I cannot fathom the reason why the major national political parties have welcomed Irom Sharmila’s decision to end her 16-year-old hunger strike (“Irom Sharmila to end fast, contest elections in Manipur”, July 27). Her decision shows that even an extreme form of peaceful protest fails to secure a just demand. It is also a defeat of the freedom of expression as most of her freedoms were curtailed. Now that she has decided to join the mainstream, one wishes that she quickly regains her health and is able to lead from the front.
Luwangamba Thounaojam,Imphal, Manipur
Irom Sharmila’s decision will be in focus for quite some time and will again highlight the issue of AFSPA. As the situation in Kashmir and the Northeast shows, officials have to think of better means to restore peace and harmony. The imposition of tough measures like the use of pellet guns and AFSPA will lead to nowhere. The violation of human rights has no place in a democracy.
Ankeet Kumar,New Delhi
Ms. Sharmila’s decision raises questions. She has conceded that a peaceful struggle is ineffective. But is her decision to contest elections a spontaneous one or is it being supported by others? How will a lone activist influence a government in Manipur to repeal an act which previous dispensations have been struggling against? Will she resume her hunger strike if she is not successful in politics?
Marchang Reimeingam,Bengaluru
Irom Sharmila’s decision to join politics will be much welcomed in a system that has failed to give a patient hearing to non-governmental or non-political entities for years and which thinks that criticism and protest are ‘privileges’ enjoyed only by the political elite. Her remarkable and inspiring journey is also reflective of a strong opinion against the misuse of laws in India and how manipulation of a peaceful satyagraha is possible through draconian laws. Almost likening it to suicide and trying to prosecute her is bad as it ignores her demand. No doubt her voice will be more audible as a politician but the cause she is fighting for will be better received if she becomes an independent MP.
Prakhar Singh,Lucknow
