Hidden crisis of mental health among English footballers

Ex-footballers can suffer from alcohol dependency or suicidal thoughts when adjusting to life after the game.

August 06, 2013 03:45 pm | Updated 03:54 pm IST - London

In this October 16, 2011 file photo, Paul Gascoigne is seen at the EPL match between Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspurs at St James' Park, Newcastle, England.

In this October 16, 2011 file photo, Paul Gascoigne is seen at the EPL match between Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspurs at St James' Park, Newcastle, England.

Amidst the mind-boggling numbers being bandied around as the summer transfer season reaches a climax, here are a few more sobering sums.

By some estimates, as many as three in five former footballers will be declared bankrupt, often blighted by bad financial advice. At least 150 ex-professionals are currently in prison. David Bernstein, chairman of the Professional Footballers Association (PFA) believes “hundreds” of current players face mental health issues. More than 700 a year end up being pitched out of the sport in their twenties after failing to win a new contract.

That the life of a professional footballer can be prone to severe and unusual pressures as well as huge fame and fortune, often at the same time, was on Monday highlighted by the latest episode in the life of Paul Gascoigne.

The former Tottenham Hotspur, Lazio and England midfielder was fined £1,000 after he admitted drunkenly assaulting a security guard at a Stevenage railway station on July 4. Gascoigne, who has battled alcoholism for many years, was fined £600 for one charge of assault and £400 for a drunk and disorderly charge.

The 46-year-old, who received treatment for alcoholism in an American clinic earlier this year amidst much conjecture about his future, was originally charged with two counts of assault, one involving his ex-wife Sheryl, but that charge was dropped.

The order was made as one of his erstwhile opponents, former Arsenal left-back Kenny Sansom, admitted to sleeping on a park bench over the weekend. It emerged that the 54-year-old, capped 86 times by England and valued £1 million in 1980, was homeless and battling alcoholism.

After giving an interview in which Sansom said he would be “better off dead”, the PFA said on Monday that he was now staying in a hotel and its counsellors were discussing treatment options with him.

“We have helped Paul continuously since he’s had his problems. We get him back on track but then it can be a pattern,” said PFA chief executive Gordon Taylor. “Coming out of the game and losing that everyday involvement has not been easy for him, the same for Kenny Sansom.”

Gascoigne — who with his starring role in Italia 90 helped bring football to a new audience — and Sansom plied their trade in an era when serious money started to flow into the game as it became a key driver of pay TV subscriptions.

But theirs was an era on the cusp, when the influence of overseas players and managers ushered in during the Premier League era had yet to disrupt the drinking culture well documented by Tony Adams, Paul Merson and others.

So clear are the memories, from Technicolor Panini stickers to the nostalgia shows that are a staple of Sky Sports, that their reduced circumstances jar even more than those players of the 1960s and 1970s that have fallen on hard times.

Some of the changes since their time on the pitch, such as the increased focus on nutrition, have helped. Others, such as the continued escalation of the gambling culture as wages have spiralled, have not.

The PFA insists it is doing all it can to help current and former players with a range of often linked issues from alcohol and gambling addictions to bankruptcy and mental health issues.

“They range across the spectrum from young men who are 16 or 17 and the people in Paul Gascoigne’s time of life who are long since retired,” said PFA chairman Clark Carlisle.

“This only seems to come to the fore when there is a Paul Gascoigne or a Kenny Sansom. It’s good to highlight their case, but my concern is for the 17-year-old boy at Aldershot or Barnet or Northampton who can’t go to the support network or celebrity friends. That’s where we need to focus.”

Taylor said the support provided ranged from funding for the “disaster recovery” of the Sporting Chance Clinic of which Adams has been an enthusiastic supporter, a network of counsellors and an education programme aimed at ensuring young academy prospects were better prepared for the challenges they face.

“There are systems and support mechanisms in place that we wouldn’t have dreamed of even when I started the game in ‘96, let alone 20 or 30 years ago,” added Carlisle, who retired from playing for Northampton Town this summer and recently made the BBC documentary Football’s Suicide Secret, about the taboo of mental health issues within the game.

“There is a shift in attitude where players are being viewed as people and not as assets. It’s not comprehensive, which is where we need it to be, but attitudes are changing.”

The dressing room stigma attached to admitting mistakes — whether money troubles stemming from bad advice over tax schemes or a drink problem — remains a serious issue.

The PFA had work to do in reassuring players that their cases would remain confidential, even to their clubs, said Carlisle. He said that for every player splashed over the papers, “hundreds” were quietly in recovery.

There are pressures peculiar to football — a short, easily curtailed career, potentially earning a large amount of money in a short space of time, a lack of education or good advice and the pressure of performing in public among them. But Carlisle insisted it was not a helpful way to look at the problem.

“These are issues that affect society. This isn’t specifically a problem within football. The difference being the lives of footballers are scrutinised,” he said.

As the arc of Gascoigne’s post-football life shows, it could be argued that it was the routine and camaraderie of a life in the sport that helped disguise lifelong problems, and it was retirement, which has been likened to post-traumatic stress by some, that brought them to the fore.

If the one certainty is that there will be more Gascoignes and more Sansoms, football at least insists it is getting better at helping them.

“It’s one of the most disappointing ends when you lay everything before a person but they are still incapable of grasping that help. There are some cases where no matter how much time and effort you put in they are unable to make the decisions conducive to a healthy lifestyle,” said Carlisle.

Or, as Taylor puts it, “Often you are taking them to water but you can’t help them drink.”

Copyright: Guardian News & Media 2013

0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in

Comments

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.