High Court asks adopted child to be handed over to biological mother

Faced with a tricky case of dispute between biological and adopted parents over the custody of a five-month-old baby girl born through a relationship, the Madras High Court Bench here on Thursday said the case only reminded it of Israel’s great king Solomon’s quote: “Divide the living child in two and give half to the one and half to the other.”

A Division Bench of Justices S. Nagamuthu and V.S. Ravi made the observation while disposing of a habeas corpus petition filed by M. Solomon Thangaraj of Aavin Nagar here accusing a woman, whom he claimed to be his wife, of having sold the baby girl born to them to a Chennai-based issueless couple through a woman doctor based at Narayanapuram.

However, on enquiry, the judges came to know that the petitioner, a Christian by faith, had begotten the baby through the Hindu woman without legally marrying her under the Special Marriage Act, 1954.

They also found that he was already a married man who had two college-going children and was also facing a criminal case booked on the basis of a complaint lodged by the baby’s mother.

The judges ascertained from the police that the biological mother had not sold the baby but actually given it to the issueless couple on her volition since she wanted to return to her parents and marry someone else according to their wish. Still, the petitioner insisted on taking custody of the child on the ground that he was her biological father.

On the other hand, the baby’s mother objected to his claim and stated that the baby be given either to her or allowed to be with the adopted parents. However, pointing out that the baby had not been given in adoption in accordance with law, the judges directed the adopted parents to hand over the child to the biological mother until they could adopt it legally.

Directive to child welfare panel

They also directed the chairperson of the District Child Welfare Committee to visit the baby girl once a month and ensure that she was brought up well.

Further, the city police were directed to ensure that the petitioner did not end up harassing the baby’s mother who was given liberty to approach the High Court Registry anytime to revive the hearing in the case.

Before parting with the case, The judges said that they had to separate the baby from the adopted parents with a heavy heart. They told the biological mother: “See, this is the result of living an immoral life. Mistakes committed by you get passed on from one generation to another. Now, the innocent baby is suffering because of your acts.”

The Bench says the case only reminded it of Israel’s great king Solomon’s quote

Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Jan 26, 2022 11:58:00 AM |

Next Story