News » National

Updated: May 31, 2011 02:10 IST

Verdict reserved on Kanimozhi's bail plea

J. Venkatesan
Comment (2)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
DMK Rajyasabha MP Kanimozhi. File Photo
DMK Rajyasabha MP Kanimozhi. File Photo

The Delhi High Court on Monday reserved verdict on the bail petitions of DMK Member of Parliament Kanimozhi and promoter and director of Kalaignar TV, Sharad Kumar, accused and remanded in judicial custody in the 2G spectrum case.

Justice Ajit Bharihoke reserved verdict after hearing arguments from senior counsel Altaf Ahmed and R. Shanmugasundaram and counsel V.G. Pragasam for Ms. Kanimozhi and Mr. Kumar and senior counsel and special Public Prosecutor for the 2G scam case, U.U. Lalit, for the CBI.

Earlier, in response to the court directions issued on May 24, Mr. Lalit produced in a sealed cover a copy of the supplementary charge sheet explaining the role of the two accused in the scam. Opposing the bail, Mr. Lalit submitted that the accused had attempted to create a “smoke screen” by projecting the bribe trail of Rs.200 crore as a loan transaction.

Describing the transaction as “dubious,” he pointed out that no contemporaneous documents were executed by any of the companies which were part of the money transaction and maintained that the amount of Rs.200 crore received by Kalaignar TV was nothing but a bribe.

However, Mr. Ahmed asserted that the amount of Rs.200 crore Kalaignar TV received from M/s. Cineyug Pvt. Ltd. was purely a loan and not a bribe as claimed by the CBI in its charge sheet. Counsel argued that it was a transparent transaction and the amount, received through bank, was duly accounted for, repaid and there was nothing dubious in the transaction.

Mr. Ahmed read out the charge sheet and said it was not the role of the CBI to question the defence of the accused that the amount received was a loan and say that such a defence was inadequate. There was no material with the CBI to show that the amount received was not a loan.

On the CBI's submission that the bail pleas of five corporate honchos were dismissed by the High Court, Mr. Ahmed argued they stood on a different footing as they figured in the first charge sheet as licencees. But in the present case the petitioners were alleged to have received the proceeds of the crime and they had no role in the alleged crime. Since all the documents were with the CBI, there was no point in keeping the accused in jail.

In her appeal against the trial court's May 20 order refusing bail, Ms. Kanimozhi said, “She is innocent and has been falsely implicated in the case due to the biased media reporting concocted on the basis of conjectures and surmises. As a Member of Parliament and whip of the DMK party in the Rajya Sabha, she has to attend Parliament sessions and all-party meetings convened from time to time in connection with parliamentary business.”

95% of our politicians are corrupt nobody is worried about the poor and they become ministers to become rich, no one lives in a shoddy or an ordinary house, all of them have top class facility and enjoy the money of the citizens of India, This case should become an example to other politicians that they can languish in Tihar Jail, these jail birds should not be given bail and should be punished with out mercy,even some death row guys can be pardoned but not these people.

from:  guruprasad
Posted on: May 31, 2011 at 17:03 IST

Isn't is highly unusual to obtain an interest-free Rs. 200 crore loan nowadays? Surely it was done as a favor - to return the favor of being granted a 2G license by Raja/DMK. The openness of this financial transaction (now being used as a defence by Kanimozhi) indicates the impunity with which corruption takes place in high levels in India. They never thought it would be scrutinized.

from:  S. Siva
Posted on: May 31, 2011 at 11:04 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor

Tamil Nadu

Andhra Pradesh

Other States






Recent Article in National

61 climbers rescued by Army’s expedition team

An Indian army expedition team on Sunday rescued over 61 climbers and retrieved 19 bodies from Mount Everest after the devastating ea... »