Winning matters in only certain key areas of human activity, not everywhere, writes Nirmal Shekar
Dear friend,
There you were, making up the rear, willing your sinewy arms and legs to do their very best to get you ahead of the ones in front of you. It was a Perfect 10 for effort. But for reasons little known to you — and wholly determined by your biological fate and environmental circumstances — you failed to get anywhere near the ones that eventually stepped on to the podium to be decorated by Olympic officials smiling their well-rehearsed smiles.
While you were running, you might not have given a thought to how many pairs of eyes that were trained on you, from the stands or on television screens all over the world. My guess is, not too many. Perhaps a handful. Mine were among them.
And I saw you, too, standing well away from centre-stage after the race, your face a sepulchral mask, wondering what went wrong. After all the long hours of training, after all the strict commitment to a special diet-plan, after all the dreams of glory on the Olympic stage, now it was time for you to get back to the athletes’ Village and pack up.
When I saw you, I wondered who you were. Of course, I did not recognise you. Nor will the courtesy car driver who will drop you at the airport, or the (quite possibly grim-faced) immigration officer at Heathrow when he checks your passport and waves you on to the boarding gate.
And in your devastated mind The What Ifs, the What-Might-Have-Beens, and a dozen other negative emotions will haunt you as you shrink into your economy class seat for a lonely journey home. Then there is the torment of broken dreams keeping you awake all night, as you break into a sweat, a dank pall enshrouding your entire being.
What did those guys — Usain Bolt or Michael Phelps or LeBron James — have that I didn’t? I trained as hard as they perhaps did. I was as committed to my work regimen as any of them might have been. But why did I fail, you wonder.
Winner in your own way
But my dear anonymous friend, let me assure you. You were a winner in your own way, no matter that you are back home without a piece of metal, barring some loose change in your pocket. For, without you, and thousands of others like you — both men and women — there would be no Phelps, no Bolt.
It is because you tried your very best and still failed that they turned out to be who they are. Imagine three athletes on a track or in a swimming pool fighting for gold, silver and bronze. The venue would be half empty and television ratings would plummet.
Your effort — and failure — in a way defines the successes of the superstars, and not the other way. Whatever the late American football coach, Vince Lombardi, might have said about success — Winning is everything — get on with life and with your athletic pursuits, my friend.
That is a goddamn lie. If it was true, the world’s population would be less than one millionth of what it is today. Winning — the way it is defined in sport, commerce and much else in life — is NOT everything. It does matter in certain key areas of human activity because the very survival of the species depends on it — but not elsewhere, and certainly not in sports, least of all in the Olympics.
The great Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges wrote about the “dignity of failure”, something that “gaudy victory” cannot match. Remember, my friend, when you have fought and failed, there is a certain dignity to it that makes winning look almost boringly quotidian.
So, the Olympic Games is not only about superstars like Bolt and Phelps. It is as much about you and your thousands of comrades, men and women, who anonymously make your way to the grounds and pools and shooting ranges and then quietly depart, unrewarded, to your place of dwelling.
But then, if you dig deeper, you would realise that you have indeed been rewarded. There are greater rewards than tiny pieces of metal. Yours is such a one. For you gave it your best shot and that is, ultimately, what matters. If nobody — or hardly anybody — noticed, then who cares? You know you did it. Doesn’t that bring a sort of satisfaction and soul-lifting feeling that is very, very special? Think about it. I know it does.
For, as a writer, I know that I will not always write the perfect sentence, that I will never be good enough to leave my imprint on history. But that is never going to stop me from tapping away at my keyboard. So long as it makes sense to me, and to a few thousands who happen to read my stuff, I know that I can steer clear of the soul-shattering feeling of abject failure.
Now you will perhaps know what I mean. Without men and women like you, there is no Olympics. This is not woolly-headed idealism or head-in-the-clouds nonsense on stilts. It is, quite simply, the truth.
As a school kid, I had two heroes — Bob Dylan and John Lennon. “There is no success like failure,” wrote Dylan. So, see you in rocking Rio de Janerio in four years’ time, my friend. Maybe you will lay your hands on a precious piece of metal out there. But even if you don’t, don’t stop dreaming.
“You may say I’m a dreamer! But I’m not the only one.”
That’s from Lennon’s immortal Imagine. What we need when it comes to our conception of failure in sport, my friend, is an inversion of perception.
