The AIADMK crisis: who'll take the party forward?

Supreme Court verdict in Jaya assets case today

AIADMK interim general secretary V.K. Sasikala.   | Photo Credit: PTI

Not only AIADMK interim general secretary V.K. Sasikala’s political future, but her personal liberty, along with the legacy of former Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Jayalalithaa, will depend on the verdict the Supreme Court will pronounce in a disproportionate assets case on Tuesday.

At 10.30 a.m., a Bench of Justices Pinaki Chandra Ghose and Amitava Roy will deliver separate judgments on appeals filed by the Karnataka government and others against the acquittal of Jayalalithaa, Sasikala, J. Ilavarasi and V.N. Sudhakaran in the case, which has cast a shadow over Ms. Sasikala’s campaign for the chief minister’s chair.

The possibility of the two-judge Bench delivering split verdicts — one setting aside the acquittal and the other upholding it — cannot be ruled out.

If so, the Bench would refer the appeals to the Chief Justice of India for hearing before another three-judge Bench.

However, legal experts say that merely because there are separate judgments listed, it does not mean they would be of a conflicting nature. In fact, it may be that both judges have concurring views and would be complementing each other in their separate verdicts.

Karnataka had appealed against the acquittal of the accused by the High Court for offences under Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and Section 120-B (criminal conspiracy) of the Indian Penal Code.

With Jayalalithaa’s death during the pendency of the appeals in the Supreme Court, charges against her would automatically abate. Section 394 of the Criminal Procedure Code mandates that all appeals — even against acquittal, as in this case — “shall finally abate on the death of the accused.”

However, the Supreme Court would deliver a verdict on the culpability of the other three accused according to the facts as the court finds them. Legal experts say that references to Jayalalithaa’s alleged role would be inevitable while discussing evidence and facts in the verdict as she was the prime accused.

In case of conviction, Ms. Sasikala and three others will have to surrender within the stipulated time laid down by the court. Further, their prison sentence, as awarded by the trial court on September 27, 2014, will revive unless it is modified by the Supreme Court.

The trial court had sentenced Ms. Sasikala, Ms. Elavarasi and Mr. Sudhakaran under Section 109 of the IPC, read with Section 13 (2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act (abetment of criminal misconduct of a public servant) to simple imprisonment for a period of four years each and imposed a fine of ₹10 crore on each. In case of default, they will further suffer imprisonment for another year.

For the offence of criminal conspiracy leading to criminal misconduct of a public servant (Section 120 (B) IPC, read with Section 13 (2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act), all three were sentenced to simple imprisonment of six months and a fine of ₹10,000 each.

Supreme Court verdict in Jaya assets case today
 

Legal experts say the death of a public servant would have no effect on the criminal liability of Ms. Sasikala or her co-accused in a corruption case. The court would also decide on separate appeals filed against the release of attached properties allegedly held by Indo-Doha Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd., Signora Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., Ramraj Agro Mills Ltd., Meadow Agro Farms, and Riverway Agro Products.

The prosecution had alleged that these companies were operating “for and on behalf of Ms. Jayalalithaa.” The prosecution had submitted that in essence, these companies were used as receptacles of “ill-gotten” cash for which no explanation was given during investigation or during the trial.

Last Monday, Justice Ghose, on an urgent mentioning by Karnataka, had indicated that the verdict would come in a week’s time.

It has been seven months since the Supreme Court reserved the appeal for judgment on June 7, 2016, after 20 days of arguments. The hearing had started on February 23 last year.

The Bench had issued notice in July 2015 on the appeals, before taking a hiatus to study the records of the prolonged litigation over nearly two decades.

Some of the 10 points of challenge made by Karnataka in its appeal against the May 11, 2015 acquittal of the four accused by the Karnataka High Court’s Single Judge Bench of Justice C.R. Kumaraswamy include the valuation of buildings spread across 1,66,839.68 sqft to rental income from Sasi Enterprises to the wedding expenditure of Mr. Sudhakaran.

The trial court had fixed the total valuation at ₹22,53,92,344. But the total cost of ₹5.10 crore arrived at by the High Court was eventually found to be even less than what the accused persons themselves admitted was the cost, ₹ 8,60,59,261.

Again, the High Court had reduced the marriage expenditure of co-accused and “foster son” Mr. Sudhakaran from ₹3,00,00,000 arrived at by the trial court to a “paltry sum” of ₹28.68 lakh on the basis of Ms. Jayalalithaa’s IT statement.

