2020 in review: The year that was

Analysis | 2020, a year of turbulence for Congress

Congress president Sonia Gandhi and her son and former party president Rahul Gandhi leave Parliament in New Delhi on February 11, 2020.   | Photo Credit: PTI

A rare act of public defiance by leaders who were always considered as loyalists of the first family, a high profile switch over and the collapse of an elected government in the Hindi heartland of Madhya Pradesh, a string of electoral losses and a few holidays in between.

As 2020 comes to a close, critics may sum up the performance of the party under the Gandhis in less than 50 words.

Historian Ramachandra Guha has repeatedly argued for the Congress to look beyond its first family.

But the party has offered several arguments — from the Gandhis being a glue to keep all factions together to them being the most recognisable face accepted by the rank and file — to explain its reliance on the Gandhis for leadership.

In August 2019, nearly three months after Rahul Gandhi stepped down as the party president following the Lok Sabha debacle, Congress leaders after a series of meetings including several rounds of dramatic Congress Working Committee (CWC) urged Sonia Gandhi to take over the post as interim president.

When the party was going through turbulence, only a member of the Gandhi family can keep the ship from rocking, they argued.

Two events in 2020, however, challenge this argument completely. First, Jyotiraditya Scindia, perceived to be among the closest friends of Mr. Gandhi, switched over to the BJP in March and that subsequently caused the collapse of the Kamal Nath-led Congress government in Madhya Pradesh.

Then came the letter by the group of 23 dissenters (G-23) in August, many of whom have been long time loyalists of the Gandhi family.

For example, in March 1998, Ghulam Nabi Azad was part of the group of CWC members who forced then Congress president Sitaram Kesri to tender his resignation in favour of Ms. Gandhi.

Mr. Kesri was reported to have been locked up in a room in the All India Congress Committee (AICC) headquarters to facilitate Ms. Gandhi’s takeover as the party chief.

Now, Mr. Azad is part of the G-23 that is talking about “collective leadership” in which the Gandhi family will be an “integral part”. More importantly, the group has also asked for an “active and full time leadership” to take on the BJP-RSS combine.

Though Mr. Gandhi has been steadfast in his opposition to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s policy, his consistency on the field has been a matter of debate.

His absence from the party’s 136th Foundation Day last Monday may have been to convey his reluctance for the top job — Randeep Surjewala though officially claimed that he was away to meet an ailing relative and 99.9 % back Mr. Gandhi as party chief — but it certainly made for bad optics.

And the uncertainty over an effective leadership has had an adverse impact both in terms of electoral outcomes and leadership in States.

While the Congress was blamed as the weakest link in the Mahagathbandhan that eventually cost the latter the Assembly polls in Bihar, its unlikely ally in Maharashtra, Shiv Sena, has been talking about the party’s ineffective leadership of the Opposition parties.

From Madhya Pradesh to Gujarat to poll-bound Assam, the party has also seen desertion by elected lawmakers.

On December 19, the Congress announced that it would go for a chintan shivir [brainstorming session] after a meeting of senior leaders including key members of G-23 at Ms. Gandhi’s residence.

Going forward, the Congress must realise that it has a responsibility to be an effective Opposition voice for the nearly 20% of the Indian electorate who voted for them in the 2019 Lok Sabha polls and must put its house in order.

Related Topics
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Mar 7, 2021 7:07:27 PM | https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/2020-a-year-of-turbulence-for-congress/article33454552.ece

In This Package
Rewind 2020: Malayalis who hogged the limelight on social media
Best TV shows of 2020: ‘Normal People’, ‘The Queen’s Gambit’ and more
2020: The year science took centre-stage
2020: The year in words, from ‘you’re on mute’ to ‘atmanirbhar’
2020 was also a year of immense kindness
You are reading
Analysis | 2020, a year of turbulence for Congress
For AAP, 2020 was an eventful year
From charity raves to virtual Champagne-toasting events... Here’s what you can do this New Year’s Eve
The best English movies of 2020: From ‘Mank’ and ‘Da 5 Bloods’ to ‘Soul’
2020: A look back at the automotive industry
A year that made you stay put at home
2020: A year that delivered multiple blows to Kolkata, the city of celebrations
West Bengal Governor Jagdeep Dhankar and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee share a light moment on the first day of Budget session, in Kolkata on February 7, 2020.
Bengal: A year of defections and worsening State-Centre ties
2020: In quest of engaging stories
Rewind 2020: How the Malayalam music industry fared
MANSAS loses people’s trust in 2020
2020: The year of Malayalam cinema
2020: When Indian scientists shifted focus to COVID-19 and made huge strides
2020: How the show went on
Here’s a look at how social media fared in 2020
The best Indian films of 2020: ‘Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo’, ‘Soorarai Pottru’, ‘Raat Akeli Hai’, and more
The best Hindi shows of 2020: From ‘Paatal Lok’ to ‘Scam 1992’
Top 10 tech developments of 2020
Year of calamity and a new normal
Top 10 non-fiction books of 2020
Year 2020 will be remembered for Secretariat demolition
Glowing up in 2020
A look at Apple's high and low points in 2020
Here’s what happened in gaming in 2020
Top videos from The Hindu in 2020
From Teams to Pluton security chip: here’s what happened at Microsoft in 2020
Serving through lockdown: 2020’s unsung food heroes
A dent in city’s heritage in 2020
Telugu cinema 2020: The year of digital streaming
Yearender 2020 | Xi Jinping tightens grip on China
2020 will be remembered as year of artistic resilience
Food and beverage trends of 2020
OTT to the top: For OTT platforms, 2020 was a time for serious growth
Despite COVID-19 cluster, many achievements at IIT-M in 2020
Top 10 fiction books of 2020
How 2020 emerged as the year of the book
The top sporting moments of 2020
In memoriam: Remembering personalities who passed away in 2020
The year when ‘normal’ was derailed
2020 a forgettable year for Prakasam’s farmers
Pandemic, politics and more: Looking back at sports in 2020
2020: A milestone in India-U.S. ties
The popular social media trends of 2020
Most-liked images from The Hindu on Instagram in 2020
The most engaged Twitter posts of 2020 
Next Story