Best wishes,
Your admirer
Keywords: Usain Bolt, Michael Phelps



Calling this article an epitaph for losers is blatant exhibition of being ignoramus.It is true that we do not have a sporting culture.Few sportsmen/sportswomen in india has the means to cater to their sporting ambition.Many of those who went out there has crossed opposition from family,society and when they lose,Its heartbreaking.Not every athlete from any nation sweep the whole lot of medals.Its just the best among those who were worthy enough to compete earns the glory of being an olympian.Many of us indians do not support nor intend to support our generation to take up a career in sports. Then we lean backward and blame those who had tried.The article does not endorse anything against competitive nature. In India, If you lose,You have to deal with personal humiliation as well as those from your society.This article is highly commendable.
Beautifully written article.Sports is all about winning and losing.Someone walks way with a medal because someone has lost it.We need to encourage our athletes for their effort and not criticize them for losing.For the first time we have bagged 4 medals in olympics which indeed is a great achievement.
What a moral to give to our children and grand children. Losing is good because it makes others win. Wake up Nirmal, the platitudes given to a losing athelete is not going to bring back the toils of so many years, pains of so many accidents and the sacrifices of the athelete and his/her near and dear ones. May be you will be able to tell your children and grand children not getting a place in IIT is okay because it helped someone else get it. Please refrain from publishing these negative philosophies.
Perfectly "rational" arguments which are admired by all of us "rational"
Indians :-( IMHO When India does not have even the most rudimentary
sports system at school level, let us stop commenting on success or rack
of the country in sports and just appreciate the efforts of our lion
hearts who dare to dedicate their lives and compete in sports, any event
, anywhere......
Just a thought, I had at the start of the olympics
Doesnt matter how great the battle was, Only a loser knows the pain of
defeat,
The second may have won many hearts, But his heart sinks when he loses
with a whisker,
The first may deserve it, But only a loser knows the pain of defeat,
Like they say, there is always a tomorrow, Tomorrow is the hope for a
loser,
Dreams should not die,
Jo bhi ho kal phir aayega
Well.. I jus read all d comments thr above.. Nirmal Shekhar has
pointed a anonymous sportperson n has not referred to any country..
The article is about d sportsmanship of any given athlete n not about
y India is not able to produce any athletes.. Please dont blame d
country for no reason jus bcz its not been able to produce any
athletes.. Our Hockey Team had 8 Olympic Gold Medals in d past.. Y we
all r alwez ready to blame d govt/country for no reason.. Jus luk at
ourselves.. have we encouraged anyone so far??? Then y to blame
others.. n please dont deviate frm d baseline of any article.. Thnx
Nirmal.. for d article.. :) Luv, GG
The Best Article of my Life.. No novel.. no story have been so deep for
me.. it was jus yest i thot abt d losers but wasnt able to go dis deep..
d thoughts expressed r so vivid n implicates true facets of daily life.
We jus go about our lives widout dreaming.. This is sumthng to learn frm
sports.. life never ends till u keep dreaming.. its never too late to
start anythng(dreaming) in life.. Media to learn frm dis very article..
A salute to d endless characters of life who dream to b d best.. :) Luv,
GG
was a motivational speech.. good going. Medal never counts , its your
participation with your hard work.
very well written!
Mr. Shekar!
I hope you know that that's an exhortation for losers only. With all due respect for
the Olympic spirit and the fact that only 3 can stand on the podium out of the
hundreds that begin, the idea is still to win.
And given the shady manner in which our Olympic committee works, there is more
than just a hint that pride of place in the team may sometimes be bought or
achieved not through sheer commitment but good connections.
Admittedly, a nation where sport is the poor cousin to science and the word
grassroots infrastructure more likely to be mistaken for a term out of the fodder
scandal report, the probability of producing an Olympic medallist or even an
athlete that qualifies for the final round ought to be a huge achievement.
There is however no substitute for victory! We need not send dozens of athletes
merely to make up numbers. Rather, we ought to send only those that have proven
themselves at other events and have shown real promise of medals!
Brilliantly written. I was able to relate to myself who play for pass time but always try to push myself everytime harder when I do so.
Thank you.
how very true!winning is certainly not everything. though cynics
will continue to rant'sour grapes' 'bad losers''find excuses for every
failure' etc etc. we must acknowledge the feat of these sports persons
who have defied the odds, broken rank and blazed a fresh trail.after
all how many well heeled parents have pushed their children to sports.
the poor of course have for it is a salvation and an escape from
poverty. then there is the aspect of genetics and environment which we
can not over come easily. also not to forget the kalmadis and his ilk
in sports who have sabotaged whatever our sports persons have
struggled and achieved against all the odds.
let us not despair .our day shall come. till then stop not ye the
lone torch bearer we are with you
I would like to reply to Mr. Virendra Gupta.
We are a billion plus country, but what is our planning towards sports. Can anyone tell me whether the Govt. of India or any State Govt. or Sports Authority of India or any sports body in the country has any plan to gromm our atletes for next 8-12 years.