The Karnataka government said the “most serious and glaring infirmity” in the High Court’s verdict judgment was how loans were considered as income. It had challenged the “mathematical error” in the judgment, saying the totalling of all 10 loans came to only ₹10.67 crore and not ₹24.17 crore. The HC judgment had treated gifts worth ₹1.5 crore received by Ms. Jayalalithaa on her 44th birthday as her “lawful income.”

The trial court had rejected a plea by the accused that Sasi Enterprises (a partnership firm between Ms. Jayalalithaa and Ms. Sasikala Natarjan) had a rental income of Rs. 12,60,800 and only Rs. 6,15,900 was taken into consideration by the prosecution. The prosecution contended that the High Court had arrived at an “abstract figure” of Rs. 25,00,000 based on “guess work.”

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Dec 1, 2020 11:32:27 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/Supreme-Court-verdict-in-Jaya-assets-case-today/article17298823.ece

In This Package
TN Govt. will not face any danger as long as it follows Jayalalithaa's path, says Dhinakaran
AIADMK reunion talks: Palaniswami faction sees contradictions in Panneerselvam camp
Behind the drama at the Tamil Nadu Assembly
Governor seeks report on Assembly incidents
Why is the AIADMK still in a crisis?
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam leader M.K. Stalin sitting on a fast near the Gandhi statue in Chennai on Saturday in protest against the happenings in the Assembly.
Secret voting impossible, says Tamil Nadu Speaker
OPS camp rebuffed rival’s attempt at rapprochement in Assembly
Sasikala’s vow fulfilled, says Palaniswami
Edappadi government to face trust vote today
Tamil Nadu Governor Ch. Vidyasagar Rao greets Chief Minister Edappadi K. Palaniswami in Chennai.
Governor not ‘duty-bound’ by popular will, says SC
EC asks Sasikala to explain appointment as AIADMK interim general secretary
Sasikala’s elevation illegal: MPs tell Election Commission
Edappadi Palaniswami sworn in as Tamil Nadu Chief Minister
Jugaad jurisprudence, the Tamil Nadu way
Change of guard
Paying homage: Edappadi K. Palaniswami went to the Jayalalithaa memorial after being
sworn-in Chief Minister.
Floor test on February 18; Palaniswami confident about majority
Stalemate continues, but AIADMK patch-up in sight
OPS seeks floor test, joins hands with Deepa
A few good officers
Edappadi K. Palaniswami
Palaniswami stakes claim to form govt.
V.K. Sasikala is consoled by a woman on her way to Poes Garden after she left Golden Bay Resorts in Koovathur, on the outskirts of Chennai on Tuesday.
Bengaluru prepares for Sasikala’s arrival
Justice Roy exhorts citizens to fight ‘deadly affliction’ of corruption
From farmer to CM pick — the rise of a Jaya loyalist
Sasikala convicted in DA case; can't contest elections for 10 years
DA case: Swamy, the man who lodged the complaint
Special Public Prosecutor B.V. Acharya File photo
DA case verdict shows that the corrupt cannot escape from law, says Acharya
O. Panneerselvam and Deepa Jayakumar, along with senior AIADMK leaders, pay homage at the Jayalalithaa's memorial, in Chennai on Tuesday.
Panneerselvam, Deepa join hands at Jayalalithaa's memorial
You are reading
AIADMK interim general secretary V.K. Sasikala.
Supreme Court verdict in Jaya assets case today
'Governor’s delay will pave way for horse trading'
Councillor announces her support to OPS
S.S. Saravanan MLA (third from left) Madurai south constituency extends his support to Chief Minister O. Panneerselvam, in Chennai on Monday.
MLAs at resort traumatised, says ‘escaped’ legislator Saravanan
Could have become CM the day Jaya died: Sasikala
AIADMK General Secretary V.K. Sasikala interacting with party MLAs at a resort in Koovathur near Chennai on Sunday.
Sasikala stays back with flock, MLA ‘escapes’
‘Stop meddling in TN’
A look at the legal cases that Sasikala faces
Cartoonscape — February 13, 2017
Supreme Court verdict in DA case: what are the possible outcomes?
How the battle for CM will proceed on the floor of the house
AIADMK crisis: Conduct floor test, A-G Rohatgi tells Governor
AIADMK General Secretary V.K. Sasikala interacting with party MLAs at a resort in Koovathur near Chennai on Sunday.
