As lawmakers propose banning the sale of shark fins in the U.S., a pair of scientists is pushing back, saying the effort might actually harm attempts to conserve the marine predators.
Democratic Sen. Cory Booker of New Jersey introduced a bill this year designed to prevent people from possessing or selling shark fins in America, much to the delight of conservation groups such as Oceana. But marine scientists like David Shiffman and Robert Hueter said this approach could be headed in the wrong direction.
Shiffman and Hueter authored a study that appears in the November issue of the journal Marine Policy, saying that the U.S. has long been a leader in shark fisheries management and that shutting down the U.S. fin trade entirely would remove a model for sustainability for the rest of the world.
The U.S. is a minor contributor to the worldwide shark fin trade, and countries with less regulated fisheries may step in to fill the void if U.S.left the business altogether, Shiffman said.
