In banning the screening of Kamal Haasan’s Vishwaroopam for a period of two weeks, the Tamil Nadu government has recused itself from a fundamental responsibility — that of protecting the right to free expression. It has relied on the old chestnut — maintenance of law and order and public tranquillity — to justify the indefensible. That a clutch of fringe Muslim organisations had protested against the film, claiming to be offended by its alleged depiction of the community in a negative light, hardly justifies restraining its screening. If a threat of violence was anticipated, the right response would have been to ensure that the necessary security arrangements were provided to ensure its smooth screening rather than slap a temporary ban. Whether a film contains objectionable elements, and whether it may be screened or not, are decisions that vest with the Central Board for Film Certification, constituted under the stringent Cinematograph Act, 1952. It is difficult to believe that a film which passes through the process of pre-censorship with its rigid guidelines contains material that would upset the sentiments of a religious community and pose a real danger to public order.

It is a pity that such reflexive bans are imposed despite the courts reiterating time and again that a law and order threat does not justify such action. In 2006, the Supreme Court adopted this position while dismissing a petition seeking to bar the screening of The Da Vinci Code; a little later, the Madras High Court quashed the Tamil Nadu government’s order suspending the screening of the film on the ground that it “may lead to demonstrations and disturb the peace and tranquillity of the state.” The landmark case, which set the tone for these and related judgments is S. Rangarajan vs. P. Jagajivan Ram, in which the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the right of the former, a film producer, to release Ore Oru Gramathile, which was critical of the reservation policy in Tamil Nadu’s educational institutions. In a stirring judgment that underlined that it was the duty of the state to protect the right to unpopular forms of speech, the court held that “freedom of expression cannot be suppressed on account of threat of demonstration and processions or threat of violence.” As it observed, this “would be tantamount to negation of the rule of law and a surrender to blackmail and intimidation.” Given the precedents, it is highly doubtful that the Tamil Nadu government’s ban on Vishwaroopam will withstand judicial scrutiny. In capitulating before those who protested against the film, the State has only passed the buck on its screening to the judiciary. Could this be exactly what it wanted?

RELATED NEWS

Bench restores ban on VishwaroopamJanuary 30, 2013

Centre may amend law so State governments don’t play censorJanuary 31, 2013

‘Will have to seek a secular State for my stay’January 30, 2013

Kamal Haasan not to move Supreme CourtJanuary 31, 2013

'Vishwaroopam not certified by competent authority' January 30, 2013

Explore amicable settlement of Vishwaroopam row, says judge January 28, 2013

High Court refuses to stay ban on ‘Vishwaroopam’ January 24, 2013

Ban defies apex court directive, says TewariJanuary 24, 2013

Silence ends, support swells for 'Vishwaroopam' January 26, 2013

Kamal moves court against Vishwaroopam banJanuary 24, 2013

Two-week ban on ‘Vishwaroopam’ in Tamil NaduJanuary 23, 2013

Screening of Kamal’s film will affect social harmony: Muslim groupsJanuary 22, 2013

Vishwaroopam to go to HollywoodJanuary 22, 2013

‘Vishwaroopam’ DTH release on February 2: KamalJanuary 14, 2013

Kamal wants Vishwaroopam’s DTH release firstDecember 7, 2012

Kamal Hassan launches ‘Vishwaroopam’ audio in CoimbatoreDecember 8, 2012

Kamal defends DTH move for Vishwaroopam December 10, 2012

We’ve always loved the moviesDecember 18, 2012

Kamal Hassan’s ‘Vishwaroopam’ to premiere on Airtel DTHDecember 24, 2012

Last ditch effort to scuttle Vishwaroopam on DTHJanuary 4, 2013

Big odds for small cinema in TNJanuary 20, 2013

Plea to bar release of ‘Vishwaroopam’ dismissed January 9, 2013

Kamal Haasan files complaint following threatsJanuary 6, 2013

Actors have become businessmen: KamalJanuary 8, 2013

Vishwaroopam release postponedJanuary 8, 2013

Kamal Haasan mulling same day DTH, theatre release of his film January 9, 2013

Why most Tamil films are unable to make it to the Rs. 100-crore clubJanuary 10, 2013

Vishwaroopam to hit theatres on January 25January 10, 2013

DTH premiere of Vishwaroopam before theatre release ruled outJanuary 11, 2013

Vishwaroopam’s DTH date on holdJanuary 12, 2013

More In: Editorial | Opinion