

Chief organiser of the "Mumbai Collective 2019" Ram Kumar speaking at inaugural  


Chief organiser R. Ramakumar, who teaches economics at the Centre for Study of Developing Economies, School of Development Studies, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, gives a welcome speech inaugurating the 'Mumbai Collective 2019' in Mumbai on March 10.

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jul 25, 2021 6:03:15 PM |

Next Story