An AIADMK MLA escapes from resort, joins OPS camp
Sasikala presents legislators before media, denies coercion
OPS, Sasikala greet Governor on his birthday
AIADMK legislators being held captive, tortured by goons, alleges Panneerselvam
MLAs at resort ‘shielded’ from media, visitors
A selfie moment for the sea of visitors to CM’s house
Karur, Dindigul ex-MLAs support Panneerselvam
Sasikala urges MLAs not to miss opportunity to form government
Puducherry AIADMK MLAs adopt ‘wait and watch’ policy
Governor has to decide TN CM issue by Monday, else case can be filed: Swamy
More AIADMK leaders switch camps, back Panneerselvam
Why Sasikala may not expel the dissident legislators
Growing support for OPS derailed Sasikala camp's plans
AIADMK general secretary V.K. Sasikala submitting the list of MLAs supporting her to Tamil Nadu Governor Ch. Vidyasagar Rao
Sasikala urges Governor to 'act soon'
O. Panneerselvam and V.K. Sasikala
Two MPs extend support to OPS
A small road leading to the resort at Koovathur saw a flurry of activity, with many AIADMK leaders and Ministers visiting the MLAs on Friday.
Not forced to stay at resort: AIADMK MLAs
E. Madhusudhanan flanked by O. Panneerselvam and K.P. Munusamy addresses the media in Chennai on Friday.
Expulsions galore as factions await Governor’s call
AIADMK general secretary V.K. Sasikala leaves after paying her tributes at the Jayalalithaa memorial, in Chennai on Thursday.
Swearing-in delayed to split party: Sasikala
After MGR’s demise in 1987 the party split, with Jayalalithaa heading one faction and MGR’s widow, Janaki Ramachandran, leading the other with the support of senior leaders such as Rm. Veerappan. Janaki was made Chief Minister on January 7, 1988, with the support of 97 members in a House of 234, after she won the confidence motion in a voting marred by allegations of foul play. The Union government led by Rajiv Gandhi dismissed her government.
Jayalalithaa vs Janaki: The last succession battle
Sasikala misconstrued my praise for OPS: Duraimurugan
AIADMK power struggle: Movers and shakers
Sasikala broke promise, betrayed Jayalalithaa: Panneerselvam
Panneerselvam camp files formal complaint against ‘illegal confinement’ of MLAs
WhatsApp forwards exhort MLAs to support OPS
Governor holds talks with Girija Vaidhyanathan
Will she, won’t she? The wait for Deepa continues
TN Governor likely to await SC judgement in Sasikala case
SC refuses urgent hearing on plea to restrain Sasikala from taking over as CM
O. Panneerselvam and V.K. Sasikala
Making sense of the numbers game
Cartoonscape — February 10, 2017
‘Every member of Sasikala’s family controls party now’
Pro-Sasikala MLAs get barrage of calls
AIADMK general secretary V.K. Sasikala leaves after paying her tributes at the Jayalalithaa memorial, in Chennai on Thursday.
Sasikala stakes claim, all eyes on Governor
O. Panneerselvam and V.K. Sasikala
Tamil Nadu witnesses its own Game of Thrones
Former Finance Minister P. Chidambaram.
There is a disconnect between ruling party leaders and people of Tamil Nadu: Chidambaram
AIADMK MPs rally behind Sasikala
Governor could exercise ‘window of discretion’ to delay swearing-in: Chidambaram
In TN, all eyes on Raj Bhavan now
A stopgap Chief Minister who became unstoppable
AIADMK MLAs in Puducherry play it safe
Stalin demands CBI inquiry into threat to Panneerselvam
Support pours in for OPS in Thoothukudi
DMK slams Sasikala, seeks CBI probe into Panneerselvam’s allegations
No one can divide AIADMK, says Sasikala
Panneerselvam dismisses Sasikala’s charge of DMK conspiracy
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister O. Panneerselvam speaking to mediapersons on Wednesday.
Judicial inquiry will be ordered into Jayalalithaa's death: Panneerselvam
Twitterati give Panneerselvam a big thumbs up
Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi
No legal problem to Sasikala's appointment as CM: A-G
Tamil Nadu CM O. Panneerselvam at the Jayalalithaa memorial
OPS revolts, says he was forced to quit
Former speaker P.H. Pandian hits out at Sasikala
Sasikala not eligible to become CM, says AIADMK leader
Party cadres greet V.K. Sasikala.
No clarity on date of Sasikala’s swearing-in
Next Story