That is where we are lacking. If we identify good talent of the age group of 8-12 years, provide them best of the training for next 8-12 years, they will bring the glory for the country in the Olympics to be held in 2020 and 2024.
A highly commendable article.
An epitaph for failure! It is not an acceptable excuse for a nation of 1.2 billion which has excelled in several other fields of competitive academic excellence but failed miserably at the altar of sporting honour namely the Olympics. The letter may console the legions of also rans at the Olympics who have participated living upto the spirit of Olympics. But is that all we wish to see in our life time? We have a neighbour equally populous if not more which though being a late entrant gone from strength to strength to get to the top of the heap. What have we to show? A bronze medal in Women's badminton besides a few more in shooting and we are very happy!. Nirmal Sekhar, you have been witness to several epic battles on the tennis court including Davis Cup matches in which India has won several stirring battles. It is better to say we are not good enough and do not have a sports culture to excel. It is a national shame not to be able to win a single Gold Medal at London so far.
Its not surprising we don't do good in sport. In fact, we are one
among the many hundreds of countries that don't win too many medals at
the Olympics. Having more people in India does not increase our
chances of winning a medal either. We are a country where sports (in
general, cricket being an exception) is not taken seriously at all.
That is the way we are. Not winning medals in Olympics is nothing to
be ashamed of. However, not being able to provide food, shelter,
clothing, education and health to the average Indian in everything to
be ashamed of.
This was a beautifully written, brilliantly articulated letter. Kudos,
Mr Shekar. While the urge to win should be and is a great motivator for
athletes, "failure" should not demean the honest effort undertaken in
hindsight.
Nice article. Reg. V Gupta's lament: The competition has become so
intense that no amount of input appears enough to produce a medal
winner. Totalitarian regimes, in order to exhibit their prowess to the
world, go about it very seriously. They catch promising youth before
they are even ten, separate them from their families and make them
grind through intensive training without any other distraction. The
developed West has had immense experience and a large number of self
motivated youth whom it helps train. In our country, the officialdom
corners a major part of the investment leaving sportspersons with less
motivation and encouragement. Kalmadi and the gate-crashing woman who
paraded herself along with our Olympics team are shameless examples.
Yes, what you said is right. Its not idealism or in-the-clouds stuff. Its plain truth. Thats the reason why its all the more relevant and this article a very beautiful one.
This article made me sick. Its this sort of defeatist drivel that has
caused our country to decay the way it has. It is clear from watching
the hockey team play that their goal was to make it to London. That
was it. There seemed to have been no intention to win. With this
attitude of good participation being paramount, rather than actually
wanting to win, we will never come close to gold. Its time to re-read
our Mahabharat and go over the part where Arjuna sees nothing but the
eye and have that similar laser like focus on winning a gold medal.
Unfortunately this defeatist attitude has become all pervasive.
Corruption running rampant? Its ok.
Pavements unusable, roads in disrepair? Its ok.
Millions shitting on the streets? Its ok
Millions dying for lack of clean water? Its ok.
Its only when we Indians accept that this sort of failure is
unacceptable, and demand better of ourselves, that we will rise to a
level where we can expect perfection in sports.
Nice!
Beautiful!!! This indeed is the 'Nirmal Shekar touch'..
There was joy, there was pain n there was inspiration..
Happy to read such an article from the master again...
Despite Nirmal Shekar's consoling words to those who don't make the podium, I can't help but wonder what must be going thru the minds of young Indian men and women watching the Olympics and seeing one country after another (small and large) come up to the podium but there is hardly anybody from their billion plus country. They must wonder why none of us is really there? What is wrong with our country? Are we not good enough? Why are we not good enough to compete with the best and win at least a few times? Hopefully, the country, its leadership, particularly sports leadership, can provide satisfactory answers to these young men and women. The rest of us -ordinary Indians - are also listening with intense curiosity.
Dear Mr. Shekar: today's was yet another sensitive and thoughtful column of yours. May I
express my deep appreciation of your columns, which are always full of style, scholarship,
and sensitivity, besides humor and words chosen with such appropriateness. Keep writing,
and maybe publish a collection of these essays.
Very well written, Nirmal Shekar. This letter should be an eye opener to all the Indian
sports reporters and editors as well. Most of the time the way they report on the
Indian sportspersons' achievements reflects their lack of depth in understanding
human achievements.
One of the best articles i have read.
It is true that life is not just about 'winning'. Putting in your best efforts is more
important than anything else. After that winning and losing become immaterial. The
same applies to other endeavors as it does to sports.
Please Email the Editor