The Delhi government’s proposal to offer internet facility at historical monuments in the city has brought forth many passionate responses. While some argue that it is a positive step, others say it will only attract people who are not there for the monuments, but for the free internet.
“I have come here from Jammu to see the monuments as part of my college project. The internet would be convenient, but people really dedicated to learn more will do their research before they visit. With easy internet, people will just come to use the free facility. Wi-Fi might increase tourism, but it will take away from the spirit of the place,” said Harneet Kaur, a student of architecture.
‘Serious’ tourists don’t think the Wi-Fi will be a big attraction. “The first time I went to see the Eiffel Tower or The Louvre, we didn’t even have smartphones. I don’t see how my experience would have been any better with them. I’ll say the same for India,” said Chloe Kurtzag from France.
“If I really could say something to the government, I would say that before they think of offering internet, they should invest in maintaining these monuments. At places like Lodi Gardens and Humayun’s Tomb, the boards and guides are helpful. If there is internet, it will be all that young people care about. Why would any government want that?” asked Elizabeth, who is from Brazil.
While one may assume that the internet would not be a distraction for the passionate visitor, many young Indians think it would mean history and heritage being brought together by technology.
“Why not?” asks Preeti Khatri, who is an intern with GoUNESCO. “It will increase tourism. Monuments will have to be maintained better. A lot of people will get jobs as guards and guides. Theory and history are great, but with internet I can watch related videos, read blogs about the places I am in while I am there,” said Ms. Khatri.
But, the government can only provide internet. It can’t control what people search for. “Historical monuments of all places?” asks Padma Srinivasan, who heads the History department at Delhi Public School, R. K. Puram.
“It is a positive for history enthusiasts in some way. What no one is considering is that many monuments are also religious sites. The Purana Quila has a mosque. Most religions will consider this frivolous, if not offensive. If they do provide internet access, there should be regulations. It should be thought through with a lot of sensitivity” Ms. Srinivasan added.
While some argue that the step to offer Wi-Fi at historical sites is good, others say it will only attract people who are there for free internet
