Reviews

Republic of Caste review: Division bell

On Tuesday, probing the alleged Maoist involvement in the Elgaar Parishad meeting in Pune on December 31, 2017, that led to violence, the police searched homes of nine human rights activists and lawyers and arrested five of them. The list included author Anand Teltumbde whose home on campus premises at the Goa Institute of Management, where he is a senior professor, was raided.

In this context, it is eerily prescient that Teltumbde writes in his book Republic of Caste that “Naxalite ideology, whatever that may be holds no terror for the state, but the simple fact of dissent does.” His book is an angry outburst on living the caste reality for 71 years after the birth of India.

Seeing through a prism

What sets his book apart from other tomes on Dalit writing is that it is not a compilation of the movement. It doesn’t even evaluate commitment towards the Dalit cause of various political parties. Instead, it directly engages with readers prodding them to look at current developments from the Swacch Bharat Mission, to the state of education or the campaign against so-called urban Maoists, through the prism of caste.

For example, in the chapter ‘Manufacturing Maoists: Dissent in the Age of Neoliberalism’ that details repression against activists many of who figure in Tuesday’s list, he writes, “Maoism and nationalism are simply modern day euphemisms for outcaste and caste, respectively.”

This book is not to comfort anyone as social scientist Sunil Khilnani notes in his foreward. Teltumbde spares no one. He slams the leftists who comfortably ignored caste politics confabulating it with class dynamics. He tears through Ambedkarites for overtly celebrating caste identities, reducing him to an “inert godhead”, instead of following Ambedkar’s own vision of annihilation of caste. He dismisses the “Dalit bourgeoisie” for failing to pull out their fellow brethrens. He fumes at the Sangh Parivar and the BJP’s efforts at appropriating Ambedkar. He mocks the Congress and prescribes homework for its president Rahul Gandhi.

“Caste is not a physical object like a wall of bricks or a line of barbed wire which prevents the Hindus from commingling and which has, therefore, to be pulled down. Caste is a notion; it is a state of mind,” Ambedkar had said in his seminal work Annihilation of Caste. Teltumbde’s book reminds you of the tone and tenor of Ambedkar’s discourse.

Ambedkar had vehemently argued in favour of reservations. He felt that Dalits occupying important positions will protect and shelter their fellowmen. But within his life time he saw contrary results and lamented against reservation. Teltumbde’s most provocative chapter is ‘Reservation: A Spark and the Blaze’ where he says that reservation in its present form needs to go. The cost of reservation far outweighs its benefit, and it simply re-institutionalises caste, he argues.

Teltumbde feels that for the few who profit from reservation, the whole community has to hear the “cliched and outrageous argument” that reservation promotes the undeserving and undermines merit. He wonders that even if the Dalits demand scrapping of reservation would the ruling class agree considering that it is the most important rallying point in every election.

Along with the reservation clichés another claim repeated often is that free market is a natural disinfectant for caste. Teltumbde questions this assumption. If this was the case caste should long have been on its death bed and not been alive and kicking. He argues that the claim that markets are caste-neutral is theoretically untenable. It would have made a gripping read had the author delved more deeply into the economics of it.

Class and caste

The uniqueness of Indian society where the class dynamics is further complicated by the caste layers had flummoxed Marx too. Surprisingly, the two movements, Communism and Dalit activism, though running parallel, never really found a meeting point. Teltumbde dissects this dichotomy. He squarely blames the communists for taking the metaphor of base and superstructure as though it was incontrovertible. He quotes the example of textile mills of Bombay where despite communist control over the workers, the practice of untouchability continued. At the same time he blames Ambedkarites for not participating in land movements, which would have paid richer dividends than reservation.

Teltumbde has reserved the most acerbic remarks for the Sangh Parivar which he accuses of not just appropriating Ambedkar but also attempting to control the terms on which people engage with him.

The book starts going off on a tangent as it looks at political parties and their idea of caste. Especially the last chapter on Aam Aadmi Party looks completely misplaced.

The general election is just nine months away. The Narendra Modi government is struggling to prove its Dalit credentials. As the election season nears, the cacophonous tug-of-war between the government and opposition each trying to outdo the other as a Dalit champion will intensify. At such a time, Teltumbde’s book will come in handy as a critical guidebook on Ambedkar’s vision, which has been distorted over the years.

Republic of Caste; Anand Teltumbde, Navanaya, ₹695.


Our code of editorial values

This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Printable version | Oct 23, 2021 12:49:14 AM | https://www.thehindu.com/books/books-reviews/republic-of-caste-review-division-bell/article24839899.ece

Next Story