Experts question Trump giving credence to false conspiracy theory on Kamala Harris

Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., removes her face mask as she prepares to speak at the Hotel DuPont in Wilmington, Delaware, Thursday, Aug. 13, 2020.

Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., removes her face mask as she prepares to speak at the Hotel DuPont in Wilmington, Delaware, Thursday, Aug. 13, 2020.   | Photo Credit: AP

President Donald Trump on Thursday gave credence to a false and racist conspiracy theory about Kamala Harris’ eligibility to be vice president, fueling an online misinformation campaign that parallels the one he used to power his rise into politics.

Asked about the matter at the White House, Trump told reporters he had “heard” rumors that Ms. Harris, a Black woman and U.S.-born citizen whose parents were immigrants, does not meet the requirement to serve in the White House. The President said he considered the rumors “very serious.”

Read: Editorial | Running mate matters

The theory is false. Ms. Harris, who was tapped this week by Joe Biden to serve as his running mate on the Democratic ticket, was born in Oakland, California, and is eligible for both the vice presidency and presidency under the constitutional requirements. The question is not even considered complex, according to constitution lawyers.

"Full stop, end of story, period, exclamation point,” said Jessica Levinson, a professor at Loyola Law School, Los Angeles.

Mr. Trump built his political career on questioning a political opponent’s legitimacy. He was a high-profile force behind the so-called “birther movement” - the lie that questioned whether President Barack Obama, the nation’s first Black president, was eligible to serve. Only after mounting pressure during his 2016 campaign did Mr. Trump disavow the claims.

Also read: Painganadu villagers in T.N.'s Tiruvarur district are elated over Kamala Harris’ nomination

Mr. Trump’s comments landed in a blizzard of other untrue, racist or sexist claims unleashed across social media and conservative websites after Mr. Biden picked Ms. Harris, the first Black woman and the first Asian American woman on a major party ticket. The misinformation campaign is built on falsehoods that have been circulating less noticeably for months, propelled by Trump supporters, and now the president himself.

"I have no idea if that’s right,” said Mr. Trump, who said he had read a column on the subject earlier Thursday. “I would have thought, I would have assumed, that the Democrats would have checked that out before she gets chosen to run for vice president.”

Also read: Kamala Harris, supporter of Green Card reform, is now on the U.S. presidential ticket

‘No doubts about Harris’ citizenship’

Mr. Trump made the comments in answer to a reporter’s question and appeared to be referencing an op-ed written by John Eastman, a conservative attorney who argues that the U.S. Constitution doesn’t grant birthright citizenship. Mr. Eastman sowed doubt about Harris’ eligibility based on her parents’ immigration status. Harris’ mother was born in India and her father was born in Jamaica.

But constitutional law experts say Ms. Harris’ parents are beside the point. The 14th Amendment grants citizenship to all people born in the U.S. and Article II Section 1 of the Constitution says that to be eligible for the vice presidency and presidency a candidate must be natural-born U.S. citizen, at least 35, and a resident of the United States for a minimum of 14 years.

"No, there’s no question about it,” said Christopher Kelley, a political science professor at Miami University in Ohio. “It’s been recognized since the people drafted it back in the 39th Congress that (the 14th) amendment would cover people not just born to American citizens but born on American soil.”

The President’s reelection campaign’s senior lawyer, Jenna Ellis, shared the controversial Eastman column on Thursday morning, hours before Trump was asked about it at a White House news conference. Trump noted that the column was written by a “very highly qualified and very talented lawyer.”

After Mr. Trump’s remarks, Republican National Committee spokesman Michael Ahrens said the national party has no plans to challenge Ms. Harris’ eligibility for the Democratic ticket.

Eastman, the former dean of Chapman University’s Fowler School of Law, where he is a professor, is also a senior fellow at the conservative Claremont Institute. According to his bio on the institute’s website, he also served as a law clerk to Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas.

Newsweek defends article

Newsweek, which published the controversial Eastman op-ed questioning Ms. Harris’ birthright qualification, defended the piece, arguing that Mr. Eastman “was focusing on a long-standing, somewhat arcane legal debate” about the 14th Amendment and not trying to “ignite a racist conspiracy theory around Kamala Harris’ candidacy.”

Online rumor and conjecture that Ms. Harris is ineligible to serve first surfaced when she announced her campaign for the White House in 2019. A viral post with the misleading information was revived again, days before she was announced as Mr. Biden’s running mate, as pro-Trump Facebook users spread the message in groups and on their pages.

Fox News host Tucker Carlson mispronounced Ms. Harris’ first name multiple times during a segment Tuesday night, and grew agitated when a guest corrected him, telling Carlson it was a matter of respect. Carlson responded, “So what?” and then mispronounced her name again, twice.

"That is certainly a slight,” said Amanda Harrington, vice president of Time’s Up, which works to stop workplace harassment. It’s a type of disrespect often shown to people of color in the workplace, she said, adding that on the national stage “it asserts a false narrative about who belongs in leadership today.”

Minutes after Mr. Biden announced his pick, conservative commentator Candace Owens posted a false attack on her Facebook page, claiming Ms. Harris had only started identifying as Black in the run-up to the presidential election. Until then Ms. Harris had solely described herself as Indian-American, Owens wrote, inaccurately.

Within 24 hours, nearly 200,000 users had liked the post - raking in more attention than Mr. Biden’s own Facebook post announcing his pick.

"These are not the kinds of things Mike Pence experienced, or Tim Kaine for that matter,” Harrington said, referring to the vice president and the 2016 Democratic vice presidential nominee.

But Mr. Trump has questioned other rivals’ eligibility to serve in the White House. In 2016, the Republican nomination fight raised questions about whether rival Sen. Ted Cruz met “natural-born” citizen requirements. Cruz was born in Canada, but his mother was born in the United States.

Similarly, in 2008, questions arose about whether Sen. John McCain qualified as a “natural-born citizen” because he was born in the Panama Canal Zone, where his father was stationed. Questions about McCain’s qualification spurred bipartisan outrage and the Senate passed a nonbinding resolution declaring Mr. McCain, who become the GOP presidential nominee, a natural-born citizen. Mr. Obama, who beat Mr. McCain in the 2008 race for the White House, was even a co-sponsor of the McCain resolution.

Recommended for you
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Sep 25, 2020 4:23:14 PM |

Next Story