National

Supreme Court lists Prashant Bhushan case on August 25 to study 'effect' of his statement

Prashant Bhushan. File   | Photo Credit: The Hindu

A three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court led by Justice Arun Mishra will on Tuesday examine the “effect” of a statement filed by advocate Prashant Bhushan that an insincere apology for his tweets, which are an expression of his bona fide beliefs, would amount to “contempt of my conscience and of an institution that I hold in highest esteem”.

Also read: Pained because I have been grossly misunderstood, says Prashant Bhushan

“My tweets represented this bona fide belief that I continue to hold. Public expression of these beliefs was, I believe, in line with my higher obligations as a citizen and a loyal officer of this court. Therefore, an apology for expression of these beliefs, conditional or unconditional, would be insincere,” he said in the supplementary statement filed on Monday.

On August 20, while reserving the suo motu contempt case for order on sentencing, a three-judge Bench led by Justice Mishra gave Mr. Bhushan an opportunity to tender an unconditional apology by August 24.

The court had said it would schedule a hearing on August 25 in case he filed a statement by August 24.

Also read: Legal and civil society luminaries issue statement on judgment against Prashant Bhushan

In his statement read out to the court during the contempt hearing on August 20, Mr. Bhushan refused to apologise for his tweet about Chief Justice S.A. Bobde astride a heavy bike and another on the role of the Supreme Court in the past six years. He had quoted Mahatma Gandhi to say that he neither asked for mercy nor magnanimity and would cheerfully accept whatever punishment the court deemed him fit.

In this supplementary statement, Mr. Bhushan said “an apology cannot be a mere incantation and any apology has to, as the court has itself put it, be sincerely made”.

“If I retract a statement before this court that I otherwise believe to be true or offer an insincere apology, that in my eyes would amount to the contempt of my conscience and of an institution that I hold in highest esteem,” he stated.

Also read: Reconsider decision in Prashant Bhushan case, Supreme Court urged

Mr. Bhushan said he had never stood on ceremony for offering his apology for a mistake or wrongdoing on his part.

“It has been a privilege for me to have served this institution and bring several important public interest causes before it. I live with the realisation that I have received from this institution much more than I have had the opportunity to give it. I cannot but have the highest regard for the institution of the Supreme Court,” he said.

‘Last bastion of hope’

He stated that he believed the Supreme Court to be the last bastion of hope for the protection of fundamental rights, the watchdog institutions and indeed for constitutional democracy itself.

Editorial: Lapsing into contempt: On punishing Prashant Bhushan

The hopes of the people vested on the Supreme Court in “these troubling times” to ensure rule of law and not the untrammelled rule of the Executive, he said.

“This casts a duty, especially for an officer of this court like myself, to speak up, when I believe there is a deviation from its sterling record. Therefore, I expressed myself in good faith, not to malign the Supreme Court or any particular Chief Justice, but to offer constructive criticism so that the court can arrest any drift away from its long-standing role as a guardian of the Constitution and custodian of peoples’ rights,” he noted.

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Oct 30, 2020 11:40:05 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/an-insincere-apology-for-a-bona-fide-belief-will-be-contempt-of-my-conscience-prashant-bhushan-tells-sc/article32427828.ece

Next Story