Crude oil prices have fallen steeply, but are the benefits being passed on fully to the consumer?
Petrol prices have not declined as dramatically in India as global crude oil prices have in recent months, but then what is the scale of the disparity?
Consumers might think that they should be paying much less for petrol, after all the price of crude has halved but that of petrol has not. The retail prices of petrol are market-determined and have been so since mid-2010. Consumers have been used to consistent increases when crude oil prices have been on the uptrend. Should not the trend by markedly different when crude oil prices fall so steeply?
But the patterns of the fall in prices are disparate: the curve is quite steep for crude oil prices but not so for petrol. Why is that?
Monthly average price of crude oil/barrel in dollars (Indian Basket)
Month-end price (in rupees) of petrol/litre in Delhi at IOC outlets
The answer partly lies in the components that make up the price of petrol, particularly the markup and taxes. If these go up, the drop in petrol prices in the local market will not mirror the decline in global crude oil prices. (This comparison is meant to be indicative and does not take the latest prices into consideration.)
|Price component |
(HPCL, Rs/litre in Delhi)
|Feb 16, 2014||Jan 2, 2015||Share of total |
|Share of total |
|Price paid by oil companies to refineries||46.05||27.25||26.42,46.05||34.14,27.25||Steep fall |
|Price fixed at the dealer level||48.90||33.73||23.57,48.90||27.66,33.73||Oil companies |
increase mark-up price
|Specific excise duty||9.48||15.40||72.47,9.48||61.39,15.40||Excise duty too |
|Dealer commission||2.01||2.03||72.47,2.01||61.39,2.03||Virtually unchanged|
|Retail price||72.47||61.39||72.47,61.39||Prices down; but further fall neutralised by other components|
One crucial element in the make-up of petrol prices is the dealer level component, the mark-up. This component, which oil companies set, does not truly reflect the global price fall.
Compare this price with what the oil companies pay to the refineries. About a year ago the difference between the two was not much - about 3 rupees. By last month, this gap had widened - the refinery price was Rs 27.25 while the dealer price was Rs 33.73 - a difference of about 6 rupees.
The government is another player in pushing prices up or down - excise duty has gone up by about 6 rupees during this period. VAT and excise duty accounts for a significant part of the price.
So the bottom line is however much global oil prices fall, do not expect it to make that much of a difference when it comes to the retail price you pay for petrol. The situation is different, of course, when prices go up. Well if it is any consolation to consumers, this phenomenon is not unique to India, it is seen in other countries as well.
Charts: T. Ramachandran. Data source: Oil company websites; Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell
With the Swachh Bharat campaign, is India focussing its attention on the right things? »
What going it alone after 25 years shows about the strength about the BJP »
India has been a leading contributor to UN peacekeeping operations. And it has also paid the price for peacekeeping in terms of casualties. »
New data on commuting shows how money affects where you go to work »
The World Wildlife Fund's 10th edition of “The Living Planet Report” paints an ecological picture that shows the earth in a state of poor health. »