"Why is the haste in starting super-specialty hospital?"

February 06, 2013 02:27 am | Updated August 05, 2016 01:51 am IST - CHENNAI

Chennai, 03-08-2011: A view of the proposed Secretariat complex built by the DMK government on Anna Salai. The complex is designed by German-based architect company GMP, a united venture of Meinhard von Gerkan and Volkwin Marg based at Berlin. The construction of the new assembly was entrusted to East Coast Constructions and Industries Limited.With its highly visible dome, the complex has four circular courtyards, and the design echoes the structural features of Dravidian temple complexes in south India. The dome is modelled on the Draupadi Ratha at Mamallapuram and resembles the top of a Tamil temple car. The Assembly-Secretariat complex has two blocks Ñ Block ÔA' and Block ÔB.' The seven-storey Block 'A' houses the Legislative Assembly Hall and the Assembly Secretariat, besides the offices of the Governor, the Chief Minister, Ministers, the Chief Secretary and certain core departments such as Finance and Home. The initial estimated cost of construction of this block was about INR 4255.7 million.In December 2009, work on the construction of the seven-storey Block ÔB' started. With a initial cost estimate of INR 2795.6 million, the work was expected to be completed in 18 months. This block will house a host of departments.The plinth area figures of Block ÔA' and Block ÔB' are 930,297 sq. ft. (86,460 sq. m) and 743,900 sq. ft., respectively. The dome is cast in stone and closed with glass and will function as the principal iconic element. A park has been created on the 5th floor of the Secretariat where the upper house is situated. Initially, the total cost was put at around INR 7,020 millionÑthe cost of construction of Block A was INR 4255.7 million and that of Block B was INR 2795.6 million. The revised cost as of February 2011, however, is  10,920 million.  Photo:S_R_Raghunathan

Chennai, 03-08-2011: A view of the proposed Secretariat complex built by the DMK government on Anna Salai. The complex is designed by German-based architect company GMP, a united venture of Meinhard von Gerkan and Volkwin Marg based at Berlin. The construction of the new assembly was entrusted to East Coast Constructions and Industries Limited.With its highly visible dome, the complex has four circular courtyards, and the design echoes the structural features of Dravidian temple complexes in south India. The dome is modelled on the Draupadi Ratha at Mamallapuram and resembles the top of a Tamil temple car. The Assembly-Secretariat complex has two blocks Ñ Block ÔA' and Block ÔB.' The seven-storey Block 'A' houses the Legislative Assembly Hall and the Assembly Secretariat, besides the offices of the Governor, the Chief Minister, Ministers, the Chief Secretary and certain core departments such as Finance and Home. The initial estimated cost of construction of this block was about INR 4255.7 million.In December 2009, work on the construction of the seven-storey Block ÔB' started. With a initial cost estimate of INR 2795.6 million, the work was expected to be completed in 18 months. This block will house a host of departments.The plinth area figures of Block ÔA' and Block ÔB' are 930,297 sq. ft. (86,460 sq. m) and 743,900 sq. ft., respectively. The dome is cast in stone and closed with glass and will function as the principal iconic element. A park has been created on the 5th floor of the Secretariat where the upper house is situated. Initially, the total cost was put at around INR 7,020 millionÑthe cost of construction of Block A was INR 4255.7 million and that of Block B was INR 2795.6 million. The revised cost as of February 2011, however, is 10,920 million. Photo:S_R_Raghunathan

The National Green Tribunal on Tuesday pulled up the State government for commencing a multi-super-specialty hospital at the Omandurar Estate on Anna Salai even while an appeal against the environment clearance given for the conversion was pending before it.

The High Court and Supreme Court had already dismissed petitions challenging the decision of the present government to convert the Assembly-cum-Secretariat complex into an advanced hospital for super-specialties, declining to interfere with a policy matter.

On Tuesday, the National Green Tribunal, Southern Bench, comprising judicial member Justice M.Chockalingam, and expert member Prof. R. Nagendran, heard an appeal against the environmental clearance granted by a State-level authority for the proposed conversion.

Interim injunction

M. Seenivasagan, counsel for the appellant, R.Veeramani, moved an application before the Bench seeking an interim injunction restraining the State government from carrying on any process of alteration or modification in the structure.

Mr. Justice Chockalingam said newspaper reports stated that the government had commenced the super-specialty hospital even while the matter was pending before the tribunal.

He told Advocate General A. Navaneethakrishnan: “What was the haste for converting the building into a super-specialty hospital? The government commenced its activities on January 30 itself while the matter is pending before this Tribunal. We expected fair play. What do you propose to do now except saying there was no stay? Why should you not wait for the result of the appeal?”

Referral hospital

The AG replied that it was a referral hospital. “It is like a dry run.” He submitted that a small area was cleared for the purpose and it was not the entire area. There was no adverse environmental impact.

Unwilling to accept the argument, Mr. Justice Chockalingam said: It seems that your people don’t care for law. Do they think this court is powerless or that this Tribunal is defunct?”

He noted that if the appeal was allowed and the Tribunal said the works will have to be stopped, the works should be stopped.

The AG explained that only a board was fixed at the premises to create awareness to the poor people. “There is no full-fledged hospital. It is only an outpatient clinic,” he added.

After hearing his submission, the Bench directed the State government to file a counter on Wednesday. “If necessary, we may go to the spot after the counter is filed.”

Originally, the DMK government constructed the new Secretariat-cum-Assembly building at the Omandurar Government Estate.

After coming to power in 2011, the AIADMK government took policy decision to convert the structure into a super-specialty hospital. It was challenged in the Madras High Court by an advocate R.Veeramani. In the meantime, he also preferred an appeal before National Green Tribunal challenging the State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA)’s environmental clearance dated May16 last year for conversion.

In January, the High Court dismissed the petitions.

Upholding that order, the Supreme Court on January 31 stated that reliefs sought by the “petitioner have to be pursued in some other forum” where the subject matter can be gone into.” Hence the subject matter is now pending before the Tribunal.

0 / 0
Sign in to unlock member-only benefits!
  • Access 10 free stories every month
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products
Sign in

Comments

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.

We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.