Justice Karnan vs Supreme Court: saga of a defiant judge

Justice Karnan fails to show up in SC

A view of the Supreme Court of India in New Delhi.  

After briefly toying with options like issuing a bailable warrant, the Supreme Court on Monday decided to wait another three weeks for sitting Calcutta High Court judge, C.S. Karnan, to explain his defiance of a judicial direction to be present in court.

Justice Karnan had been asked to be present in court on Monday.

A seven-judge Bench led by Chief Justice of India J.S. Khehar said Justice Karnan had not indicated any reason for his non-appearance in a letter he wrote to the Registrar General of the Supreme Court on February 10, after a contempt notice was issued against him on February 8.

The Bench also comprised Justices Misra, J. Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B. Lokur, P. C. Ghose and Kurian Joseph.

C.S. Karnan

C.S. Karnan  

 

Frame charge: A-G

Attorney-General Mukul Rohatgi advised the Bench to formally frame criminal contempt charge against Justice Karnan. Referring to Justice Karnan’s February 10 letter, which stated that the contempt proceedings violated the principles of natural justice and made disparaging remarks about the judiciary, Mr. Rohatgi said show cause notice should now be issued on the specific charge that it was “calculated to lower the dignity of the judicial institution.”

To this, Justice Misra said there were two options available: “One, give him another opportunity to come and explain himself. Two, issue bailable warrant against him.”

But Chief Justice Khehar sought to tread with caution. “For the time being, we will defer the proceedings. Consequences are great. We will ask him some questions and let him respond to these questions. Then we will proceed.”

In his submission, Mr. Rohatgi said the February 10 letter “aggravated” the position in the case. “The letter is on WhatsApp. It is with the media. It is written on his letterhead. Rantings like this of a senior judge does not behold the institution... public confidence requires the court to act against its own. We are sorry that this has come to such a pass,” he said.

“He has not said he will not appear,” Chief Justice Khehar responded. “He has said that he was not granted appropriate time. If it is a reasonable request, we will do so.”


Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jan 27, 2022 3:17:56 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/Justice-Karnan-fails-to-show-up-in-SC/article17295774.ece

In Depth
Delhi High Court dismisses Justice Karnan’s plea against contempt law
Karnan petitions Ram Nath Kovind seeking remission of sentence
Jailing a judge: On Justice Karnan arrest
Justice Karnan
Karnan: a long history of confrontation with colleagues
Supreme Court registry dismisses Justice Karnan’s writ petition
Jail for contempt: Justice Karnan seeks President’s intervention
Justice Karnan tells SC he wants to challenge his conviction
SC sentences Justice Karnan to six months imprisonment
Karnan orders 5-year RI for CJI, 7 other SC judges
Justice Karnan refuses to undergo medical test
Karnan issues warrant against CJI, six judges
SC orders Karnan to be medically examined
Now, Karnan ‘bans’ travel of SC judges
Justice Karnan's outrageous defiance
Karnan directs SC judges to appear before him
Karnan visits HC, doesn’t do administrative, judicial work
Arrest me, imprison me, Karnan dares SC
Respond to contempt notice in four weeks, SC tells Justice Karnan
Justice Karnan rejects warrant issued by Supreme Court
Justice Karnan threatens to prosecute SC judges
Supreme Court issues bailable warrants against Justice Karnan
You are reading
Justice Karnan fails to show up in SC
Justice Karnan: Contempt notice a violation of natural justice principles
In a first, SC issues contempt notice against HC Judge Karnan
Madras High Court judge C. S. Karnan.
Passed erroneous order due to mental frustration: Karnan
Madras High Court judge C. S. Karnan.
Judicial hierarchy comes under strain as Madras HC judge ‘stays’ his transfer
Madras High Court judge C. S. Karnan.
Justice Karnan’s judicial journey
Supreme Court on Monday refused to pass an interim order on a fervent plea of Congress against “illegal” swearing-in of its rebel leader Kalikho Pul-led government in Arunachal Pradesh, saying it can “set the clock back” if the Governor’s actions are found unconstitutional.
Stop allotting work to Justice Karnan, SC tells Madras High Court
Collegium recommends transfer of High Court judges
Next Story