National » Other States

Updated: October 20, 2012 18:10 IST

Mamata ‘shares’ her anger on Facebook over Jairam letter

Comment (3)   ·   print   ·   T  T  
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee
PTI West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee today took serious umbrage at Union Minister Jairam Ramesh writing to her that the ‘brain-dead government in Delhi’ was sensitive to the needs of people of the State.

“Incidentally, may I add that this reflects how sensitive the so-called “brain-dead government” in Delhi is to the needs of the people of West Bengal”, Mr Ramesh, the Union Minister for Rural Development said in his letter informing Ms Banerjee of the release of the fourth instalment of MGNREGA funds amounting to Rs 601.2 crore for 2012/13.

He also informed her that with this, West Bengal had received a total of 2655.2 crore till now.

Drawing attention to a paragraph in the letter which referred to the “brain-dead government in Delhi”, Ms Banerjee said on her Facebook page, “the statement is clearly vindictive, unethical and unconstitutional”.

“I am really stunned to see that a Union Minister can write a distasteful statement like this to a State Government. This creates a bad precedence and adds stigma to healthy democratic fibre of our country,” Ms Banerjee said.

“I am sharing a copy of the letter dated 19.10.12 received from the Union Minister of Rural Development. You would be shocked to see the attitude of the Central Government towards the State of West Bengal,” she said.

She reminded Mr Ramesh that under Central government schemes like MGNREGA, Central funds were released to all States for implementation of the scheme.

“Releasing funds for the Central schemes is not a matter of charity. This is a pure governmental activity,” Ms Banerjee, the Trianmool Congress chief said.

Ms Banerjee, a former UPA ally said “In a federal structure, the Central Government and the State Governments perform their roles as per the Constitution in public interest. Good and effective governance deserves a clear delineation of governmental activity and political activity.”

I am not sure if The Chief Minister is unncessarily locking horns with Shri Jairam Ramesh for his expression "brain-dead government in delhi". Shri Ramesh is not pointing to the State of West Bengal at all through his expression. It would be more appropriate if she shared what the state government had written to him for which the expression was used. Also, it is true that funds released to the state government are not on charity basis, however, his job being Union Minister of MRD is not just disbursing funds as requested by the state, but also to see the rightful use of those funds in the state, which I think would have been his intention. The chief minister should not read too much into the expression and involve in mudslinging.

from:  Dr Nagarjun Konduru
Posted on: Oct 20, 2012 at 21:21 IST

Arrogance and treating the Central Funds distrubution to states for its
political purpose the congress in Center has attacked the foundations of
Federal structure that we have not seen even Indira Gandhi and Rajiv
Gandhi and Narsimha Rao ever resorted.

Sonia and MMS have made serious damage

from:  Venkat G
Posted on: Oct 20, 2012 at 20:49 IST

While one may mock at her, truth is the scheme is the brainchild of the Congress with Mrs. Gandhi taking credit and those funds are allocated to all states based on their performance! His remarks are indeed unfortunate and in bad taste!

from:  M Ikariam
Posted on: Oct 20, 2012 at 18:28 IST
This article is closed for comments.
Please Email the Editor





Recent Article in Other States

Goa doctor, wife convicted for child labour

They were sentenced to three years' simple imprisonment for employing two minor girls as maids at their residence. »